Economic Climate

Economic Competitiveness Index

2021 · Report · 28 PDF pages

← Research Finder

Report text

Text extracted from the original PDF. Tables, footnotes, and reading order can differ. Check the PDF before quoting. Page numbers below refer to PDF viewer pages.

PDF page 1

ECONOMIC COMPETITIVENESS INDEX 2021 Taking Stock of Oklahoma’s Competitive Position

Open PDF at page 1 ↗
PDF page 2

FROM THE EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR Recent years have seen a paradigm shift in the thinking of Oklahoma’s leaders. We now speak of becoming a Top Ten state, not content in the old “Oklahoma is OK” motto. Thankfully, our state is aiming higher than just “okay.” But how are we doing? If Oklahoma’s plan for economic growth begins and ends only with unfocused talk of Top Ten—and celebration when we reach that mark in any category, regardless of importance—we will fall short. To have a dynamic, prosperous Oklahoma full of opportunity for her citizens, we need a thorough—and honest—assessment of where we currently stand. Only then can our plans align with our goals. That is the purpose of this report. This Economic Competitiveness Index—the first of what will be an annual report—evaluates Oklahoma’s competitive position compared to the nation, region, and a set of peer states sharing various characteristics. It does so across metrics that, together, are highly impactful on prosperity and growth. It is important to note what this index is and what it is not. The ECI is intended as a tool for policymakers. The report measures Oklahoma’s economic competitiveness based on key metrics that are indicative of public policy choices, minimizing characteristics of the economy that are baked-in. Some states have coastlines and ports, some have large populations densely packed into small geography, others have tiny populations spread across massive territory. These characteristics certainly matter to economic growth and business climate, but no change in state law can fundamentally alter them. As such, comparing the incredibly diverse United States on such measures is of limited value to policymakers. Worse, it lets policymakers off the hook. It is far too easy for state policymakers to explain away uncompetitive economic policy as an unfair comparison of apples to oranges. This Index facilitates no such defeatist thinking. Instead, it is squarely aimed at economic variables that can be improved through sound policy choices. It also doesn’t pull punches. The uncomfortable truth is that Oklahoma does not rank very well in far too many categories. But problems cannot be addressed until they are clearly identified. And here is the exciting part: these things can be fixed. This report allows us to train our enthusiasm for improvement on the things that really matter. With good public policy targeted at the right problems, there is no reason to stop at Top Ten. We should strive for First Place. BEN LEPAK Executive Director State Chamber Research Foundation 2

Open PDF at page 2 ↗
PDF page 3

Chief Executive Magazine Best & Worst States for Business 28TH USA Today / Wall Street 24/7 39TH CNBC - America’s Top States for Business 32ND Forbes Best States for Business 24TH US News Best States for Business 37TH Measurement National Rank CUMULATIVE GDP GROWTH (10 years) 16% 21st of 50 PER CAPITA PERSONAL INCOME $48,413.67 29th of 50 CUMULATIVE DOMESTIC MIGRATION (10 years) 41,279 16th of 50 UNEMPLOYMENT RATE (June 2021) 3.70% 8th of 50 LABOR PARTICIPATION RATE (June 2021) 60.70% 34th of 50 CUMULATIVE NON-FARM EMPLOYMENT GROWTH (10 years) 10.39% 29th of 50 ECONOMIC VITAL SIGNS OKLAHOMA’S REPUTATION 3

Open PDF at page 3 ↗
PDF page 4

ECONOMIC COMPETITIVENESS INDEX NATION AT-A-GLANCE NATIONAL RANK LAGGING LAGGING LAGGING REGIONAL RANK OF 7 OF 14 PEER STATES RANK 36TH 5TH 10TH HIGHLY COMPETITIVE 1. Utah 2. South Dakota 3. Florida 4. Colorado 5. North Carolina 6. North Dakota 7. New Hampshire 8. Texas 9. Massachusetts 10. Washington 11. Virginia 12. Delaware 13. Idaho 14. Nevada 15. Tennessee 16. Arizona 17. Nebraska 18. Georgia 19. Indiana 20. Wyoming 21. Minnesota 22. Oregon 23. Wisconsin 24. Connecticut 25. Maryland 26. Montana 27. Michigan 28. Pennsylvania 29. Iowa 30. Alaska 31. Ohio 32. Kansas 33. South Carolina 34. Missouri 35. Vermont 36. Oklahoma 37. Rhode Island 38. Maine 39. New Jersey 40. Kentucky 41. Hawaii 42. New Mexico 43. Arkansas 44. New York 45. Illinois 46. California 47. Alabama 48. Louisiana 49. Mississippi 50. West Virginia OKLAHOMA 4

Open PDF at page 4 ↗
PDF page 5

NATIONAL RANKINGS OVERVIEW Overall Competitiveness Tax Competitiveness Legal Climate Workforce Government Encroachment Infrastructure Rank Score State Rank Rank Rank Rank Rank 1 10 Utah 8 18 5 21 2 2 9.831785584 South Dakota 2 9 13 15 35 3 9.512081761 Colorado 21 17 2 18 29 4 9.273960388 North Dakota 17 7 9 29 5 5 8.976278678 Massachusetts 34 26 1 3 34 6 8.838692251 Florida 4 49 28 10 4 7 8.747929832 New Hampshire 6 22 6 7 26 8 8.740561341 Washington 16 29 8 30 19 9 8.709226989 North Carolina 10 8 30 27 15 10 8.706264046 Texas 11 38 32 25 17 11 8.579578268 Idaho 20 4 18 20 20 12 8.523837998 Delaware 13 1 36 17 1 13 8.206042951 Virginia 26 23 7 19 18 14 8.136613492 Nevada 7 30 41 1 6 15 7.785998314 Arizona 24 16 35 13 10 16 7.718313568 Georgia 31 39 34 5 3 17 7.69943414 Wyoming 1 6 12 50 43 18 7.667487452 Indiana 9 31 25 9 25 19 7.457660219 Tennessee 18 35 39 12 9 20 7.422754858 Minnesota 46 24 4 8 22 21 7.317894114 Nebraska 28 15 15 36 13 22 7.077870134 Oregon 15 20 19 44 7 23 7.054967316 Maryland 44 28 10 11 8 24 7.053574204 Montana 5 13 17 31 47 25 7.037650648 Connecticut 47 5 11 4 38 26 6.974255394 Wisconsin 25 14 16 26 30 27 6.558943408 Michigan 14 32 38 6 39 28 6.369473354 Pennsylvania 27 36 20 2 21 29 6.115441412 Alaska 3 2 40 49 45 30 6.043547878 Kansas 35 27 21 35 16 31 6.010654683 Iowa 40 19 24 41 14 32 5.793387539 Ohio 39 34 29 32 12 33 5.533090299 Vermont 43 10 14 33 28 34 5.402408069 South Carolina 33 37 43 37 33 35 5.244820241 Missouri 12 44 37 16 42 36 5.156941351 Oklahoma 30 25 42 40 24 37 5.019792002 Maine 29 3 31 24 49 38 4.755962338 Rhode Island 37 21 33 14 48 39 4.682737616 Kentucky 19 42 44 28 11 40 4.245466179 New Jersey 50 41 3 23 36 41 3.824358068 Hawaii 38 11 27 42 46 42 3.798520262 New York 48 40 26 39 31 43 3.570186105 New Mexico 23 12 45 47 37 44 3.288459302 California 49 47 23 43 40 45 3.272570625 Arkansas 45 33 47 46 32 46 2.947884425 Alabama 41 43 50 38 23 47 2.499777445 Illinois 36 50 22 22 27 48 1.415015355 Mississippi 32 45 46 48 44 49 1.385022939 Louisiana 42 48 48 34 41 50 1 West Virginia 22 46 49 45 50

Open PDF at page 5 ↗
PDF page 6

KEY FINDINGS: • Despite cuts to tax rates in recent years, Oklahoma’s overall tax structure is uncompetitive nationally, regionally, and compared to peers. • Oklahoma’s individual income tax ranks in the bottom half of states (30th) due to a middle-of-the- pack rate (not low, despite common perception), disincentives to capital investment, an un-flat rate structure not indexed to inflation, and a marriage penalty. • Oklahoma’s combined state and local sales tax is relatively high and has a narrow tax base, leading to the state’s worst tax subcategory ranking (39th). • Oklahoma’s property tax ranks in the bottom half of states—despite some of the lowest tax rates in the nation—due to its levying of various taxes that do not exist in other states, such as a tax on business tangible property, a capital stock tax (though, capped), and the highly distortionary inventory tax, which few states continue to impose. These taxes discourage business growth and relocation to Oklahoma. NATIONAL RANK LAGGING LAGGING LAGGING REGIONAL RANK OF 7 OF 14 PEER STATES RANK 30TH 5TH 9TH INDIVIDUAL INCOME TAX CORPORATE TAX SALES TAX 33RD 11TH UNEMPLOYMENT TAX PROPERTY TAX 39TH 1ST 29TH TAX COMPETITIVENESS 6

