Report text
Text extracted from the original PDF. Tables, footnotes, and reading order can differ. Check the PDF before quoting. Page numbers below refer to PDF viewer pages.
PDF page 1
THE ECONOMIC AND FISCAL IMPACT OF EXCESSIVE TORT COSTS ON OKLAHOMA JANUARY 2025
Open PDF at page 1 ↗PDF page 2
www.perrymangroup.com The Economic and Fiscal Impact of Excessive Tort Costs on Oklahoma January 2025
Open PDF at page 2 ↗PDF page 3
The Economic and Fiscal Impact of Excessive Tort Costs on Oklahoma Contents Executive Summary ............................................................................................. i Introduction ........................................................................................................ 1 The Importance of Caps on Noneconomic Damages ...................................... 3 Economic and Fiscal Impacts ............................................................................ 7 Total Excess Tort Costs ................................................................................................. 9 Losses Due the Removal of Caps on Noneconomic Damages ............................ 10 Fiscal Effects .................................................................................................................. 11 Potential Impact on Economic Development ................................................. 13 Conclusion ........................................................................................................ 15 Appendix A: Methods Used ............................................................................ 16 US Multi-Regional Impact Assessment System ...................................................... 16 US Multi-Regional Econometric Model .................................................................... 23 Appendix B: Detailed Results ......................................................................... 29
Open PDF at page 3 ↗PDF page 4
i The Economic and Fiscal Impact of Excessive Tort Costs on Oklahoma Executive Summary • The civil justice system is crucial to the proper functioning of society and the economy. However, it is possible for the system to become imbalanced through flaws such as generating exorbitant levels of damages or numbers of awards. When such imbalances occur, the associated expenses rise, leading to higher costs for goods and services across the economy. These costs are ultimately borne by consumers and workers through higher prices, reduced income, and lost jobs. • The Perryman Group quantified the aggregate excess costs associated with the current Oklahoma civil justice system and examined the resulting downstream effects. o The current annual losses from excess tort costs in Oklahoma are estimated to be more than $3.7 billion in gross product each year and almost 32,300 jobs (including multiplier effects). o Over the 2020 through 2023 time-period, the excess tort costs in Oklahoma led to a cumulative estimated loss in gross product of almost $14.9 billion and 128,500 job-years (including multiplier effects). A job- year is one person working for one year, though it could be multiple individuals working partial years. • A contributing factor to overall excess tort costs and related economic effects in Oklahoma is the 2019 removal of caps on noneconomic damages. o The Perryman Group estimates the cumulative losses over the 2020 through 2023 time horizon associated with elimination of non- economic damages caps total almost $2.7 billion in gross product and 20,330 job-years including multiplier effects. (Note that these losses are a subset of the overall totals previously described.) o The removal of the non-economic damage caps contributed to a significant portion of the excessive tort costs from 2020 through 2023 including approximately 19.7% of the lost expenditures, 17.9% of decreased gross product, 15.4% of the decrease in personal income and 15.8% of the lost employment.
Open PDF at page 4 ↗PDF page 5
ii The Economic and Fiscal Impact of Excessive Tort Costs on Oklahoma • Business activity generates tax revenue, and the economic losses associated with excess tort costs decrease tax receipts to the State of Oklahoma and local government entities. o The Perryman Group estimates that the annual decrease in tax receipts includes approximately $195.0 million to the State of Oklahoma and $162.5 million to local government entities across the state, with cumulative losses over the 2020 through 2023 period of an estimated $776.1 million to the State and $646.6 million to local government entities. o Of these amounts, removal of the cap on noneconomic damages comprised losses of $135.9 million in tax receipts to the State and $102.8 million to local government entities during the 2020 through 2023 period. • Excess tort costs can also make a state less competitive and, thus, play a role in the state’s ability to attract desirable corporate locations and expansions. o The Perryman Group estimates the annual economic development losses as of 2033 associated with excess tort costs in Oklahoma total about $4.7 billion in annual gross product and almost 29,500 jobs (including multiplier effects). o The cumulative losses in economic development for the period 2024 through 2033 associated with excess tort costs in Oklahoma total about $24.1 billion in gross product and almost 155,900 job-years including multiplier effects. • The costs of excess torts to the Oklahoma economy impose substantial short- term and long-term harms to Oklahoma and its citizens.
Open PDF at page 5 ↗PDF page 6
1 The Economic and Fiscal Impact of Excessive Tort Costs on Oklahoma Introduction The civil justice system is crucial to the proper functioning of society and the economy. The purpose of the system is to provide a fair and equitable forum for the resolution of disputes among parties, appropriately compensating those who have legitimately been harmed. The civil justice system is designed to provide proper remedies for injured parties and incentives for responsible actions; it is not intended to be punitive, random, or unpredictable. However, it is possible for the system to become imbalanced through flaws such as generating exorbitant levels of damages or numbers of awards. In addition, unpredictable outcomes contribute to negative impacts through the misallocation of society’s scarce economic and human resources. When such imbalances occur, the associated expenses rise, leading to higher costs for goods and services across the economy. These costs are ultimately borne by consumers and workers through higher prices, reduced income, and lost jobs. The Perryman Group has studied the costs of excessive tort costs on a number of occasions and estimates that the reduction in Oklahoma gross product on a per-capita basis due to excessive civil justice costs was more than $922 in 2023.1 Although somewhat lower than the US average cost per person of $1,666, the harm to the Oklahoma economy is nonetheless significant.2 A contributing factor to these costs is the fact that Oklahoma no longer has a cap on certain non-economic damages, which are the portion of damages awarded to attempt to compensate for an injured person's 1 Economic Benefits of Tort Reform, An Assessment of Excessive US Tort Costs and Potential Economic Benefits of Reform, The Perryman Group, 2024. 2 Economic Benefits of Tort Reform, An Assessment of Excessive US Tort Costs and Potential Economic Benefits of Reform, The Perryman Group, 2024. When imbalances in the civil justice system occur, the excess tort costs spread across the economy. These costs are ultimately borne by consumers through higher prices.
Open PDF at page 6 ↗PDF page 7
2 The Economic and Fiscal Impact of Excessive Tort Costs on Oklahoma emotional distress and suffering related to an accident. Such awards are separate from economic damages, which seek to restore an injured person to their original financial condition. In 2019, the Oklahoma Supreme Court declared a cap on noneconomic pain and suffering damage awards under a law passed in 2011 to be an unconstitutional special law. The Oklahoma Constitution forbids the passage of special laws in which part of a group of similarly affected persons are targeted for different treatment. The issue was the “statute purports to limit recovery for pain and suffering in cases where the plaintiff survives the injury-causing event, while persons who die from the injury-causing event face no such limitation.”3 The economic costs of excessive noneconomic damages can be significant and will ultimately be borne by individuals, families, and businesses across the state. According to data from the US Census Bureau, the median household income in Oklahoma was about $62,100 in 2023 compared to the median US household income of $77,700, and only five states had lower median household incomes.4 Lower household income means excessive tort costs have a particularly significant impact on families in Oklahoma compared to other states with higher household incomes. The purpose of this study is to quantify not only the impact of excess tort costs on Oklahoma business activity, but also the portion associated with the 2019 elimination of caps on noneconomic damages. An empirical perspective on the potential consequences for economic development is also provided. 3 Carter, Roy, “Oklahoma Supreme Court Strikes Down Cap on Noneconomic Damages,” Law and Principles, Oklahoma Council of Public Affairs, April 23, 2019. 4 US Census Bureau, US Department of Commerce. "Median Household Income in the Past 12 Months (in 2023 Inflation-Adjusted Dollars)." American Community Survey, ACS 1-Year Estimates Detailed Tables, Table B19013.
Open PDF at page 7 ↗PDF page 8
3 The Economic and Fiscal Impact of Excessive Tort Costs on Oklahoma The Importance of Caps on Noneconomic Damages Limits on noneconomic damages vary by state and by type of claim. Some states have limits on noneconomic damages for personal injury claims, while others have total caps that limit both economic and noneconomic damages.5 A common type of cap involves punitive damages, and some states have caps on wrongful death claims.6 Many studies show the benefits of civil justice reform and caps on noneconomic damages. For example, a study on the cap on noneconomic damages in Texas found the cap reduced “allowed noneconomic damages by an estimated 73 percent, allowed verdicts by 38 percent, and payouts by 27 percent. In settled cases, the estimated decline in payouts is 18 percent.”7 It also concluded, based on a simulation of caps, that there is a large variation in cap impact depending on how the cap is designed, with caps on total damages having an especially large impact.8 The potential increase in non-medical damages and noneconomic damages caps for medical professional liability cases in New Mexico has 5 States with caps limiting various types of damages (other than medical malpractice) include Alabama, Alaska, Arizona, Colorado, Connecticut, Florida, Georgia, Hawaii, Idaho, Iowa, Indiana, Kansas, Maine, Maryland, Mississippi, Montana, Nevada, New Hampshire, New Jersey, Nebraska, North Carolina, Ohio, Oklahoma, Oregon, Pennsylvania, South Carolina, Tennessee, Texas, Wisconsin, Virginia, and West Virginia. 6 Note that many states also have caps on noneconomic damages for medical malpractice. For a listing of medical malpractice and related caps by state, see State Laws Chart I: Liability Reforms, American Medical Association Advocacy Resource Center, 2024, https://www.ama- assn.org/system/files/mlr-state-laws-chart-I.pdf. 7 Hyman, David A., Bernard Black, Charles Silver, and William M. Sage, Estimating the Effect of Damages Caps in Medical Malpractice Cases: Evidence from Texas, Journal of Legal Analysis, Winter 2009: Volume 1. 8 Hyman, David A., Bernard Black, Charles Silver, and William M. Sage, Estimating the Effect of Damages Caps in Medical Malpractice Cases: Evidence from Texas, Journal of Legal Analysis, Winter 2009: Volume 1. Many studies show the benefits of civil justice reform and caps on noneconomic damages.
Open PDF at page 8 ↗PDF page 9
4 The Economic and Fiscal Impact of Excessive Tort Costs on Oklahoma also been examined.9 The analysis included various scenarios based on differing cap changes, concluding that cap increases or removal of noneconomic caps would lead to a notable increase in loss and allocated loss adjustment expense (ALAE) costs in New Mexico. In the case of removal of the noneconomic damages cap, the total effect on loss and pure premium ALAE was an expected increase from 35.9% to 73.8% for the central estimate.10 A recent bill in the Maryland State Senate would eliminate Maryland’s statutory limits on noneconomic damages in personal injury cases and allow unlimited pain and suffering awards outside of healthcare liability claims.11 Testimony before the Maryland Senate committee indicated the change would: • complicate the ability to reach reasonable settlements, since plaintiffs’ lawyers will demand significantly higher amounts for immeasurable harm and some may hold out for the chance of a jackpot verdict, • lead to more frequent excessive verdicts for a wide range of businesses and nonprofit organizations and lengthy appeals, and • result in higher insurance costs for Maryland drivers, homeowners, and businesses.12 Another study reviewed the increasing size of punitive damages and excessive, or “nuclear,” verdicts which it defined as verdicts awarded larger than $100 million.13 It indicated the number and size of punitive damage awards has grown considerably, with 24 verdicts in excess of $100 million in 2021, with the awards totaling $309 billion and having a 9 Increase in New Mexico Cap on Damages Analysis of Effect on Loss and ALAE Costs, Milliman Client Report, for the Doctors Company, November 3, 2020. 10 Increase in New Mexico Cap on Damages Analysis of Effect on Loss and ALAE Costs, Milliman Client Report, for the Doctors Company, November 3, 2020. 11 Silverman, Cary, On Behalf of the American Tort Reform Association, Testimony Before the Maryland Senate Judicial Proceedings Committee in Opposition to S.B. 538, A Bill That Would Allow Unlimited Pain & Suffering Awards in Personal Injury and Wrongful Death Cases, February 16, 2024. 12 Silverman, Cary, On Behalf of the American Tort Reform Association, Testimony Before the Maryland Senate Judicial Proceedings Committee in Opposition to S.B. 538, A Bill That Would Allow Unlimited Pain & Suffering Awards in Personal Injury and Wrongful Death Cases, February 16, 2024. 13 Cole, Casandra and Chad Marzen, Nuclear Verdicts, Tort Liability, and Legislative Responses, Journal of Insurance Regulation, 2023.
Open PDF at page 9 ↗PDF page 10
5 The Economic and Fiscal Impact of Excessive Tort Costs on Oklahoma median of $175.0 million.14 The study indicates several potential adverse effects of these verdicts. For example, they may reduce funds available to companies for safety and mitigation strategies, discourage innovation, lead to greater out-of-pocket insurance and claims costs for consumers and businesses, or lead to bankruptcy. Additionally, nuclear verdicts could reduce the capacity of the global insurance market.15 A similar study analyzed excessive verdicts in personal injury and wrongful death cases over a 10-year period, defining them as jury verdicts of $10 million or more.16 This report also found that these types of verdicts are increasing in both amount and frequency.17 The analysis indicates nuclear verdicts “can have devastating impacts on businesses, entire industries, and society at large, even when a verdict is later thrown out or substantially reduced by an appellate court. These verdicts can drive up the costs of goods and services, adversely affect the cost and availability of insurance, and undermine fundamental fairness and predictability in the rule of law.”18 A report from the Congressional Budget Office in 2004 analyzed numerous studies on the impact of various types of tort reform.19 One section of the report evaluated the effects of tort reform legislation on the liability insurance market. The studies reviewed indicated that insurers in states with caps on noneconomic damages had lower loss ratios and charged lower premiums than insurers in other states.20 These results collectively indicate excessive noneconomic damage awards can have negative effects in a variety of ways. They can reduce insurance availability, discourage business formation or eliminate business operations, and lead to notable cost increases for insurance coverage. Higher costs of insurance are spread across the economy, 14 Cole, Casandra and Chad Marzen, Nuclear Verdicts, Tort Liability, and Legislative Responses, Journal of Insurance Regulation, 2023. 15 Cole, Casandra and Chad Marzen, Nuclear Verdicts, Tort Liability, and Legislative Responses, Journal of Insurance Regulation, 2023. 16 Nuclear Verdicts Trends, Causes, and Solutions, US Chamber of Commerce Institute for Legal Reform, September 2022. 17 Nuclear Verdicts Trends, Causes, and Solutions, US Chamber of Commerce Institute for Legal Reform, September 2022. 18 Nuclear Verdicts Trends, Causes, and Solutions, US Chamber of Commerce Institute for Legal Reform, September 2022. 19 The Effects of Tort Reform: Evidence from the States, The Congress of the United States, Congressional Budget Office, June 2004. 20 The Effects of Tort Reform: Evidence from the States, The Congress of the United States, Congressional Budget Office, June 2004.
Open PDF at page 10 ↗PDF page 11
6 The Economic and Fiscal Impact of Excessive Tort Costs on Oklahoma leading to price increases and other allocation issues. A reasonable cap on noneconomic damages helps ensure the civil justice system remains balanced, benefiting individuals, businesses, and society as a whole.