Open PDF at page 6 ↗
PDF page 7

REGION State Regional Rank National Rank Texas 1 11 Missouri 2 12 Colorado 3 21 New Mexico 4 23 Oklahoma 5 30 Kansas 6 35 Arkansas 7 45 PEER STATES State Peer Rank National Rank Nevada 1 7 Utah 2 8 Indiana 3 9 Missouri 4 12 Oregon 5 15 Tennessee 6 18 Kentucky 7 19 Colorado 8 21 Oklahoma 9 30 South Carolina 10 33 Kansas 11 35 Iowa 12 40 Alabama 13 41 Louisiana 14 42 Arkansas 15 45 1. Wyoming 2. South Dakota 3. Alaska 4. Florida 5. Montana 6. New Hampshire 7. Nevada 8. Utah 9. Indiana 10. North Carolina 11. Texas 12. Missouri 13. Delaware 14. Michigan 15. Oregon 16. Washington 17. North Dakota 18. Tennessee 19. Kentucky 20. Idaho 21. Colorado 22. West Virginia 23. New Mexico 24. Arizona 25. Wisconsin 26. Virginia 27. Pennsylvania 28. Nebraska 29. Maine 30. Oklahoma 31. Georgia 32. Mississippi 33. South Carolina 34. Massachusetts 35. Kansas 36. Illinois 37. Rhode Island 38. Hawaii 39. Ohio 40. Iowa 41. Alabama 42. Louisiana 43. Vermont 44. Maryland 45. Arkansas 46. Minnesota 47. Connecticut 48. New York 49. California 50. New Jersey HIGHLY COMPETITIVE NATION 7

Open PDF at page 7 ↗
PDF page 8

KEY FINDINGS: • At 25th nationally, Oklahoma’s Legal Climate ranks well in areas where policymakers have focused in recent years, but warning flags are on the horizon. • Significantly, Oklahoma’s overall ranking is held by its scores on the quality of its trial and appellate judges. Oklahoma ranks 25th in Quality of Appellate Courts, 30th in Trial Judge Impartiality, and 31st in Trial Judge Competence. This strongly indicates a need to improve the process for selecting judges. • A collection of lawsuit reform measures in recent years have earned the state a number 10 ranking in overall treatment of tort and contract litigation, but recent actions by Oklahoma courts to undo these reforms will likely lead to a worse ranking if left unaddressed. • Oklahoma scores a 1st place ranking in Jury Fairness, reflecting a culture in the state that no doubt has been influenced by the business community’s push for tort reform. NATIONAL RANK LAGGING LAGGING LAGGING REGIONAL RANK OF 7 OF 14 PEER STATES RANK 25TH 3RD 5TH QUALITY OF APPELLATE COURTS JURY FAIRNESS QUALITY OF TRIAL JUDGES 25TH 1ST LEGAL SERVICES SHARE OF PRIVATE ECONOMY DAMAGES CAP TREATMENT OF TORT & CONTRACT LITIGATION 31ST 21ST NO 10TH LEGAL CLIMATE 8

Open PDF at page 8 ↗
PDF page 9

HIGHLY COMPETITIVE 1. Delaware 2. Alaska 3. Maine 4. Idaho 5. Connecticut 6. Wyoming 7. North Dakota 8. North Carolina 9. South Dakota 10. Vermont 11. Hawaii 12. New Mexico 13. Montana 14. Wisconsin 15. Nebraska 16. Arizona 17. Colorado 18. Utah 19. Iowa 20. Oregon 21. Rhode Island 22. New Hampshire 23. Virginia 24. Minnesota 25. Oklahoma 26. Massachusetts 27. Kansas 28. Maryland 29. Washington 30. Nevada 31. Indiana 32. Michigan 33. Arkansas 34. Ohio 35. Tennessee 36. Pennsylvania 37. South Carolina 38. Texas 39. Georgia 40. New York 41. New Jersey 42. Kentucky 43. Alabama 44. Missouri 45. Mississippi 46. West Virginia 47. California 48. Louisiana 49. Florida 50. Illinois NATION REGION State Regional Rank National Rank New Mexico 1 12 Colorado 2 17 Oklahoma 3 25 Kansas 4 27 Arkansas 5 33 Texas 6 38 Missouri 7 44 PEER STATES State Peer Rank National Rank Wisconsin 1 14 Colorado 2 17 Utah 3 18 Iowa 4 19 Oklahoma 5 25 Kansas 6 27 Nevada 7 30 Indiana 8 31 Arkansas 9 33 Tennessee 10 35 Kentucky 11 42 Alabama 12 43 Missouri 13 44 Mississippi 14 45 Arkansas 15 45 9

Open PDF at page 9 ↗
PDF page 10

KEY FINDINGS: • Oklahoma’s labor force participation rate ranks 34th in the nation, a worrying sign for the competitiveness of the state’s workforce. • The poor performance of Oklahoma’s K12 school system continues to hold back economic growth, ranking 41st in the nation in 4th and 8th grade reading and math scores. • Oklahoma ranks 49th in STEM and STEM-related degrees held by working age adults. The state also scores poorly in other educational attainment metrics, at 46th in bachelor’s degree attainment and 33rd in attainment of high school diploma or equivalent. • The relatively high individual productivity of Oklahoma workers (16th in the nation) is the only bright note that keeps the state from competing with West Virginia and Alabama for the status of worst state in the nation for workforce. NATIONAL RANK LAGGING LAGGING LAGGING REGIONAL RANK OF 7 OF 14 PEER STATES RANK 42ND 5TH 10TH QUALITY OF K-12 EDUCATION SYSTEM EDUCATIONAL ATTAINMENT QUALITY OF LABOR SUPPLY 41ST 46TH 35TH WORKFORCE 10

Open PDF at page 10 ↗
PDF page 11

HIGHLY COMPETITIVE 1. Massachusetts 2. Colorado 3. North Dakota 4. Utah 5. New Jersey 6. Minnesota 7. Washington 8. Virginia 9. Maryland 10. New Hampshire 11. Nebraska 12. Connecticut 13. South Dakota 14. Wyoming 15. Wisconsin 16. Oregon 17. Idaho 18. Vermont 19. Montana 20. California 21. Kansas 22. Pennsylvania 23. Illinois 24. New York 25. Hawaii 26. Texas 27. Iowa 28. Indiana 29. Ohio 30. Florida 31. North Carolina 32. Rhode Island 33. Georgia 34. Maine 35. Alaska 36. Arizona 37. Missouri 38. Delaware 39. Michigan 40. Tennessee 41. Nevada 42. Oklahoma 43. South Carolina 44. Kentucky 45. New Mexico 46. Mississippi 47. Louisiana 48. Arkansas 49. Alabama 50. West Virginia NATION REGION State Regional Rank National Rank Colorado 1 2 Kansas 2 21 Texas 3 26 Missouri 4 37 Oklahoma 5 42 New Mexico 6 45 Arkansas 7 48 PEER STATES State Peer Rank National Rank Colorado 1 2 Utah 2 4 Wisconsin 3 15 Kansas 4 21 Iowa 5 27 Indiana 6 28 Missouri 7 37 Tennessee 8 40 Nevada 9 41 Oklahoma 10 42 Kentucky 11 44 Mississippi 12 46 Arkansas 13 48 Alabama 14 49 Arkansas 15 45 11

Open PDF at page 11 ↗
PDF page 12

KEY FINDINGS: • Ranking 40th overall, Oklahoma’s private sector is significantly crowded out by the creep of state and local government. • Oklahoma’s score suffers from a comparatively heavy regulatory burden (27th of 50 states), a large share of its population employed by state and local government (32nd of 50), and a high proportion of its GDP attributable to state and local government spending (46th of 50). • Even when adjusted for its low population density and/or large land area—which might indicate a need for relatively larger state and local government—Oklahoma still ranks uncompetitively in the Government Encroachment component. NATIONAL RANK LAGGING LAGGING LAGGING REGIONAL RANK OF 7 OF 14 PEER STATES RANK 40TH 5TH 11TH SHARE OF WORKFORCE EMPLOYED BY GOVERNMENT SHARE OF GDP ATTRIBUTABLE TO STATE & LOCAL GOV. REGULATORY BURDEN 32ND 46TH 27TH GOVERNMENT ENCROACHMENT ON PRIVATE INDUSTRY 12