Open PDF at page 11 ↗PDF page 12
7 The Economic and Fiscal Impact of Excessive Tort Costs on Oklahoma Economic and Fiscal Impacts Any economic stimulus leads to dynamic responses across the economy. The Perryman Group has developed complex and comprehensive models over the past four decades to measure these dynamic responses. The total economic impact (not only direct, but also downstream multiplier effects) of excessive tort costs were measured (1) on an annual basis as of 2023 and (2) cumulatively over the 2020 through 2023 period. In addition, the portion of losses associated with the 2019 removal of caps on noneconomic damages was estimated. The fiscal impact of these losses in business activity were also quantified. In addition, the potential effects of excess tort costs on Oklahoma’s economic growth were estimated. Methods used in this analysis are summarized on the following page, with substantial additional detail in Appendix A. Results by industry are presented in Appendix B. Any economic stimulus leads to dynamic responses across the economy.
Open PDF at page 12 ↗PDF page 13
8 The Economic and Fiscal Impact of Excessive Tort Costs on Oklahoma Measuring Economic and Fiscal Effects Any economic stimulus, whether positive or negative, generates multiplier effects throughout the economy. In this instance, excess tort costs reduce productive activity across the economy. The resulting decrease in economic activity has notable negative effects on tax receipts to State and local governments. The Perryman Group’s dynamic input-output assessment system (the US Multi-Regional Impact Assessment System) and comprehensive forecasting system (the US Multi- Regional Econometric Model), which are described in further detail in the Appendices to this report, were developed by the firm about 40 years ago and have been consistently maintained and updated since that time. These models have been used in hundreds of analyses for clients ranging from major corporations to government agencies and have been peer reviewed on multiple occasions. The impact system uses a variety of data (from surveys, industry information, and other sources) to describe the various goods and services (known as resources or inputs) required to produce another good/service. This process allows for estimation of the total economic impact (including multiplier effects) of the proposed policies. The models used in the current analysis reflect the specific industrial composition and characteristics of Oklahoma. Total economic effects are quantified for the key measures of business activity described below (further explained in Appendix A). Note that these are different ways of looking at the same economic effects; they are not additive. • Total expenditures (or total spending) measure change in the volume of dollars changing hands as a result of the economic stimulus. • Gross product (or output) is the change in the level of production of goods and services in the area as a result of the stimulus. This measure is parallel to the gross domestic product numbers commonly reported by various media outlets and is a subset of total expenditures. • Personal income reflects dollars that end up in the hands of people in the area; the vast majority of this aggregate derives from the earnings of employees, but payments such as interest and rents are also included. • Jobs are expressed on a full-time-equivalent basis for ongoing effects or job-years (one person working for one year, though it could be multiple individuals working partial years) for multi-year impacts or temporary stimuli such as construction. Monetary values were quantified on a constant (2023) basis to eliminate the effects of inflation. See Appendix A for additional information regarding the methods and assumptions used in this analysis.
Open PDF at page 13 ↗PDF page 14
9 The Economic and Fiscal Impact of Excessive Tort Costs on Oklahoma Total Excess Tort Costs The Perryman Group quantified the aggregate excess costs associated with the current Oklahoma civil justice system and examined the resulting downstream effects. The Perryman Group estimates the annual losses from excess tort costs in Oklahoma total more than $3.7 billion in gross product each year and almost 32,300 jobs (including multiplier effects). The Estimated Annual Economic Cost Associated with Excessive Tort Costs on Business Activity in Oklahoma Total Expenditures (Billions of 2023 Dollars) Gross Product (Billions of 2023 Dollars) Personal Income (Billions of 2023 Dollars) Employment (Jobs) -$7.289 -$3.739 -$2.382 32,297 Note: Based on The Perryman Group’s estimate of excess costs of the Oklahoma tort system and related dynamic effects. Additional definitions of terms and explanation of methods and assumptions may be found elsewhere in this report and in Appendix A. Results by industry are included in Appendix B. Source: US Multi-Regional Impact Assessment System, The Perryman Group Over the 2020 through 2023 time-period, the excess tort costs in Oklahoma led to a cumulative estimated loss in gross product of almost $14.9 billion and 128,500 job-years (including multiplier effects). A job- year is one person working for one year, though it could be multiple individuals working partial years.
Open PDF at page 14 ↗PDF page 15
10 The Economic and Fiscal Impact of Excessive Tort Costs on Oklahoma The Estimated Cumulative Costs (2020-2023) Associated with Excessive Tort Costs on Business Activity in Oklahoma Total Expenditures (Billions of 2023 Dollars) Gross Product (Billions of 2023 Dollars) Personal Income (Billions of 2023 Dollars) Employment (Job-Years) -$29.005 -$14.878 -$9.479 -128,514 Note: Based on The Perryman Group’s estimate of excess costs of the Oklahoma tort system and related dynamic effects. The period from 2020-2023 represented the approximate time frame subsequent to the removal of caps on non-economic damages. Employment is measured in job-years (one person working for one year, though it could be multiple individuals working partial years). Additional definitions of terms and explanation of methods and assumptions may be found elsewhere in this report and in Appendix A. Results by industry are included in Appendix B. Source: US Multi-Regional Impact Assessment System, The Perryman Group Losses Due the Removal of Caps on Noneconomic Damages As noted, a contributing factor to overall excess tort costs and related economic effects is the 2019 removal of caps on noneconomic damages. The Perryman Group estimates the cumulative losses over the 2020 through 2023 time horizon associated with elimination of non-economic damages caps total almost $2.7 billion in gross product and 20,330 job-years including multiplier effects. (Note that these losses are a subset of the overall totals previously described.)
Open PDF at page 15 ↗PDF page 16
11 The Economic and Fiscal Impact of Excessive Tort Costs on Oklahoma The Estimated Cumulative Costs (2020-2023) Associated with the Elimination of Non-Economic Damage Caps on Business Activity in Oklahoma Total Expenditures (Billions of 2023 Dollars) Gross Product (Billions of 2023 Dollars) Personal Income (Billions of 2023 Dollars) Employment (Job-Years) -$5.716 -$2.668 -$1.459 -20,330 Note: Based on The Perryman Group’s estimate of the portion of excess costs of the Oklahoma tort system related to removal of the cap on noneconomic damages and related dynamic effects. The period from 2020- 2023 represented the approximate time frame subsequent to the removal of caps on non-economic damages. Employment is measured in job-years (one person working for one year, though it could be multiple individuals working partial years). Additional definitions of terms and explanation of methods and assumptions may be found elsewhere in this report and in Appendix A. Results by industry are included in Appendix B. Source: US Multi-Regional Impact Assessment System, The Perryman Group The removal of the non-economic damage caps contributed to a significant portion of the excessive tort costs from 2020 through 2023 including approximately 19.7% of the lost expenditures, 17.9% of decreased gross product, 15.4% of the decrease in personal income and 15.8% of the lost employment. Fiscal Effects Business activity generates tax revenue, and the economic losses associated with excess tort costs decrease tax receipts to the State and local government entities. Tax effects were estimated based on the decrease in economic activity quantified by The Perryman Group and described in the preceding sections. For example, retail sales decrease as a result of the economic effects measured in this study (results appear in Appendix B). A portion of these retail sales would be taxable, leading to decreased receipts to the State and local taxing entities. Similarly, reduced earnings result in lower income tax collections.
Open PDF at page 16 ↗PDF page 17
12 The Economic and Fiscal Impact of Excessive Tort Costs on Oklahoma Economic activity also affects property tax values. Lower incomes associated with the economic losses would decrease housing demand, leading to lower taxable values as well as a decreased need for houses. In addition, decreased retail sales and incomes negatively affect the need for commercial space such as restaurants, retail outlets, and personal service facilities. Lower property values decrease related taxes. When the total economic effects are considered (such as those measured in this study), the tax losses associated with excess tort costs are significant. The Perryman Group estimates that the annual decrease in tax receipts includes approximately $195.0 million to the State of Oklahoma and $162.5 million to local government entities across the state, with cumulative losses over the 2020 through 2023 period of an estimated $776.1 million to the State and $646.6 million to local government entities. Of these amounts, removal of the cap on noneconomic damages comprised losses of $135.9 million in tax receipts to the State and $102.8 million to local government entities during the 2020 through 2023 period. The Perryman Group estimates that the annual decrease in tax receipts due to excess tort costs includes approximately $195.0 million to the State of Oklahoma and $162.5 million to local government entities across the state.
Open PDF at page 17 ↗PDF page 18
13 The Economic and Fiscal Impact of Excessive Tort Costs on Oklahoma Potential Impact on Economic Development The Perryman Group has extensive experience in the area of economic development and has studied the relationship between the civil justice system and economic growth in a variety of contexts including access, supply and compensation of judicial personnel, adequate court records, and numerous types of judicial reforms. A balanced civil justice system is an important aspect of fundamental economic health and development, which involves much of what state government does on an ongoing basis. Economic development hinges on an environment conducive to doing business, and an unbalanced civil justice system can be a deterrent. Areas where awards are unpredictable and insurance costs are higher, for example, can be less attractive for business investment and, hence, economic growth. Basic factors such as workforce availability, infrastructure, regulatory environment, cost structure, and proximity to customers are essential elements of economic development. However, excess tort costs can make a state less competitive and, thus, also play a role in the state’s ability to attract desirable corporate locations and expansions. The Perryman Group projected the reduction in potential economic development and resulting smaller size of the economy in Oklahoma as of 2033 compared to a situation in which excess tort costs were eliminated. The inputs to these projections are based on studies of the relationship between economic growth and the civil justice system and excess tort costs. The Perryman Group estimates the annual economic development losses as of 2033 associated with excess tort costs in Oklahoma total about $4.7 billion in annual gross product and almost 29,500 jobs (including multiplier effects). Economic development hinges on an environment conducive to doing business, and an unbalanced civil justice system can be a deterrent.
Open PDF at page 18 ↗PDF page 19
14 The Economic and Fiscal Impact of Excessive Tort Costs on Oklahoma The Estimated Annual Economic Development Losses As of 2033 Associated with Excess Tort Costs in Oklahoma Total Expenditures (Billions of 2023 Dollars) Gross Product (Billions of 2023 Dollars) Personal Income (Billions of 2023 Dollars) Employment (Jobs) -$9.522 -$4.703 -$2.279 -29,494 Note: Based on The Perryman Group’s estimate of growth in the Oklahoma economy assuming the current situation compared to one in which excess tort costs and related economic development constraints are eliminated. Additional definitions of terms and explanation of methods and assumptions may be found elsewhere in this report and in Appendix A. Results by industry are included in Appendix B. Source: US Multi-Regional Impact Assessment System, The Perryman Group The cumulative losses in economic development for the period 2024 through 2033 associated with excess tort costs in Oklahoma total about $24.1 billion in gross product and almost 155,900 job-years including multiplier effects. The Estimated Cumulative Economic Development Losses from 2024 through 2033 Associated with Excess Tort Costs in Oklahoma Total Expenditures (Billions of 2023 Dollars) Gross Product (Billions of 2023 Dollars) Personal Income (Billions of 2023 Dollars) Employment (Job-Years) $48.724 $24.066 $11.662 155,876 Note: Based on The Perryman Group’s estimate of growth in the Oklahoma economy assuming the current situation compared to one in which excess tort costs and related economic development constraints are eliminated over the 2024 through 2033 period. Employment is measured in job-years (one person working for one year, though it could be multiple individuals working partial years). Additional definitions of terms and explanation of methods and assumptions may be found elsewhere in this report and in Appendix A. Results by industry are included in Appendix B. Source: US Multi-Regional Impact Assessment System, The Perryman Group
Open PDF at page 19 ↗PDF page 20
15 The Economic and Fiscal Impact of Excessive Tort Costs on Oklahoma Conclusion A properly functioning civil justice system is essential to long-term economic growth, opportunity, and competitiveness. Excess tort costs (including the removal of caps on noneconomic damages) lead to a diversion of scarce societal resources, and economic costs which ultimately affect individuals, businesses, and overall growth prospects. The costs of excess torts to the Oklahoma economy are substantial. Moreover, the civil justice environment in the state curtails potential economic development, leading to additional losses to individuals, businesses, and government entities across the state. In summary, excess tort costs impose substantial short-term and long-term harms to Oklahoma and its citizens. Excess tort costs impose substantial short-term and long-term harms to Oklahoma and its citizens.
Open PDF at page 20 ↗PDF page 21
16 The Economic and Fiscal Impact of Excessive Tort Costs on Oklahoma Appendix A: Methods Used US Multi-Regional Impact Assessment System Overview The US Multi-Regional Impact Assessment System (USMRIAS) measures multiplier effects of economic stimuli. The USMRIAS was developed and is maintained by The Perryman Group. This model has been used in hundreds of diverse applications across the country and has an excellent reputation for accuracy and credibility; it has also been peer reviewed on multiple occasions and has been a key factor in major national and international policy simulations. The basic modeling technique is known as dynamic input-output analysis, which essentially uses extensive survey data, industry information, and a variety of corroborative source materials to create a matrix describing the various goods and services (known as resources or inputs) required to produce one unit (a dollar’s worth) of output for a given sector. Once the base information is compiled, it can be mathematically simulated to generate evaluations of the magnitude of successive rounds of activity involved in the overall production process. There are two essential steps in conducting an input-output analysis once the system is operational. The first major endeavor is to accurately define the levels of direct activity to be evaluated. In order to measure the effects of excessive tort costs on the United States economy and its various states (including Oklahoma), it is initially necessary to estimate the current overall direct costs of the liability system. One key input to this analysis stems from a 2022 study sponsored by the Institute for Legal Reform of the US Chamber of Commerce. This assessment included a detailed review of insurance claims and other data across a spectrum of categories. It was estimated that, as of 2020, the aggregate outlays were $442.966 billion.21 Another consistent source of estimates of the magnitude of the tort system that was maintained for many years dating back to the 1950s has been periodic reports by Towers Watson and its predecessors. Although this measure has not 21 Tort Costs in America An Empirical Analysis of Costs and Compensation of the US Tort System, US Chamber of Commerce Institute for Legal Reform, November 2022.