Open PDF at page 12 ↗
PDF page 13

HIGHLY COMPETITIVE NATION 1. Nevada 2. Pennsylvania 3. Massachusetts 4. Connecticut 5. Georgia 6. Michigan 7. New Hampshire 8. Minnesota 9. Indiana 10. Florida 11. Maryland 12. Tennessee 13. Arizona 14. Rhode Island 15. South Dakota 16. Missouri 17. Delaware 18. Colorado 19. Virginia 20. Idaho 21. Utah 22. Illinois 23. New Jersey 24. Maine 25. Texas 26. Wisconsin 27. North Carolina 28. Kentucky 29. North Dakota 30. Washington 31. Montana 32. Ohio 33. Vermont 34. Louisiana 35. Kansas 36. Nebraska 37. South Carolina 38. Alabama 39. New York 40. Oklahoma 41. Iowa 42. Hawaii 43. California 44. Oregon 45. West Virginia 46. Arkansas 47. New Mexico 48. Mississippi 49. Alaska 50. Wyoming REGION State Regional Rank National Rank Missouri 1 16 Colorado 2 18 Texas 3 25 Kansas 4 35 Oklahoma 5 40 Arkansas 6 46 New Mexico 7 47 PEER STATES State Peer Rank National Rank Nevada 1 1 Indiana 2 9 Tennessee 3 12 Missouri 4 16 Colorado 5 18 Utah 6 21 Wisconsin 7 26 Kentucky 8 28 Kansas 9 35 Alabama 10 38 Oklahoma 11 40 Iowa 12 41 Arkansas 13 46 Mississippi 14 48 Arkansas 15 45 13

Open PDF at page 13 ↗
PDF page 14

KEY FINDINGS: • Oklahoma ranks 9th of 50 in transportation infrastructure, largely due to concentrated investment and planning in recent years focused on addressing road and bridge deficiencies through the 8-year Plan. • Oklahoma continues to enjoy extremely low electric power costs, scoring a number 2 national ranking in this category. Overall, Oklahoma’s electric power infrastructure scores well with a number 15 ranking nationally. • Oklahoma still has ground to make up in broadband, particularly with regard to access to high- speed internet in rural areas. NATIONAL RANK LAGGING LAGGING LAGGING REGIONAL RANK OF 7 OF 14 PEER STATES RANK 24TH 3RD 8TH ELECTRIC POWER INFRASTRUCTURE BROADBAND INFRASTRUCTURE TRANSPORTATION INFRASTRUCTURE 15TH 43RD 9TH INFRASTRUCTURE 14

Open PDF at page 14 ↗
PDF page 15

HIGHLY COMPETITIVE 1. Delaware 2. Utah 3. Georgia 4. Florida 5. North Dakota 6. Nevada 7. Oregon 8. Maryland 9. Tennessee 10. Arizona 11. Kentucky 12. Ohio 13. Nebraska 14. Iowa 15. North Carolina 16. Kansas 17. Texas 18. Virginia 19. Washington 20. Idaho 21. Pennsylvania 22. Minnesota 23. Alabama 24. Oklahoma 25. Indiana 26. New Hampshire 27. Illinois 28. Vermont 29. Colorado 30. Wisconsin 31. New York 32. Arkansas 33. South Carolina 34. Massachusetts 35. South Dakota 36. New Jersey 37. New Mexico 38. Connecticut 39. Michigan 40. California 41. Louisiana 42. Missouri 43. Wyoming 44. Mississippi 45. Alaska 46. Hawaii 47. Montana 48. Rhode Island 49. Maine 50. West Virginia NATION REGION State Regional Rank National Rank Kansas 1 16 Texas 2 17 Oklahoma 3 24 Colorado 4 29 Arkansas 5 32 New Mexico 6 37 Missouri 7 42 PEER STATES State Peer Rank National Rank Utah 1 2 Nevada 2 6 Tennessee 3 9 Kentucky 4 11 Iowa 5 14 Kansas 6 16 Alabama 7 23 Oklahoma 8 24 Indiana 9 25 Colorado 10 29 Wisconsin 11 30 Arkansas 12 32 Missouri 13 42 Mississippi 14 44 Arkansas 15 45 15

Open PDF at page 15 ↗
PDF page 16

Ranking the competitiveness of 50 very different states presents many challenges, and no index is without flaws. Recognizing this reality, the ECI was developed with several key features in mind. First, the ECI is focused on Oklahoma, and meant as a tool to aid Oklahoma policymakers. This Oklahoma-centric approach modestly influenced both the selection and weighting of the variables (though variables were largely chosen and weighted according to their correlation with economic growth). Second, the touchstone of the ECI, as the name suggests, is competitiveness. Wherever possible, the states are measured against each other, not in a vacuum. Therefore, a state receiving the lowest score in a given category does not indicate the state is the worst it is possible to be on that measure, but rather that it rates worse than every other state. Likewise, states receiving first place rankings in a given category still have room for improvement, but, for now, outpace the other forty-nine. This relative scoring approach improves the ECI’s explanatory power for policymakers because it points to areas where there is great divergence among states. Categories that feature little significant difference between the states likely do not have much impact on business decisions (at least not when it comes to location), but categories (such as the individual income tax) in which states vary greatly likely do heavily weigh in business decision-making. Lastly, the ECI attempts to only include variables that can be accurately measured, and only those that touch some important aspect of state public policy. Wherever possible, data was controlled for factors more influenced by federal policy than state policy (for example, state and local employees, not all government employees, are measured to determine rankings as to share of workforce in the public sector). It also seeks to avoid the double counting of particularly pronounced aspects of a state’s economy. This is admittedly difficult to accomplish, but where possible double-counting was avoided. Ephemeral categories such as “quality of life” and categories prone to double-counting (i.e., cost of doing business) were excluded entirely from the ECI as they are more likely to distort the Index’s findings than to shed light. With these principles in mind, the ECI has a hierarchical structure that results in an overall Economic Competitiveness Score and Ranking of all 50 states. The ECI is composed of five major Components (Tax Competitiveness, Legal Climate, Workforce, Government Encroachment on Private Industry, and Infrastructure). Each Component consists of several subcomponents, calculated across nearly 40 variables. Scores and rankings for the subcomponents are combined to produce an overall Component score and ranking, which are then combined to yield an overall ECI score and ranking for each state. Throughout the calculation of scores and rankings, data is normalized as appropriate, facilitating comparison of different types of data. Weights for subcomponents and variables are generally determined based on the standard deviations of the data, emphasizing factors where there is wider divergence among states, i.e., facilitating analysis of competitiveness in areas that matter to economic decisions. NOTES ON METHODOLOGY 16

Open PDF at page 16 ↗
PDF page 17

TAX COMPETITIVENESS - HOW IT’S MEASURED & WHY IT MATTERS: • The ECI measures states’ tax competitiveness across five components: (1) Individual Income Tax, (2) Corporate Tax, (3) Sales Tax, (4) Property Tax, and (5) Unemployment Insurance Tax. • Each tax category is scored according to both the rates charged and the composition of applicable tax base. In general, states that tax broad bases at low rates score better in the tax component of the ECI, and states that forego assessing a given tax altogether score favorably in that subcategory. • The Tax Competitiveness component of the ECI borrows heavily from the Tax Foundation’s 2021 State Business Tax Climate Index, and does not account for recent tax changes enacted but not yet in effect (such as Oklahoma’s recent individual and corporate rate cuts). LEGAL CLIMATE - HOW IT’S MEASURED AND WHY IT MATTERS: • The ECI measures states’ Legal Climate across six components: (1) Quality of Appellate Review, (2) Quality of Trial Judges (both fairness and competence), (3) Jury Friendliness, (4) Overall Treatment of Tort and Contract Litigation, (5) Size of Legal Services Industry (as a share of private economy), and (6) (liability predictability, i.e. whether noneconomic or punitive damages are capped by law). • Quality of appellate and trial courts are essentially a measure of the quality of judges on the bench, which is highly dependent on the method of selection the state employs. This is a policy decision with far-reaching impact, so it is weighted accordingly. • Jury friendliness is partly (possibly largely) cultural and thus not as responsive to policy determinations, so it receives a lower weight. However, jury friendliness does, in part, reflect statutory rules governing items submitted to juries, so it is included in the index. • Size of legal services industry is a proxy variable for how litigious a state is and how costly legal compliance with state law is. Stated simply, legal services eats up an ever larger share of the private economy in states where it is highly profitable to be engaged in the practice of law, i.e., states where legal costs to businesses are high. • Liability predictability is measured by whether a state caps noneconomic damages in state law. No weight is given to how high or low the cap is, ensuring that the variable measures certainty and is not distorted. Per capita tort costs are not included for a similar reason: they may be skewed by a variety of factors (such as the existence of a relatively dangerous industry) that are not helpful to policymakers. WORKFORCE - HOW IT’S MEASURED AND WHY IT MATTERS: • The ECI measures states’ Workforce Competitiveness across three components: (1) Quality of K12 Education System, (2) Educational Attainment, and (3) Quality of Labor Supply. Within each are a number of variables, weighted according to importance. • The quality of a state’s K12 education system is based solely on National Assessment of Educational Process scores for 4th and 8th grade reading and math. Referred to as “the Nation’s Report Card,” NAEP is the gold standard for measuring the end-product the education system produces, and is the only true, objective measure of educational quality. • Educational attainment scores states’ on the share of their working age populations achieving a high school diploma, a bachelor’s degree, and a STEM-related degree. • The quality of a state’s labor supply, strongly correlated to economic growth, is calculated based on participation in the labor force (and contributors non-participation), worker productivity, and the existence of a right to work law. 17