Open PDF at page 21 ↗PDF page 22
17 The Economic and Fiscal Impact of Excessive Tort Costs on Oklahoma been updated in recent years, the lengthy available time series exhibits a high (between 94% and 98%) degree of correlation with standard economic data series related to the legal system that are provided by the Bureau of Economic Analysis and the Bureau of the Census and exhibiting statistical significance at the 0.01 level.22 Consequently, it can be estimated and projected forward using models that are statistically significant and exhibit excellent empirical properties. The Towers Watson values are based on insurance industry data related to benefit payments and legal and administrative expenses with appropriate adjustments. They capture several aspects of the overall cost of the litigation system but fail to fully incorporate efficiency losses and administrative costs because excessive tort costs typically represent a tax on economic activity. As a result, it may be estimated using well-established methods analogous to the "welfare triangle" approach to taxation effects.23 The approach has been widely used in numerous contexts, including prior studies of this issue.24 The incremental administrative burden imposed by an inefficient and costly tort system may be conceptualized by the economic framework of rent seeking and rent avoiding behavior.25 TPG implemented these various modifications to the Towers Watson approach and estimated the overall cost of the system to be 22 US Tort Cost Trends, 2011 Update, Towers Watson, 2012. 23 See, for example, Jorgenson, Dale W. and Kun-Young Yun, Investment, Vol. 3: Lifting the Burden: Tax Reform, the Cost of Capital, and U.S. Economic Growth (Cambridge, Mass.: MIT Press, 2001). The original estimation concept was presented in Harberger, Arnold C., Monopoly and Resource Allocation, American Economic Review 44 (1954), pp. 77–87. 24 See, for example, President’s Council of Economic Advisers, Who Pays for Tort Liability Claims? An Economic Analysis of the US Tort Liability System (April 2002), p. 12; Economic Benefits of Tort Reform, An Assessment of Excessive US Tort Costs and Potential Economic Benefits of Reform, The Perryman Group, 2022; Economic Benefits of Tort Reform, An Assessment of Excessive US Tort Costs and Potential Economic Benefits of Reform, The Perryman Group, 2023; An Assessment of Excessive Tort Costs in California and Potential Economic Benefits of Reform, The Perryman Group, 2019; An Assessment of Excessive Tort Costs in Florida and Potential Economic Benefits of Reform, The Perryman Group, 2019; An Assessment of Excessive Tort Costs in Illinois and Potential Economic Benefits of Reform, The Perryman Group, 2019; An Assessment of Excessive Tort Costs in Louisiana and Potential Economic Benefits of Reform, The Perryman Group, 2019; An Assessment of Excessive Tort Costs in Missouri and Potential Economic Benefits of Reform, The Perryman Group, 2019; An Assessment of Excessive Tort Costs in West Virginia and Potential Economic Benefits of Reform, The Perryman Group, 2019; and The Impact of the Proposed Judicial Reforms in House Bill 4 (HB4) on Business Activity in Texas: An Initial Assessment, The Perryman Group, 2003. 25 The classic reference outlining this process is Tullock, Gordon, The Welfare Costs of Tariffs, Monopolies and Theft, Western Economic Journal 5 (1967), pp. 224–32.
Open PDF at page 22 ↗PDF page 23
18 The Economic and Fiscal Impact of Excessive Tort Costs on Oklahoma $478.214 billion as of 2016. This value is highly comparable to (modestly above) the estimate from the Institute for Legal Reform. For purposes of conservatism in the analysis, the lower value was adopted. It was then projected forward using the econometric model described below to generate a current estimate of $614.9 billion. This level was used as the starting point in defining the direct excess costs incurred in each step. It must be noted that, as described in the report, it is essential in any advanced economy to have a robust framework to protect intellectual property, sustain the legal framework, adjudicate legitimate disputes, and provide a viable platform for business activity. Thus, there are necessary and legitimate costs associated with the judicial system. The next step in this investigation was to determine the portion of the costs quantified above which constitutes an excessive burden. Numerous studies have compared the relative outlays associated with the tort process in various countries.26 By comparing the costs (as a percentage of the Gross Domestic Product) in other developed areas with similar standards of living and well-developed judicial systems (such as the European Union), it is possible to determine a reasonable estimate of the level of resources required to support an efficient and well-functioning tort resolution process. TPG integrated this information into the computation process and found that $247.0 billion of the outlays were necessary and, thus, the excessive burden was $367.8 billion. This amount is likely understated in that (1) the benchmark countries include several positive outliers, thus overstating the actual resource commitment that is needed and (2) the percentage of US output absorbed by the tort process has expanded markedly since this assessment was completed. Once the US burden is quantified, it is necessary to allocate the aggregate amount across the 50 states and the District of Columbia. The requirements are estimated based on overall economic and demographic magnitudes, that is, larger business complexes and populations generate the need for higher outlays. This process is used to measure the proportion of the estimated cost that is appropriate for each area. The total system expenditures in the various locales are then approximated based on the concentration of factors which are indicative of the extent of tort activity as described above. The differential between the required and overall system costs constitutes the direct excessive burden in each state. 26 See, for example, International Comparison of Litigation Costs, Canada, Europe, Japan, and the United States, US Chamber, Institute for Legal Reform, June 2013 update.
Open PDF at page 23 ↗PDF page 24
19 The Economic and Fiscal Impact of Excessive Tort Costs on Oklahoma The final task prior to implementation of the impact assessment model is the allocation of the excess costs across industrial categories. This determination is accomplished using the direct requirements coefficients from the USMRIAS for segments of activity that are correlated with tort expenses. This approach requires assignment of effects across more than 500 sectors reflecting the composition of each economy. The resulting values become the inputs for the individual simulations that are conducted in the second phase of the empirical analysis. The Perryman Group estimated the direct costs associated with removal of the caps on noneconomic damages based on detailed data related to excess tort costs by industry, studies of outcomes in other areas, and the firm’s extensive databases and systems. The years 2020 through 2023 were used because it approximates the period after the caps were removed. More specifically, data from the US Census Bureau’s County Business Patterns was merged with data from the Bureau of Economic Analysis of the US Department of Commerce in order to obtain an estimate of the total costs associated with property and casualty insurance, which is the primary source of harms associated with removing the caps. This phase of the modeling effort resulted in baseline estimates for Oklahoma as of 2021 (the latest year for which data was available). The Perryman Group’s US Multi-Regional Econometric Model (which is described in Appendix A) was then used to project these costs for 2023 based on changes in the state economy since that time. Direct costs were then allocated across 500 industry sectors based on typical insurance costs by industry using the coefficients from The Perryman Group’s US Multi-Regional Impact Assessment System (described in Appendix A). The result was an allocation across the economy of total estimated current direct costs of property and casualty insurance. In order to test this phase of the modeling process, these allocated direct costs of insurance (which provide a measure of total output/gross product for insurance) were compared to the portion of total expenditures by industry which were for insurance. These two approaches to measuring output/gross product for insurance were found to yield virtually identical results, supporting the validity of the approach. The next phase of the analysis involved reviewing empirical analyses of impacts of tort costs including the role of caps on noneconomic damages. After reviewing a number of evaluations, an assessment by the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation
Open PDF at page 24 ↗PDF page 25
20 The Economic and Fiscal Impact of Excessive Tort Costs on Oklahoma was judged to be appropriate for this analysis.27 This study examined an array of analyses and found that they indicated reductions in awards for noneconomic damages ranging from 23% to 31% for states studied. The mean direct cost increase was used in defining incremental costs. Note that use of this assessment introduces an element of conservatism; as noted in the prior section, many other analyses have indicated higher cost increases in the absence of caps. These incremental costs represent a deadweight loss to the economy that will be borne by businesses and consumers within the state. The estimated direct effects were used in a simulation of the input-output system to measure total overall economic effects (not only direct, but also indirect and induced). The system used reflects the unique industrial structure of the Oklahoma economy. Model Structure The USMRIAS is somewhat similar in format to the Input-Output Model of the United States which is maintained by the US Department of Commerce. The model developed by TPG, however, incorporates several important enhancements and refinements. Specifically, the expanded system includes (1) comprehensive 500-sector coverage for any county, multi-county, or urban region; (2) calculation of both total expenditures and value-added by industry and region; (3) direct estimation of expenditures for multiple basic input choices (expenditures, output, income, or employment); (4) extensive parameter localization; (5) price adjustments for real and nominal assessments by sectors and areas; (6) comprehensive measurement of the induced impacts associated with payrolls and consumer spending; (7) embedded modules to estimate multi-sectoral direct spending effects; (8) estimation of retail spending activity by consumers; and (9) comprehensive linkage and integration capabilities with a wide variety of econometric, real estate, occupational, and fiscal impact models. The impact assessment (input-output) process essentially estimates the amounts of all types of goods and services required to produce one unit (a dollar’s worth) of a specific type of output. For purposes of illustrating the nature of the system, it is useful to think of inputs and outputs in dollar (rather than physical) terms. As an example, the construction of a new building will require specific dollar amounts of lumber, glass, concrete, hand tools, architectural services, interior design services, paint, plumbing, and numerous other elements. Each of these suppliers 27 Mello, Michelle M., Research Synthesis Report No. 10—Medical Malpractice: Impact of the Crisis and Effect of State Tort Reforms, The Robert Wood Johnson Foundation, May 2006.