Open PDF at page 17 ↗
PDF page 18

GOVERNMENT ENCROACHMENT - HOW IT’S MEASURED AND WHY IT MATTERS: • As the size of government grows it begins to crowd out private investment, slowing overall economic growth. Moreover, certain types of encroachment—such as heavy regulation or government competition within industries—impose substantial costs on business that slow economic growth. • The ECI measures states’ Government Encroachment across three subcomponents: (1) share of the labor force employed by state and local government, (2) the state’s regulatory burden, and (3) the share of GDP attributable to state and local government, as opposed to private industry. • The Government Encroachment Component of the ECI controls for activity of the federal government so states are not rewarded or penalized for factors (such as the presence of a large number of military bases and personnel) that are outside the control of state policymakers. This ensures a truer picture of the policy factors that can be adjusted to reduce government encroachment on the private sector. INFRASTRUCTURE - HOW IT’S MEASURED AND WHY IT MATTERS: • The ECI measures states’ infrastructure across three components: (1) Electric Power Infrastructure, (2) Broadband Infrastructure, and (3) Transportation Infrastructure. • The ranking of states’ electric power infrastructure is based on industry-standard measures of both cost and reliability. • Similarly, broadband infrastructure is ranked according to both speed and accessibility of broadband. • Lastly, the transportation infrastructure subcomponent utilizes data from the National Highway Safety Administration to rate the condition of roads and bridges in each of the states, another widely-accepted measure of quality. For more detailed information on the methodology used, please contact SCRF or visit our website, www.okstatechamber.com/SCRF. 18

Open PDF at page 18 ↗
PDF page 19

Individual Income Tax Corporate Tax Sales Tax Property Tax Unemployment Tax Rank State Rank Rank Rank Rank Rank 1 Wyoming 1 1 6 39 29 2 South Dakota 1 1 33 20 42 3 Alaska 1 26 5 22 45 4 Florida 1 6 21 13 2 5 Montana 25 21 3 28 20 6 New Hampshire 9 41 1 47 44 7 Nevada 5 25 44 5 47 8 Utah 10 14 23 7 17 9 Indiana 15 12 20 2 27 10 North Carolina 16 4 22 26 10 11 Texas 6 47 35 36 16 12 Missouri 23 3 24 8 7 13 Delaware 42 50 2 4 3 14 Michigan 12 20 10 35 18 15 Oregon 38 49 4 16 36 16 Washington 6 40 48 18 19 17 North Dakota 20 8 29 12 12 18 Tennessee 8 24 47 33 26 19 Kentucky 18 19 13 21 49 20 Idaho 26 29 9 3 48 21 Colorado 14 10 36 32 41 22 West Virginia 28 17 19 10 28 23 New Mexico 31 9 41 1 9 24 Arizona 17 22 40 11 8 25 Wisconsin 37 30 7 17 35 26 Virginia 35 16 11 27 46 27 Pennsylvania 19 43 17 15 40 28 Nebraska 21 32 15 41 11 29 Maine 22 37 8 40 33 30 Oklahoma 33 11 39 29 1 31 Georgia 36 7 27 24 39 32 Mississippi 27 13 32 37 5 33 South Carolina 34 5 31 34 24 34 Massachusetts 11 38 12 44 50 35 Kansas 24 31 37 30 13 36 Illinois 13 36 38 48 43 37 Rhode Island 29 39 25 42 30 38 Hawaii 47 18 30 9 25 39 Ohio 43 42 34 6 6 40 Iowa 40 46 14 38 37 41 Alabama 30 23 50 19 14 42 Louisiana 32 35 49 23 4 43 Vermont 39 44 16 49 15 44 Maryland 45 33 18 43 34 45 Arkansas 41 34 46 25 23 46 Minnesota 46 45 28 31 32 47 Connecticut 44 27 26 50 22 48 New York 48 15 43 45 38 49 California 49 28 45 14 21 50 New Jersey 50 48 42 46 31 TAX COMPETITIVENESS COMPONENT RANKINGS SELECTED DATA TABLES *Not all data relied on is included. 19

Open PDF at page 19 ↗
PDF page 20

Individual Income Tax Corporate Tax Sales Tax Property Tax Unemployment Tax Overall Rank State Top Rate Top Rate State Sales Tax Rate Avg. Local Rate Total Sales Tax Rate Property Tax Share of Personal Income Max Rate Taxable Wage Base 1 Wyoming 0.00% 0 4.00% 1.34% 5.34% 3.88% 8.70% $26,400 2 South Dakota 0.00% 0 4.50% 1.90% 6.40% 3.27% 10.00% $15,000 3 Alaska 0.00% 9.40% 0.00% 1.76% 1.76% 3.73% 5.40% $41,500 4 Florida 0.00% 4.46% 6.00% 1.05% 7.05% 2.78% 5.40% $7,000 5 Montana 6.90% 6.75% 0.00% 0.00% 0.00% 3.50% 6.30% $34,100 6 New Hampshire 5.00% 7.70% 0.00% 0.00% 0.00% 5.66% 7.50% $14,000 7 Nevada 0.00% 0* 6.85% 1.38% 8.23% 2.16% 5.40% $30,500 8 Utah 4.95% 4.95% 6.10% 1.08% 7.18% 2.36% 7.10% $36,600 9 Indiana 3.23% of federal AGI W/ modification 5.25% 7.00% 0.00% 7.00% 2.30% 7.40% $9,500 10 North Carolina 5.25% 2.50% 4.75% 2.23% 6.98% 2.20% 5.76% $25,200 11 Texas 0.00% 0* 6.25% 1.94% 8.19% 3.91% 6.31% $9,000 12 Missouri 5.40% 4.00% 4.23% 3.98% 8.21% 2.27% 9.75% $11,500 13 Delaware 6.60% 8.7%* 0.00% 0.00% 0.00% 1.83% 8.20% $16,500 14 Michigan 4.25% of federal AGI w/ modification 6.00% 6.00% 0.00% 6.00% 3.05% 12.77% $9,000 15 Oregon 9.90% 7.6%* 0.00% 0.00% 0.00% 3.07% 5.40% $42,100 16 Washington 0.00% 0* 6.50% 2.73% 9.23% 2.56% 5.72% $52,700 17 North Dakota 2.90% 4.31% 5.00% 1.94% 6.94% 3.14% 9.69% $37,900 18 Tennessee 2.00% 6.50% 7.00% 2.55% 9.55% 1.95% 10.00% $7,000 19 Kentucky 5.00% 5.00% 6.00% 0.00% 6.00% 2.03% 9.00% $10,800 20 Idaho 6.93% 6.93% 6.00% 0.03% 6.03% 2.42% 5.40% $41,600 21 Colorado 4.63% of federal income 4.63% 2.90% 4.75% 7.65% 2.79% 8.15% $13,600 22 West Virginia 6.50% 6.50% 6.00% 0.50% 6.50% 2.45% 8.50% $12,000 23 New Mexico 4.90% 5.90% 5.13% 2.70% 7.83% 2.00% 6.40% $25,800 24 Arizona 4.50% 4.90% 5.60% 2.80% 8.40% 2.59% 12.76% $7,000 25 Wisconsin 7.65% 7.90% 5.00% 0.43% 5.43% 3.36% 12.00% $14,000 26 Virginia 5.75% 6%* 5.30% 0.35% 5.65% 2.99% 6.21% $8,000 27 Pennsylvania 3.07% 9.99% 6.00% 0.34% 6.34% 2.88% 11.03% $10,000 28 Nebraska 6.84% 7.81% 5.50% 1.43% 6.93% 3.86% 5.40% $9,000 29 Maine 7.15% 8.93% 5.50% 0.00% 5.50% 4.59% 5.46% $12,000 30 Oklahoma 5.00% 6.00% 4.50% 4.45% 8.95% 1.67% 5.50% $18,700 31 Georgia 5.50% 5.50% 4.00% 3.31% 7.31% 2.61% 7.56% $9,500 32 Mississippi 5.00% 5.00% 7.00% 0.07% 7.07% 2.79% 5.60% $14,000 33 South Carolina 7.00% 5.00% 6.00% 1.46% 7.46% 2.85% 5.46% $14,000 34 Massachusetts 5.05% 8.00% 6.25% 0.00% 6.25% 3.57% 14.37% $15,000 35 Kansas 5.70% 7.00% 6.50% 2.18% 8.68% 3.15% 7.10% $14,000 36 Illinois 4.95% of federal AGI w/ modification 9.50% 6.25% 2.55% 8.80% 4.15% 6.83% $12,740 37 Rhode Island 5.99% 7.00% 7.00% 0.00% 7.00% 4.60% 9.19% $24,000 38 Hawaii 11.00% 6.40% 4.00% 0.44% 4.44% 2.32% 5.60% $48,100 39 Ohio 4.80% 0* 5.75% 1.42% 7.17% 2.82% 9.40% $9,000 40 Iowa 8.53% 12.00% 6.00% 0.94% 6.94% 3.44% 7.50% $31,600 41 Alabama 5.00% 6.50% 4.00% 5.22% 9.22% 1.44% 6.80% $8,000 42 Louisiana 6.00% 8.00% 4.45% 5.07% 9.52% 2.05% 6.20% $7,700 43 Vermont 8.75% 8.50% 6.00% 0.22% 6.22% 5.14% 6.50% $16,100 44 Maryland 5.75% 8.25% 6.00% 0.00% 6.00% 2.68% 7.50% $8,500 45 Arkansas 6.60% 6.50% 6.50% 3.03% 9.53% 1.79% 14.20% $10,000 46 Minnesota 9.85% 9.80% 6.88% 0.58% 7.46% 2.91% 9.00% $35,000 47 Connecticut 6.99% 8.25% 6.35% 0.00% 6.35% 4.18% 6.80% $15,000 48 New York 8.82% 6.50% 4.00% 4.52% 8.52% 4.42% 9.10% $11,600 49 California 13.30% 8.84% 7.25% 1.43% 8.68% 2.67% 6.20% $7,000 50 New Jersey 10.75% 10.50% 6.63% -0.03% 6.60% 5.05% 5.40% $35,300 Source: The Tax Foundation - State Business Tax Climate Index STATE TAX SYSTEMS - SELECTED FEATURES 20

Open PDF at page 20 ↗
PDF page 21

Sources: Bureau of Economic Analysis GDP Data, Author Research re: Damages Caps, US Chamber Institute for Legal Reform 2019 Lawsuit Climate Survey Quality of Appellate Courts Jury Fairness Quality of Trial Judges Overall Treatment of Tort & Contract Litigation Legal Services Share of Private Economy Damages Cap Rank State Rank Rank Rank Rank Rank Legal Services Share of Private GDP In Law Struck Down 1 Delaware 1 12 1 1 49 2.67% 2 Alaska 2 11 5 2 1 0.44% + 3 Maine 3 9 3 4 27 1.12% 4 Idaho 4 4 9 11 5 0.61% + 5 Connecticut 7 2 2 2 33 1.21% 6 Wyoming 5 19 4 6 4 0.57% 7 North Dakota 6 3 16 5 2 0.45% 8 North Carolina 8 17 8 28 11 0.85% 9 South Dakota 13 10 18 8 3 0.54% 10 Vermont 24 14 13 7 26 1.10% 11 Hawaii 11 25 15 14 23 1.03% + 12 New Mexico 9 23 23 25 12 0.86% 13 Montana 29 6 11 9 18 0.94% 14 Wisconsin 26 16 19 16 13 0.91% 15 Nebraska 14 8 12 21 14 0.92% 16 Arizona 15 20 6 23 19 0.94% 17 Colorado 31 24 7 15 28 1.14% + 18 Utah 17 7 28 19 10 0.83% 19 Iowa 19 26 21 20 6 0.66% 20 Oregon 27 13 20 33 17 0.93% + 21 Rhode Island 20 21 26 12 38 1.39% 22 New Hampshire 18 30 14 13 22 1.03% - 23 Virginia 12 28 35 18 34 1.23% 24 Minnesota 34 15 10 34 31 1.18% 25 Oklahoma 25 1 31 10 21 1.03% - 26 Massachusetts 28 29 27 26 42 1.50% 27 Kansas 35 22 25 24 7 0.68% + 28 Maryland 10 31 37 32 37 1.33% + 29 Washington 33 5 22 36 29 1.17% - 30 Nevada 22 34 32 17 30 1.17% 31 Indiana 37 27 24 29 9 0.78% 32 Michigan 40 32 17 31 25 1.10% 33 Arkansas 38 18 29 27 8 0.71% 34 Ohio 39 33 30 35 20 0.98% + 35 Tennessee 42 36 33 22 16 0.93% + 36 Pennsylvania 23 40 36 42 45 1.75% 37 South Carolina 16 35 42 40 32 1.21% 38 Texas 30 38 43 30 35 1.28% 39 Georgia 32 43 39 37 36 1.32% * 40 New York 21 41 34 38 50 2.75% 41 New Jersey 41 42 40 43 41 1.45% 42 Kentucky 43 37 38 39 15 0.92% 43 Alabama 36 39 45 44 40 1.40% * 44 Missouri 45 44 41 45 44 1.61% 45 Mississippi 47 49 47 47 24 1.04% + 46 West Virginia 48 45 44 41 47 1.97% 47 California 49 50 48 49 39 1.39% 48 Louisiana 43 46 50 48 43 1.59% 49 Florida 46 47 46 46 46 1.84% - 50 Illinois 50 48 49 50 48 2.19% - LEGAL CLIMATE COMPONENT RANKINGS & SELECTED FEATURES 21

Open PDF at page 21 ↗
PDF page 22

WORKFORCE COMPONENT RANKINGS & SELECTED FEATURES Quality of K-12 Education System Educational Attainment Quality of Labor Supply Overall Rank Subcomponent Rank 4th Graders Failing to Achieve “Proficient” Score in Reading Subcomponent Rank Share of Working Age Population with Bachelor’s or Higher Subcomponent Rank Labor Force Participation Rate Share of Working Age Population on Disability 1 Massachusetts 1 54.61% 1 44.00% 11 65.70% 3.30896% 2 Colorado 9 60.33% 3 41.00% 3 68.50% 2.07597% 3 New Jersey 2 58.10% 6 40.00% 23 62.50% 2.60700% 4 Minnesota 3 61.94% 15 36.00% 7 67.90% 2.64329% 5 Utah 7 59.97% 20 34.00% 2 67.50% 1.91213% 6 New Hampshire 4 61.85% 8 37.00% 17 66.40% 4.07459% 7 Virginia 8 61.73% 5 39.00% 19 62.70% 2.95944% 8 Washington 21 64.91% 4 36.00% 10 63.10% 2.70672% 9 North Dakota 18 65.65% 31 30.00% 1 68.80% 2.32942% 10 Maryland 26 64.91% 2 40.00% 8 65.60% 2.56751% 11 Connecticut 5 59.88% 11 39.00% 30 61.50% 2.68114% 12 Wyoming 6 59.45% 23 27.00% 20 64.80% 2.87321% 13 South Dakota 19 64.03% 32 29.00% 5 68.70% 2.64913% 14 Vermont 15 62.86% 7 38.00% 36 60.80% 4.04301% 15 Nebraska 16 63.19% 39 32.00% 4 68.40% 2.67788% 16 Wisconsin 11 64.48% 28 30.00% 12 66.30% 3.33276% 17 Montana 20 63.65% 14 32.00% 25 61.70% 2.99723% 18 Idaho 12 62.56% 22 28.00% 22 62.60% 3.13666% 19 Oregon 34 66.24% 9 34.00% 16 62.50% 2.98309% 20 Pennsylvania 13 60.29% 24 31.00% 31 61.60% 3.72933% 21 Kansas 25 66.18% 35 33.00% 6 67.50% 3.07205% 22 Illinois 27 65.63% 18 35.00% 21 62.40% 2.64133% 23 California 43 67.85% 10 34.00% 13 60.80% 1.95461% 24 Iowa 24 64.91% 38 29.00% 9 66.60% 3.03878% 25 Indiana 10 63.04% 41 27.00% 28 63.20% 3.71639% 26 New York 31 65.74% 16 37.00% 26 60.90% 3.00431% 27 Hawaii 40 66.21% 13 33.00% 18 59.80% 1.79266% 28 Florida 17 62.33% 33 30.00% 38 58.30% 3.07514% 29 Ohio 14 63.94% 36 28.00% 37 60.20% 3.59919% 30 North Carolina 23 64.01% 25 31.00% 40 59.20% 3.68596% 31 Maine 22 63.99% 19 32.00% 44 60.20% 4.83057% 32 Texas 36 69.73% 30 30.00% 15 62.20% 2.42792% 33 Rhode Island 32 64.58% 17 34.00% 33 62.30% 4.02292% 34 Georgia 33 67.78% 34 31.00% 27 61.60% 3.29217% 35 Arizona 38 68.62% 27 30.00% 29 60.50% 2.56886% 36 Delaware 37 67.49% 26 32.00% 34 61.10% 3.35480% 37 Missouri 30 65.83% 37 29.00% 32 63.40% 4.18734% 38 Michigan 35 68.35% 29 29.00% 41 59.10% 4.06842% 39 Tennessee 29 65.43% 42 27.00% 39 60.70% 4.31872% 40 Alaska 49 74.95% 12 30.00% 14 64.40% 2.03318% 41 Nevada 44 69.08% 43 25.00% 24 62.20% 2.56231% 42 Oklahoma 41 71.48% 46 26.00% 35 60.70% 3.96936% 43 South Carolina 42 68.21% 40 28.00% 43 57.20% 4.11642% 44 Kentucky 28 64.92% 49 24.00% 46 56.30% 5.34196% 45 New Mexico 50 76.28% 21 27.00% 42 57.20% 3.76323% 46 Mississippi 39 68.48% 50 22.00% 49 56.00% 5.17317% 47 Arkansas 45 68.81% 48 23.00% 47 57.30% 5.52534% 48 Louisiana 47 74.28% 45 24.00% 45 57.90% 4.14334% 49 West Virginia 46 69.68% 47 21.00% 50 55.20% 5.67317% 50 Alabama 48 71.84% 44 26.00% 48 56.80% 5.58689% 22