Open PDF at page 25 ↗PDF page 26
21 The Economic and Fiscal Impact of Excessive Tort Costs on Oklahoma must, in turn, purchase additional dollar amounts of inputs. This process continues through multiple rounds of production, thus generating subsequent increments to business activity. The initial process of building the facility is known as the direct effect. The ensuing transactions in the output chain constitute the indirect effect. Another pattern that arises in response to any direct economic activity comes from the payroll dollars received by employees at each stage of the production cycle. As workers are compensated, they use some of their income for taxes, savings, and purchases from external markets. A substantial portion, however, is spent locally on food, clothing, health care services, utilities, housing, recreation, and other items. Typical purchasing patterns in the relevant areas are obtained from the Center for Community and Economic Research Cost of Living Index, a privately compiled inter-regional measure which has been widely used for several decades, and the Consumer Expenditure Survey of the US Department of Labor. These initial outlays by area residents generate further secondary activity as local providers acquire inputs to meet this consumer demand. These consumer spending impacts are known as the induced effect. The USMRIAS is designed to provide realistic, yet conservative, estimates of these phenomena. Sources for information used in this process include the Bureau of the Census, the Bureau of Labor Statistics, the Regional Economic Information System of the US Department of Commerce, and other public and private sources. The pricing data are compiled from the US Department of Labor and the US Department of Commerce. The verification and testing procedures make use of extensive public and private sources. Impacts are typically measured in constant dollars to eliminate the effects of inflation. The USMRIAS is also integrated with a comprehensive fiscal model, which links the tax payments by industry to the specific rates and structures associated with the relevant State and local governmental authorities. Measures of Business Activity The USMRIAS generates estimates of total economic effects on several measures of business activity. Note that these are different ways of measuring the same impacts; they are not additive. The most comprehensive measure of economic activity is Total Expenditures. This measure incorporates every dollar that changes hands in any transaction. For example, suppose a farmer sells wheat to a miller for $0.50; the miller then sells flour to a baker for $0.75; the baker, in turn, sells bread to a customer for $1.25.
Open PDF at page 26 ↗PDF page 27
22 The Economic and Fiscal Impact of Excessive Tort Costs on Oklahoma The Total Expenditures recorded in this instance would be $2.50, that is, $0.50 + $0.75 + $1.25. This measure is quite broad but is useful in that (1) it reflects the overall interplay of all industries in the economy, and (2) some key fiscal variables such as sales taxes are linked to aggregate spending. A second measure of business activity is Gross Product. This indicator represents the regional equivalent of Gross Domestic Product, the most commonly reported statistic regarding national economic performance. In other words, the Gross Product of Texas is the amount of US output that is produced in that state; it is defined as the value of all final goods produced in a given region for a specific period of time. Stated differently, it captures the amount of value-added (gross area product) over intermediate goods and services at each stage of the production process, that is, it eliminates the double counting in the Total Expenditures concept. Using the example above, the Gross Product is $1.25 (the value of the bread) rather than $2.50. Alternatively, it may be viewed as the sum of the value-added by the farmer, $0.50; the miller, $0.25 ($0.75 - $0.50); and the baker, $0.50 ($1.25 - $0.75). The total value-added is, therefore, $1.25, which is equivalent to the final value of the bread. In many industries, the primary component of value-added is the wage and salary payments to employees. The third gauge of economic activity used in this evaluation is Personal Income. As the name implies, Personal Income is simply the income received by individuals, whether in the form of wages, salaries, interest, dividends, proprietors’ profits, or other sources. It may thus be viewed as the segment of overall impacts which flows directly to the citizenry. The final aggregates used are Jobs and Job-Years, which reflect the full-time equivalent jobs generated by an activity. For an economic stimulus expected to endure (such as the ongoing operations of a facility), the Jobs measure is used. It should be noted that, unlike the dollar values described above, Jobs is a “stock” rather than a “flow.” In other words, if an area produces $1 million in output in 2022 and $1 million in 2023, it is appropriate to say that $2 million was achieved in the 2022-23 period. If the same area has 100 people working in 2022 and 100 in 2023, it only has 100 Jobs. When a flow of jobs is measured, such as in a construction project or a cumulative assessment over multiple years, it is appropriate to measure employment in Job-Years (a person working for a year, though it could be multiple individuals working for partial years). This concept is distinct from Jobs, which anticipates that the relevant positions will be maintained on a continuing basis.
Open PDF at page 27 ↗PDF page 28
23 The Economic and Fiscal Impact of Excessive Tort Costs on Oklahoma US Multi-Regional Econometric Model A submodel of The Perryman Group’s econometric model was developed for Oklahoma and used in quantifying the economic development effects of excess tort costs. Baseline projections were generated assuming the current excess tort costs persist. Potential effects on growth trajectories associated with decreasing the tort cost burden were quantified based on studies of the relationship between economic development and civil justice systems.28 The resulting differential provides an estimate of the costs of maintaining the current system. The US Multi-Regional Econometric Model was developed by Dr. M. Ray Perryman, President and CEO of The Perryman Group (TPG), about 40 years ago and has been consistently maintained, expanded, and updated since that time. It is formulated in an internally consistent manner and is designed to permit the integration of relevant global, national, state, and local factors into the projection process. It is the result of four decades of continuing research in econometrics, economic theory, statistical methods, and key policy issues and behavioral patterns, as well as intensive, ongoing study of all aspects of the global, US, state, and metropolitan area economies. It is extensively used by scores of federal and State governmental entities on an ongoing basis, as well as hundreds of major corporations. It can be integrated with The Perryman Group’s other models and systems to provide dynamic projections. This section describes the forecasting process in a comprehensive manner, focusing on both the modeling and the supplemental analysis. The overall methodology, while certainly not ensuring perfect foresight, permits an enormous body of relevant information to impact the economic outlook in a systematic manner. Model Logic and Structure The Model revolves around a core system which projects output (real and nominal), income (real and nominal), and employment by industry in a simultaneous manner. For the purposes of illustration, it is useful to initially consider the employment functions. Essentially, employment within the system is 28 See, for example, Koch, James V. and Richard J. Cebula, “Do Lawyers Inhibit Economic Growth? New Evidence from the 50 US States,” Journal of Economic Development, Volume 4, Number 3 September 2023; “The Site Selection Guide,” US General Services Administration, Public Building Services, Office of the Chief Architect, (n.d.); and King White, “10 Critical Factors to Consider During Corporate Site Selection,” Site Selection Group, March 14, 2024.