Open PDF at page 22 ↗
PDF page 23

4th Grade Math 4th Grade Reading 8th Grade Math 8th Grade Reading K12 Component Overall Rank State At or above Basic At or above Proficient At or above Basic At or above Proficient At or above Basic At or above Proficient At or above Basic At or above Proficient 1 Massachusetts 85.18% 50.19% 76.00% 45.39% 78.46% 47.41% 81.07% 44.65% 2 New Jersey 85.24% 48.16% 71.99% 41.90% 75.87% 44.09% 76.51% 42.87% 3 Minnesota 85.33% 52.85% 69.29% 38.06% 77.07% 44.16% 73.96% 34.16% 4 New Hampshire 85.70% 45.82% 70.87% 38.15% 76.51% 38.48% 78.01% 37.67% 5 Connecticut 82.46% 45.00% 70.03% 40.12% 71.74% 39.23% 77.51% 41.01% 6 Wyoming 87.10% 47.80% 73.34% 40.55% 76.42% 37.14% 75.19% 33.93% 7 Utah 82.42% 46.34% 71.75% 40.03% 72.40% 37.34% 77.38% 37.78% 8 Virginia 86.98% 47.91% 68.97% 38.27% 74.53% 37.80% 71.11% 33.24% 9 Colorado 80.48% 44.46% 70.80% 39.67% 72.52% 36.94% 76.87% 37.66% 10 Indiana 84.11% 47.07% 67.33% 36.96% 73.38% 37.40% 75.01% 37.00% 11 Wisconsin 79.92% 44.76% 65.57% 35.52% 75.50% 41.31% 76.46% 38.53% 12 Idaho 81.95% 43.02% 69.19% 37.44% 73.95% 37.34% 77.42% 37.08% 13 Pennsylvania 81.32% 47.31% 68.40% 39.71% 70.49% 38.61% 73.02% 35.16% 14 Ohio 81.91% 41.13% 68.35% 36.06% 73.31% 37.52% 75.22% 38.09% 15 Vermont 81.03% 38.80% 68.49% 37.14% 74.65% 38.33% 76.81% 40.23% 16 Nebraska 84.13% 45.48% 68.89% 36.81% 74.15% 36.87% 74.19% 33.82% 17 Florida 87.36% 47.53% 70.28% 37.67% 65.73% 30.64% 72.13% 33.91% 18 North Dakota 84.22% 44.34% 68.56% 34.35% 75.37% 37.35% 74.85% 31.63% 19 South Dakota 82.91% 43.03% 68.85% 35.97% 76.27% 39.44% 73.78% 31.88% 20 Montana 82.43% 42.58% 68.83% 36.35% 72.93% 35.67% 75.85% 34.33% 21 Washington 78.80% 39.28% 65.03% 35.09% 71.55% 40.03% 74.37% 38.46% 22 Maine 81.45% 41.77% 67.21% 36.01% 71.09% 33.60% 75.07% 35.55% 23 North Carolina 82.11% 41.37% 66.84% 35.99% 70.69% 36.51% 72.01% 32.93% 24 Iowa 80.93% 42.00% 67.65% 35.09% 71.60% 32.55% 73.08% 32.57% 25 Kansas 79.38% 40.31% 66.38% 33.82% 70.56% 32.88% 74.00% 32.30% 26 Maryland 75.78% 39.11% 64.22% 35.09% 65.02% 32.59% 72.83% 35.99% 27 Illinois 77.28% 38.50% 64.41% 34.37% 69.46% 33.84% 73.67% 35.45% 28 Kentucky 80.69% 39.92% 66.79% 35.08% 67.31% 29.01% 72.58% 33.43% 29 Tennessee 79.44% 39.89% 65.65% 34.57% 67.84% 31.15% 72.65% 31.55% 30 Missouri 79.72% 39.32% 63.95% 34.17% 69.59% 31.58% 73.92% 33.31% 31 New York 76.48% 36.94% 65.53% 34.26% 65.89% 33.52% 70.42% 32.46% 32 Rhode Island 80.56% 40.47% 66.05% 35.42% 63.82% 29.49% 71.48% 35.02% 33 Georgia 77.23% 36.49% 63.34% 32.22% 66.87% 31.14% 71.65% 32.13% 34 Oregon 75.40% 37.25% 63.89% 33.76% 66.95% 31.39% 72.68% 34.04% 35 Michigan 76.16% 35.59% 64.24% 31.65% 68.07% 30.99% 73.32% 31.49% 36 Texas 84.39% 43.67% 61.25% 30.27% 67.96% 29.55% 67.05% 25.04% 37 Delaware 78.74% 39.14% 62.42% 32.51% 65.23% 29.22% 69.03% 30.96% 38 Arizona 77.49% 37.35% 61.35% 31.38% 67.72% 31.01% 69.59% 28.39% 39 Mississippi 84.21% 38.83% 65.40% 31.52% 62.19% 24.33% 67.19% 25.04% 40 Hawaii 78.38% 39.77% 62.55% 33.79% 64.58% 27.66% 67.56% 29.16% 41 Oklahoma 80.30% 34.50% 63.32% 28.52% 66.23% 25.51% 71.43% 25.64% 42 South Carolina 76.65% 36.33% 61.12% 31.79% 63.69% 28.90% 68.78% 29.32% 43 California 74.58% 33.63% 62.55% 32.15% 60.96% 28.51% 67.81% 29.84% 44 Nevada 77.12% 34.30% 64.21% 30.92% 61.50% 25.70% 68.72% 28.62% 45 Arkansas 75.12% 33.25% 62.12% 31.19% 63.04% 27.31% 68.14% 29.52% 46 West Virginia 74.12% 29.65% 60.14% 30.32% 61.52% 24.13% 67.32% 25.34% 47 Louisiana 73.42% 28.77% 54.68% 25.72% 60.76% 23.07% 67.51% 27.19% 48 Alabama 71.49% 28.10% 57.73% 28.16% 57.22% 21.28% 63.90% 23.60% 49 Alaska 72.86% 33.17% 53.25% 25.05% 63.08% 29.04% 63.27% 23.29% 50 New Mexico 72.30% 28.72% 53.05% 23.72% 56.19% 20.74% 61.02% 23.34% STATE K12 EDUCATION OUTCOMES Source: U.S. Department of Education, Institute of Education Sciences, National Center for Education Statistics, National Assessment of Educational Progress (NAEP), 2019. 23

Open PDF at page 23 ↗
PDF page 24

ENCROACHMENT OF GOVERNMENT ON PRIVATE INDUSTRY COMPONENT RANKINGS & SELECTED FEATURES Encroachment on Workforce Regulatory Burden Crowding of Private Capital Rank State Subcomponent Rank Share of Workforce 16+ Employed by State or Local Government Subcomponent Rank Total Restrictions in Regulatory Code Total Words in Regulatory Code Lower-Income Occupations Licensed (out of 102 studied) Average Calendar Days Lost to Licensing Requirements Subcomponent Rank Share of GDP Attributable to State & Local Gov. 1 New Hampshire 11 11.87% 18 133592 8060053 38 273 7 7.82% 2 Pennsylvania 4 10.31% 35 162937 13093618 51 117 2 7.26% 3 Georgia 12 11.96% 17 109848 6067499 41 464 4 7.64% 4 Nevada 1 9.26% 31 64265 4981924 75 861 11 8.03% 5 Massachusetts 5 10.59% 38 164575 10888804 50 513 1 6.96% 6 Florida 2 9.88% 41 168795 10986328 56 693 10 8.02% 7 South Dakota 35 14.07% 1 43251 3358016 32 355 14 8.08% 8 Michigan 7 11.51% 7 76236 4367835 49 255 20 8.52% 9 Tennessee 9 11.74% 28 119272 8276640 71 226 9 8.02% 10 Missouri 24 12.61% 11 93915 6720122 37 348 22 8.57% 11 Arizona 3 10.13% 29 64319 6004954 68 765 29 9.09% 12 Colorado 15 12.20% 30 154964 12177626 34 260 17 8.34% 13 Connecticut 10 11.80% 21 96247 5930071 64 361 3 7.58% 14 Indiana 17 12.27% 12 91155 8160320 37 323 8 7.94% 15 Maryland 8 11.61% 34 123465 9113182 59 529 6 7.81% 16 Rhode Island 6 10.67% 23 94051 5789509 72 326 30 9.16% 17 Minnesota 20 12.48% 8 98067 5696249 34 300 12 8.03% 18 Texas 18 12.29% 42 263369 17117088 37 341 13 8.07% 19 Delaware 25 12.71% 14 93421 5933639 44 475 16 8.33% 20 Utah 33 13.47% 24 91517 5672997 64 504 19 8.49% 21 Virginia 23 12.58% 39 140021 8688471 68 620 15 8.22% 22 Illinois 13 12.04% 44 273989 18213395 40 249 5 7.78% 23 North Carolina 31 13.25% 20 107092 5970940 67 234 33 9.31% 24 Idaho 27 12.82% 9 38961 4005332 67 332 36 9.59% 25 New Jersey 22 12.55% 33 * * 54 422 25 8.87% 26 Wisconsin 21 12.49% 32 161549 12250243 42 214 31 9.18% 27 Washington 16 12.21% 43 197466 17507192 77 163 26 8.89% 28 Ohio 19 12.36% 48 274470 22646803 40 350 18 8.42% 29 Kentucky 34 13.68% 16 116252 6108663 37 466 32 9.20% 30 Maine 26 12.76% 22 119591 8685587 45 298 34 9.32% 31 Louisiana 38 14.60% 40 164387 11222553 77 202 24 8.86% 32 Montana 41 15.00% 5 59788 4742174 32 312 37 9.98% 33 Nebraska 43 15.09% 15 95660 7217308 63 118 39 10.13% 34 North Dakota 46 16.00% 6 52368 3707901 65 122 21 8.57% 35 South Carolina 29 13.12% 13 78727 4765126 60 440 45 11.53% 36 Kansas 48 16.99% 2 69925 3211823 35 200 35 9.45% 37 Alabama 42 15.03% 19 107686 7514839 63 142 42 10.56% 38 New York 37 14.40% 45 296296 17622247 41 275 27 9.01% 39 Oklahoma 32 13.41% 27 142604 9211617 41 399 46 11.63% 40 Iowa 40 14.99% 37 160603 9816474 71 288 38 10.06% 41 California 14 12.18% 50 395608 21284860 76 827 23 8.67% 42 Oregon 28 12.90% 46 200477 18179103 69 537 41 10.52% 43 Vermont 36 14.31% 4 * * 31 287 43 10.68% 44 Hawaii 30 13.14% 49 * * 63 988 28 9.09% 45 Alaska 49 17.69% 10 52569 5763061 63 211 50 12.88% 46 West Virginia 45 15.61% 26 114964 7711578 70 210 44 11.07% 47 Arkansas 39 14.73% 47 * * 72 642 40 10.16% 48 New Mexico 44 15.47% 36 128946 9485592 66 520 47 12.01% 49 Mississippi 47 16.42% 25 116153 8880233 66 160 48 12.54% 50 Wyoming 50 21.44% 3 71294 3841197 26 280 49 12.85% Sources: Sources: Census Data; Bureau of Economic Analysis Data, Mercatus Center RegData (“QuantGov”), Institute for Justice Occupational Licensing Database 24

Open PDF at page 24 ↗
PDF page 25

Electric Power Infrastructure Broadband Infrastructure Transportation Infrastructure Rank State Reliability of Electricity Ranking Price of Electricity Ranking Subcomponent Rank Access to Coverage (Share of Population) Access to High Speed (Share of Population) Subcomponent Rank Share of Roads in “Acceptable” Condition Share of Bridges in “Poor” Condition 1 Delaware 1 34 4 97.20% 97.20% 15 84.01% 3.00% 2 Utah 2 7 10 96.50% 86.90% 14 78.18% 0.85% 3 Georgia 7 25 18 94.70% 77.70% 1 92.88% 1.48% 4 Florida 16 32 9 96.90% 86.90% 3 87.12% 1.36% 5 North Dakota 9 12 24 96.80% 62.80% 6 94.06% 4.23% 6 Nevada 21 10 25 92.90% 74.20% 4 85.47% 1.00% 7 Oregon 10 13 29 92.50% 69.60% 8 89.90% 3.46% 8 Maryland 6 38 6 96.70% 93.80% 29 73.00% 3.32% 9 Tennessee 37 23 23 93.70% 73.80% 7 94.68% 4.57% 10 Arizona 4 36 30 88.30% 82.20% 17 79.14% 1.48% 11 Kentucky 15 9 32 93.30% 62.90% 13 90.08% 4.93% 12 Ohio 29 22 22 94.50% 71.20% 18 83.58% 3.35% 13 Nebraska 8 15 34 89.40% 75.20% 16 88.86% 4.89% 14 Iowa 5 16 20 91.20% 84.10% 28 92.04% 9.83% 15 North Carolina 40 19 16 95.00% 82.30% 24 86.44% 6.52% 16 Kansas 19 33 33 89.40% 75.50% 11 87.92% 2.99% 17 Texas 42 8 26 91.60% 76.10% 19 78.09% 1.42% 18 Virginia 46 20 19 91.80% 83.70% 12 86.01% 3.38% 19 Washington 25 5 14 95.10% 86.40% 38 72.76% 6.57% 20 Idaho 14 3 42 80.70% 76.40% 5 96.35% 5.03% 21 Pennsylvania 17 29 8 95.20% 93.30% 41 73.03% 7.80% 22 Minnesota 24 35 31 92.20% 69.40% 21 84.08% 4.10% 23 Alabama 20 26 44 88.90% 45.10% 2 88.70% 1.68% 24 Oklahoma 33 2 43 83.10% 65.10% 9 93.42% 4.82% 25 Indiana 39 27 28 90.00% 78.40% 26 77.42% 3.72% 26 New Hampshire 12 44 11 96.80% 85.80% 33 80.33% 6.81% 27 Illinois 13 21 15 94.50% 87.60% 45 79.88% 12.11% 28 Vermont 43 43 17 92.90% 85.80% 22 82.62% 3.86% 29 Colorado 45 31 21 92.30% 80.20% 30 77.78% 5.15% 30 Wisconsin 22 37 38 89.30% 55.70% 23 82.49% 3.85% 31 New York 35 42 5 98.10% 93.30% 44 73.38% 9.60% 32 Arkansas 36 4 47 79.80% 57.10% 10 93.33% 4.80% 33 South Carolina 23 28 39 92.30% 44.90% 27 81.90% 6.00% 34 Massachusetts 3 46 7 97.80% 90.20% 47 75.13% 11.93% 35 South Dakota 34 30 36 91.60% 58.80% 34 86.12% 9.66% 36 New Jersey 32 40 2 98.50% 97.60% 48 52.95% 7.13% 37 New Mexico 18 18 37 85.10% 70.80% 36 68.45% 4.43% 38 Connecticut 38 48 3 99.00% 93.60% 46 66.02% 7.48% 39 Michigan 44 39 27 92.00% 71.90% 35 78.51% 7.50% 40 California 30 45 13 96.80% 81.30% 43 64.84% 6.47% 41 Louisiana 47 1 35 89.00% 70.00% 40 75.10% 8.41% 42 Missouri 11 24 45 86.50% 52.10% 39 75.29% 8.45% 43 Wyoming 26 6 49 80.90% 22.30% 20 94.70% 7.78% 44 Mississippi 48 17 46 84.20% 58.60% 32 73.20% 3.88% 45 Alaska 41 49 40 82.20% 76.90% 31 82.97% 7.21% 46 Hawaii 27 50 12 97.40% 80.70% 42 57.25% 2.56% 47 Montana 31 14 50 79.90% 16.20% 25 88.30% 7.28% 48 Rhode Island 28 47 1 98.60% 98.60% 50 49.68% 20.53% 49 Maine 50 41 41 96.40% 25.80% 37 77.31% 7.70% 50 West Virginia 49 11 48 77.10% 57.90% 49 68.93% 15.03% INFRASTRUCTURE COMPONENT RANKINGS & SELECTED FEATURES Sources: Electricity Information Agency Data; BroadbandNow Data; National Highway Safety Administration 25