Open PDF at page 28 ↗PDF page 29
24 The Economic and Fiscal Impact of Excessive Tort Costs on Oklahoma a derived demand relationship obtained from a neo-Classical production function. The expressions are augmented to include dynamic temporal adjustments to changes in relative factor input costs, output and (implicitly) productivity, and technological progress over time. Thus, the typical equation includes output, the relative real cost of labor and capital, dynamic lag structures, and a technological adjustment parameter. The functional form is logarithmic, thus preserving the theoretical consistency with the neo-Classical formulation. The income segment of the model is divided into wage and non-wage components. The wage equations, like their employment counterparts, are individually estimated at the 3-digit North American Industry Classification System (NAICS) level of aggregation. Hence, income by place of work is measured for approximately 90 production categories. The wage equations measure real compensation, with the form of the variable structure differing between “basic” and “non-basic.” The basic industries, comprised primarily of the various components of Mining, Agriculture, and Manufacturing, are export-oriented, i.e., they bring external dollars into the area and form the core of the economy. The production of these sectors typically flows into national and international markets; hence, the labor markets are influenced by conditions in areas beyond the borders of the particular region. Thus, real (inflation-adjusted) wages in the basic industry are expressed as a function of the corresponding national rates, as well as measures of local labor market conditions (the reciprocal of the unemployment rate), dynamic adjustment parameters, and ongoing trends. The “non-basic” sectors are somewhat different in nature, as the strength of their labor markets is linked to the health of the local export sectors. Consequently, wages in these industries are related to those in the basic segment of the economy. The relationship also includes the local labor market measures contained in the basic wage equations. Note that compensation rates in the export or “basic” sectors provide a key element of the interaction of the regional economies with national and international market phenomena, while the “non-basic” or local industries are strongly impacted by area production levels. Given the wage and employment equations, multiplicative identities in each industry provide expressions for total compensation; these totals may then be aggregated to determine aggregate wage and salary income. Simple linkage equations are then estimated for the calculation of personal income by place of work.
Open PDF at page 29 ↗PDF page 30
25 The Economic and Fiscal Impact of Excessive Tort Costs on Oklahoma The non-labor aspects of personal income are modeled at the regional level using straightforward empirical expressions relating to national performance, dynamic responses, and evolving temporal patterns. In some instances (such as dividends, rents, and others) national variables (for example, interest rates) directly enter the forecasting system. These factors have numerous other implicit linkages into the system resulting from their simultaneous interaction with other phenomena in national and international markets which are explicitly included in various expressions. The output or gross area product expressions are also developed at the 3-digit NAICS level. Regional output for basic industries is linked to national performance in the relevant industries, local and national production in key related sectors, relative area and national labor costs in the industry, dynamic adjustment parameters, and ongoing changes in industrial interrelationships (driven by technological changes in production processes). Output in the non-basic sectors is modeled as a function of basic production levels, output in related local support industries (if applicable), dynamic temporal adjustments, and ongoing patterns. The inter-industry linkages are obtained from the input-output (impact assessment) system which is part of the overall integrated modeling structure maintained by The Perryman Group. Note that the dominant component of the econometric system involves the simultaneous estimation and projection of output (real and nominal), income (real and nominal), and employment at a disaggregated industrial level. This process, of necessity, also produces projections of regional price deflators by industry. These values are affected by both national pricing patterns and local cost variations and permit changes in prices to impact other aspects of economic behavior. Income is converted from real to nominal terms using relevant Consumer Price Indices, which fluctuate in response to national pricing patterns and unique local phenomena. Several other components of the model are critical to the forecasting process. The demographic module includes (1) a linkage equation between wage and salary (establishment) employment and household employment, (2) a labor force participation rate function, and (3) a complete population system with endogenous migration. Given household employment, labor force participation (which is a function of economic conditions and evolving patterns of worker preferences), and the working-age population, the unemployment rate and level become identities.
Open PDF at page 30 ↗PDF page 31
26 The Economic and Fiscal Impact of Excessive Tort Costs on Oklahoma The population system uses Census information, fertility rates, and life tables to determine the “natural” changes in population by age group. Migration, the most difficult segment of population dynamics to track, is estimated in relation to relative regional and extra-regional economic conditions over time. Because evolving economic conditions determine migration in the system, population changes are allowed to interact simultaneously with overall economic conditions. Through this process, migration is treated as endogenous to the system, thus allowing population to vary in accordance with relative business performance (particularly employment). Real retail sales is related to income, interest rates, dynamic adjustments, and patterns in consumer behavior on a store group basis. It is expressed on an inflation-adjusted basis. Inflation at the state level relates to national patterns, indicators of relative economic conditions, and ongoing trends. As noted earlier, prices are endogenous to the system. A final significant segment of the forecasting system relates to real estate absorption and activity. The short-term demand for various types of property is determined by underlying economic and demographic factors, with short-term adjustments to reflect the current status of the pertinent building cycle. In some instances, this portion of the forecast requires integration with the US Multi- Regional Industry-Occupation System which is maintained by The Perryman Group. This system also allows any employment simulation or forecast from the econometric model to be translated into a highly detailed occupational profile. The overall US Multi-Regional Econometric Model contains numerous additional specifications, and individual expressions are modified to reflect alternative lag structures, empirical properties of the estimates, simulation requirements, and similar phenomena. Moreover, it is updated on an ongoing basis as new data releases become available. Nonetheless, the above synopsis offers a basic understanding of the overall structure and underlying logic of the system. Model Simulation and Multi-Regional Structure The initial phase of the simulation process is the execution of a standard non- linear algorithm for the state system and that of each of the individual sub-areas. The external assumptions are derived from scenarios developed through national and international models and extensive analysis by The Perryman Group. Once the initial simulations are completed, they are merged into a single system with additive constraints and interregional flows. Using information on minimum
Open PDF at page 31 ↗PDF page 32
27 The Economic and Fiscal Impact of Excessive Tort Costs on Oklahoma regional requirements, import needs, export potential, and locations, it becomes possible to balance the various forecasts into a mathematically consistent set of results. This process is, in effect, a disciplining exercise with regard to the individual regional (including metropolitan and rural) systems. By compelling equilibrium across all regions and sectors, the algorithm ensures that the patterns in state activity are reasonable in light of smaller area dynamics and, conversely, that the regional outlooks are within plausible performance levels for the state as a whole. The iterative simulation process has the additional property of imposing a global convergence criterion across the entire multi-regional system, with balance being achieved simultaneously on both a sectoral and a geographic basis. This approach is particularly critical on non-linear dynamic systems, as independent simulations of individual systems often yield unstable, non-convergent outcomes. It should be noted that the underlying data for the modeling and simulation process are frequently updated and revised by the various public and private entities compiling them. Whenever those modifications to the database occur, they bring corresponding changes to the structural parameter estimates of the various systems and the solutions to the simulation and forecasting system. The multi-regional version of the econometric model is re-estimated and simulated with each such data release, thus providing a constantly evolving and current assessment of state and local business activity. The Final Forecast The process described above is followed to produce an initial set of projections. Through the comprehensive multi-regional modeling and simulation process, a systematic analysis is generated which accounts for both historical patterns in economic performance and inter-relationships and the best available information on the future course of pertinent external factors. While the best available techniques and data are employed in this effort, they are not capable of directly capturing “street sense,” i.e., the contemporaneous and often non-quantifiable information that can materially affect economic outcomes. In order to provide a comprehensive approach to the prediction of business conditions, it is necessary to compile and assimilate extensive material regarding current events and other relevant factors. This critical aspect of the forecasting methodology includes activities such as (1) daily review of hundreds of financial and business publications and electronic information sites; (2) review of major newspapers and online news sources in
Open PDF at page 32 ↗PDF page 33
28 The Economic and Fiscal Impact of Excessive Tort Costs on Oklahoma the state on a daily basis; (3) dozens of hours of direct telephone interviews with key business and political leaders in all parts of the state; (4) face-to-face discussions with representatives of major industry groups; and (5) frequent site visits to the various regions of the state. The insights arising from this “fact finding” are analyzed and evaluated for their effects on the likely course of the future activity. Another vital information resource stems from the firm’s ongoing interaction with key players in the international, domestic, and state economic scenes. Such activities include visiting with corporate groups on a regular basis and being regularly involved in the policy process at all levels. The firm is also an active participant in many major corporate relocations, economic development initiatives, and regulatory proceedings. Once organized, this information is carefully assessed and, when appropriate, independently verified. The impact on specific communities and sectors that is distinct from what is captured by the econometric system is then factored into the forecast analysis. For example, the opening or closing of a major facility, particularly in a relatively small area, can cause a sudden change in business performance that will not be accounted for by either a modeling system based on historical relationships or expected (primarily national and international) factors. The final step in the forecasting process is the integration of this material into the results in a logical and mathematically consistent manner. In some instances, this task is accomplished through “constant adjustment factors” which augment relevant equations. In other cases, anticipated changes in industrial structure or regulatory parameters are initially simulated within the context of the Multi- Regional Impact Assessment System to estimate their ultimate effects by sector. Those findings are then factored into the simulation as constant adjustments on a distributed temporal basis. Once this scenario is formulated, the extended system is again balanced across regions and sectors through an iterative simulation algorithm analogous to that described in the preceding section.