Open PDF at page 25 ↗
PDF page 26

INFRASTRUCTURE COMPONENT RANKINGS & SELECTED FEATURES Economy Wealth Growth Rank State Real GDP Growth (Cumulative over 10 years) Rank Per Capita Personal Income Rank Cumulative Net Domestic Migration (10 years) Rank 39 Alabama 8.9 37 46207.67 40 28,699 18 43 Alaska -9.3 49 52985.00 17 -66,705 34 17 Arizona 23.3 9 42893.33 48 565,662 3 32 Arkansas 11.1 33 47228.33 35 16,639 20 34 California 30.1 4 50900.67 22 -1,162,930 49 5 Colorado 29.6 6 53532.00 12 379,946 6 8 Connecticut -2.9 47 65699.67 1 -219,328 43 36 Delaware 2.3 43 49345.67 24 48,774 15 4 Florida 21.3 12 46730.00 37 1,462,321 1 14 Georgia 23.1 10 46627.67 39 294,482 9 45 Hawaii 9.8 35 43117.33 47 -84,226 37 22 Idaho 26.6 8 44719.00 45 144,933 12 44 Illinois 8.4 38 53905.67 11 -978,498 48 28 Indiana 16.7 18 49071.33 26 -47,210 30 21 Iowa 15.2 25 51808.00 20 -37,249 27 20 Kansas 15.2 24 52996.00 16 -118,086 39 41 Kentucky 10.7 34 45061.33 43 -12,162 25 47 Louisiana -4.8 48 48198.33 30 -125,586 40 42 Maine 6.2 39 45302.33 41 21,272 19 19 Maryland 14.9 26 54008.67 10 -185,994 41 6 Massachusetts 20.7 13 60329.67 2 -190,343 42 33 Michigan 16.5 19 47912.67 32 -296,910 46 11 Minnesota 17.6 16 54104.67 9 -37,326 28 50 Mississippi 0.1 46 41326.33 50 -93,977 38 38 Missouri 4.8 40 49133.00 25 -64,393 33 27 Montana 17 17 47864.00 33 57,716 14 7 Nebraska 20.1 14 54606.67 7 -26,048 26 25 Nevada 14.7 27 47683.67 34 270,908 10 15 New Hampshire 13.7 31 53374.67 14 13,052 22 37 New Jersey 4.6 42 54499.00 8 -536,306 47 46 New Mexico 9.1 36 42393.67 49 -61,803 32 48 New York 14.4 28 54853.00 6 -1,585,770 50 16 North Carolina 15.6 23 46773.00 36 548,965 4 1 North Dakota 42.8 1 56924.67 4 32,564 17 30 Ohio 15.7 22 50959.00 21 -241,020 44 29 Oklahoma 16 21 48413.67 29 41,279 16 10 Oregon 28.1 7 46686.67 38 252,060 11 26 Pennsylvania 13.9 29 53385.00 13 -283,487 45 35 Rhode Island 2.1 44 50458.33 23 -41,528 29 18 South Carolina 21.4 11 44765.67 44 422,700 5 9 South Dakota 16.1 20 54924.00 5 13,771 21 13 Tennessee 17.7 15 48920.33 27 308,834 8 2 Texas 30.1 5 48902.00 28 1,303,879 2 12 Utah 33.7 3 45236.33 42 98,345 13 40 Vermont 4.7 41 48048.67 31 -11,798 24 24 Virginia 11.4 32 52873.67 18 -80,255 36 3 Washington 38.7 2 53078.00 15 371,258 7 49 West Virginia 1.3 45 43433.67 46 -47,401 31 23 Wisconsin 13.8 30 51855.00 19 -76,587 35 31 Wyoming -12.2 50 59739.67 3 -11,664 23 26

Open PDF at page 26 ↗
PDF page 27

REPUTATION FOR ECONOMIC COMPETITIVENESS SELECTED BUSINESS CLIMATE INDEX RANKINGS SCRF Economic Competitiveness Index Chief Exec. Magazine CNBC Best Places for Business New Economy Index Rich States Poor States Forbes Magazine US News USA Today Wall St. 24/7 Outlook Performance Rank State Rank Rank Rank Rank Rank Rank Rank Rank 46 Alabama 30 31 42 25 28 40 38 44 29 Alaska 33 50 43 18 48 50 50 29 15 Arizona 10 30 20 13 7 18 7 24 45 Arkansas 31 43 49 23 26 33 41 35 44 California 50 33 2 45 16 31 10 13 3 Colorado 20 8 8 20 2 9 2 3 25 Connecticut 43 24 9 39 50 43 22 14 12 Delaware 14 27 12 31 20 23 24 12 6 Florida 2 17 22 2 5 5 8 20 16 Georgia 9 6 16 14 10 6 12 22 41 Hawaii 42 49 46 42 27 47 46 48 11 Idaho 21 16 32 11 8 10 3 7 47 Illinois 48 15 13 47 42 37 39 42 18 Indiana 5 19 29 6 21 12 21 30 31 Iowa 17 20 35 33 33 17 27 21 30 Kansas 27 28 28 26 39 36 31 37 39 Kentucky 23 41 39 29 29 38 40 43 49 Louisiana 19 44 40 22 49 46 47 49 37 Maine 36 48 37 43 36 44 36 38 23 Maryland 38 12 4 40 35 34 35 9 5 Massachusetts 45 14 1 30 19 19 5 1 27 Michigan 15 11 17 16 30 35 29 28 20 Minnesota 40 7 11 46 18 15 15 16 48 Mississippi 32 45 50 27 47 42 49 46 35 Missouri 18 25 25 21 41 22 23 45 24 Montana 25 34 44 34 15 30 19 19 21 Nebraska 26 13 31 35 24 11 20 27 14 Nevada 8 40 26 7 11 13 6 26 7 New Hampshire 24 37 18 19 25 25 11 15 40 New Jersey 47 26 10 48 46 39 33 32 43 New Mexico 35 38 36 38 43 48 44 47 42 New York 49 22 7 50 23 28 43 25 9 North Carolina 4 2 19 5 14 1 17 6 4 North Dakota 29 18 38 8 12 26 32 5 32 Ohio 7 10 27 28 32 29 34 41 36 Oklahoma 28 32 48 3 22 24 37 39 22 Oregon 44 35 15 44 9 20 14 23 28 Pennsylvania 41 23 21 36 40 27 42 40 38 Rhode Island 37 46 23 41 37 41 28 36 34 South Carolina 6 39 34 24 6 16 18 31 2 South Dakota 12 29 41 10 17 14 30 17 19 Tennessee 3 5 30 12 13 7 16 33 10 Texas 1 4 14 9 1 2 9 18 1 Utah 11 3 3 1 4 3 1 2 33 Vermont 39 42 24 49 38 45 25 10 13 Virginia 13 1 6 17 31 4 13 8 8 Washington 46 9 5 37 3 8 4 4 50 West Virginia 34 47 47 32 45 49 48 50 26 Wisconsin 22 21 33 15 34 21 26 34 17 Wyoming 16 36 45 4 44 32 45 10 27

Open PDF at page 27 ↗
PDF page 28

ABOUT THE STATE CHAMBER RESEARCH FOUNDATION The State Chamber Research Foundation is the business community’s think tank. We educate policymakers, the public, and the business community about the virtues of the free enterprise system, the greatest vehicle for maximizing human flourishing; public policy ideas that will make Oklahoma a place where the free enterprise system thrives; and the positive contributions of the business community to the prosperity and welfare of the people of Oklahoma. We believe that ideas change the world, and good ideas change the world for the better. Visit us at www.okstatechamber.com/SCRF.

Open PDF at page 28 ↗

Related Research