Open PDF at page 33 ↗PDF page 34
29 The Economic and Fiscal Impact of Excessive Tort Costs on Oklahoma Appendix B: Detailed Results The Estimated Annual Impact Associated with Excessive Tort Costs on Business Activity in Oklahoma Results by Industry Industry Total Expenditures Gross Product Personal Income Jobs Agriculture +$103.9 m +$30.7 m +$19.7 m +248 Mining +$164.7 m +$39.7 m +$21.8 m +105 Utilities +$391.1 m +$88.2 m +$38.5 m +135 Construction +$454.4 m +$217.2 m +$179.0 m +2,048 Manufacturing +$1,077.5 m +$356.8 m +$201.4 m +2,354 Wholesale Trade +$278.1 m +$188.2 m +$108.5 m +1,001 Retail Trade* +$945.3 m +$710.8 m +$413.6 m +10,299 Transportation & Warehousing +$276.8 m +$179.7 m +$118.8 m +1,318 Information +$231.8 m +$142.9 m +$61.0 m +444 Financial Activities* +$1,482.9 m +$539.8 m +$205.4 m +1,707 Business Services +$1,069.8 m +$772.6 m +$630.3 m +6,251 Health Services +$295.6 m +$204.3 m +$172.7 m +2,324 Other Services +$517.4 m +$268.0 m +$211.5 m +4,065 Total, All Industries +$7,289.4 m +$3,739.1 m +$2,382.3 m +32,297 Source: US Multi-Regional Impact Assessment System, The Perryman Group Notes: Monetary values given in millions of 2023 US dollars per year. Components may not sum due to independent rounding. Retail Trade includes Restaurants, Financial Activities includes Real Estate.
Open PDF at page 34 ↗PDF page 35
30 The Economic and Fiscal Impact of Excessive Tort Costs on Oklahoma The Estimated Cumulative Impact (2020-2023) of Excessive Tort Costs on Business Activity in Oklahoma* Results by Industry Industry Total Expenditures Gross Product Personal Income Job Years* Agriculture +$413.5 m +$122.1 m +$78.3 m +987 Mining +$655.2 m +$158.0 m +$86.8 m +419 Utilities +$1,556.1 m +$351.1 m +$153.2 m +537 Construction +$1,808.1 m +$864.3 m +$712.3 m +8,151 Manufacturing +$4,287.5 m +$1,419.9 m +$801.4 m +9,366 Wholesale Trade +$1,106.7 m +$748.7 m +$431.7 m +3,982 Retail Trade* +$3,761.3 m +$2,828.4 m +$1,645.6 m +40,979 Transportation & Warehousing +$1,101.5 m +$715.0 m +$472.9 m +5,242 Information +$922.5 m +$568.7 m +$242.8 m +1,766 Financial Activities* +$5,900.7 m +$2,148.0 m +$817.4 m +6,794 Business Services +$4,256.9 m +$3,074.4 m +$2,507.9 m +24,872 Health Services +$1,176.3 m +$812.9 m +$687.3 m +9,246 Other Services +$2,058.8 m +$1,066.5 m +$841.6 m +16,174 Total, All Industries +$29,004.9 m +$14,878.0 m +$9,479.2 m +128,514 Source: US Multi-Regional Impact Assessment System, The Perryman Group Notes: Monetary values given in millions of 2023 US dollars. A job-year is equivalent to one person working for one year. Components may not sum due to independent rounding. Retail Trade includes Restaurants, Financial Activities includes Real Estate. The period from 2020-2023 represented the approximate time frame subsequent to the removal of caps on non-economic damages
Open PDF at page 35 ↗PDF page 36
31 The Economic and Fiscal Impact of Excessive Tort Costs on Oklahoma The Estimated Cumulative Impact (2020-2023) Associated with the Elimination of Non-Economic Damage Caps on Business Activity in Oklahoma* Results by Industry Industry Total Expenditures Gross Product Personal Income Job Years* Agriculture +$103.1 m +$29.8 m +$19.8 m +252 Mining +$346.6 m +$78.8 m +$38.6 m +171 Utilities +$260.0 m +$58.7 m +$25.6 m +87 Construction +$204.0 m +$101.8 m +$83.9 m +956 Manufacturing +$695.5 m +$223.2 m +$128.0 m +1,563 Wholesale Trade +$249.7 m +$168.9 m +$97.4 m +899 Retail Trade* +$663.9 m +$497.9 m +$289.4 m +7,236 Transportation & Warehousing +$260.1 m +$163.1 m +$107.9 m +1,196 Information +$126.4 m +$78.0 m +$33.3 m +238 Financial Activities* +$1,941.3 m +$739.3 m +$199.9 m +1,651 Business Services +$287.1 m +$182.9 m +$149.2 m +1,477 Health Services +$266.6 m +$181.9 m +$153.8 m +2,069 Other Services +$311.4 m +$163.7 m +$131.8 m +2,533 Total, All Industries +$5,715.7 m +$2,667.8 m +$1,458.6 m +20,330 Source: US Multi-Regional Impact Assessment System, The Perryman Group Notes: Monetary values given in millions of 2023 US dollars. A job-year is equivalent to one person working for one year. Components may not sum due to independent rounding. Retail Trade includes Restaurants, Financial Activities includes Real Estate. The period from 2020-2023 represented the approximate time frame subsequent to the removal of caps on non-economic damages
Open PDF at page 36 ↗PDF page 37
The State Chamber Research Foundation strives to support Oklahoma’s growth and increase prosperity for all Oklahomans. We create solution orientated programming, advance research and policy, and provide sound data geared to advancing Oklahoma’s economic climate, workforce, infrastructure, and legal and regulatory environment. The State Chamber Research Foundation is the business community’s think tank. Your support is key to our success and allows us to educate elected leaders about the issues and policies that are critical to a competitive environment. By donating to the Foundation, you are supporting vital programs like these: Competitiveness Data Legislative Scorecard Leadership Exchange Academy All contributions to The State Chamber Research Foundation are tax deductible, in accordance with the IRS code for 501(c)(3) organizations. DONATE TO THE SCRF!
Open PDF at page 37 ↗