Report text
Text extracted from the original PDF. Tables, footnotes, and reading order can differ. Check the PDF before quoting. Page numbers below refer to PDF viewer pages.
PDF page 2
~ OKLAHOMA 2000, INC. _ BOARD OF DIRECTORS | WALTER V. ALLISON Chairman & Chief Executive Officer. WestStar Bank, N.A- ‘Bartlesville __ GILBERT C. GIBSON Chairman of the Board Citizens Bank Lawton, JAMES G. HARLOW, IR. Chairman of the Board, President & CEO Oklahoma Gas & Electric Company Oklahoma City : ROBERT. Ss. KERR, JR. President Kerr Foundation, Inc. Oklahoma City. : FRANK A MCPHERSON- : _ Chairman of the Board & CEO. _ Kerr-McGee Corpor: ation : OK! ahoma City. DONALD A. MURRY Professor of Economics _ College of Arts and Science — i ity of Oklahoma . RHOADES. esident & Chief Executive Officer : _ DREW ROY oe : President - Oklahoma Division = Southwestern Bell Telephone Company : Oklahoma City RICHARD P. RUSH : President & Chief Executive officer The Oklahoma State Chamber of Commerce and Industry ‘ Oklahoma City ROBERT L. SANDMEYER Dean College of Business Administration. Oklahoma State Univer: sity Stillwater —gD.SCOTT _ ~ Chairman of the Board, Pr esident, & CEO a8 ONEOK Ine. :
Open PDF at page 2 ↗PDF page 3
TABLE OF CONTENTS Preface Chapter I The New State Finance Environment Budget Implications Survey Results Revenues Expenditure Impaets Perspective Chapter II The State Budgeting Cycle and the Balanced Budget Requirement. The History of the Constitutional Reserve Fund Certified Funds for Fiscal Year 1995 The Growth of Fees to Fund State Government, Chapter OT Attitudes of Oklahomans Toward State and Local Taxes and Expenditures National Norms Perception of Value and Knowledge Indicators Attitudes Toward Specifie Programs Attitudes Toward Sources of Revenue The Citizen Psyehe Conclusions Chapter IV Prospects for State Expenditures Elementary and Secondary Education Higher Education Corrections and Juvenile Justice Health Care Chapter V Responding to Tax Limitations by Developing Non-Tax Revenues An Oklahoma Lottery A Tuition Increase Fee for Service: The Turnpike Authority iv 13 21
Open PDF at page 3 ↗PDF page 4
PREFACE he approval of State Question 640 has altered the structure and processes of state finance. It requires that tax measures must go to a vote of the people if they fail to get a supermajority in both houses of the Oklahoma Legislature, The supermajority requirement sets Oklahoma apart from the many budget limitation policies recently established in many states. Six professors at the University of Oklahoma and Oklahoma State Uni- versity began an analysis of the impact of the State Question 640 upon the processes of state finance nearly two years ago. The team’s primary research interest has been on the longer-term implications for economic development. This report, the first published from this longer- term study, is an analysis of several important issues in the fiscal 1995 budgeting, Taken together they characterize the emerging structural change to state finance. The research team's findings indicate that these developments are evidence of a longer-term pattern of state finance in Oklahoma, and in that regard, this pattern previews the state’s revenue-expenditure future, ‘The project has been co-directed by Dr. Donald Murry, Professor of Economies at OU and Dr. Larkin Warner, Regents Professor at OSU. Other members of the research team are Dr. Robert Dauffenbach, Director of the Center for Economic and Management Researeh, OU, Dr. Mary Gade, Associate Professor of Economics, OSU, Dr. Alexander Holmes, Regents Professor of Econam- ies, OU, and Dr. Kent Olson, Professor of Eeonam- ics, OSU, As in previous reports by Oklahoma 2000, Inc., the research team has determined the research direction and the topics selected for study. The views selected herein aye those of the authors and should not be attributed to the officers and diree- tors of Oklahoma 2000, Inc.
Open PDF at page 4 ↗PDF page 5
CHAPTER I THE NEW STATE FINANCE ENVIRONMENT tate Question 640, adopted by a 57 percent majority of Oklahoma’s voters on March 10, 1992, was an effort by the electorate to capture control of state level taxation. Simply stated, the measure requires that the voters review all state tax changes in the next general election if a “rev- enue bill” passes either house of the legislature with less than a three-quarters majority. The limitations imposed by State Question 640, coupled with the restraining influence of Oklahoma’s budget balancing amendment, will unquestionably alter the revenue and expendi- ture structure of Oklahoma state government. A new pattern of funding state government services is emerging and, while its outlines are not yet fully apparent, certain implications are becoming clear. Careful observation can help Oklahomans gain insight into what their new-found power to control taxes will mean for the future of state government finance. This special report addresses some of the near- term effects of State Question 640’s passage— effects that are likely to be important issues in the current and next fiscal years’ budgeting process. It is part of a more extensive study of the long-term impact of State Question 640 upon state revenues and budgeting in Oklahoma. Budget Implications To put the revenue implications of State Ques- tion 640 in perspective, the authors investigated the constitutional amendment in the context of Oklahoma’s taxing and budgeting history, com- pared the tax limitation measure with those in other states, and surveyed current attitudes of Oklahoma voters. Historically, Oklahomans have limited the spending authority of state officials, and, in that regard, State Question 640 is not an anomaly. Limits upon appropriations or taxes in other state governments are also not uncommon, but bypass- ing those limits is easier in most states than in Oklahoma. In comparison to tax limitation mea- sures in other states, State Question 640 stands out because it contains the “supermajority” provi- sion. The requirement that a tax proposal be approved by a 75 percent vote in each house of the legislature or be referred to the electorate for a decision means that future tax measures in Okla- homa are likely to go to a vote of the people. Even ifthe voters would approve a tax increase that fails to achieve the necessary legislative majority, most new tax measures will have to wait to get ona ballot at a subsequent general election. This built- in delay in getting revenue items to the electorate compels the Governor and the legislature to struc- ture any given year’s budget by taking into account only the forecasted revenues from existing sources. Using the current budget year to assess the impact of State Question 640 is illuminating. A budget shortfall existed in fiscal year 1994 and another is likely to occur for fiscal 1995. Although the economy is expanding and some important funding sources will surely increase, revenue fore- casts suggest that new revenues will fail to keep pace with the expected growth in expenditures. The shortfall in 1994 was handled by using one- time funds from reserves; however, that potential is diminished for fiscal 1995. Consequently, the fiscal 1995 budget is likely to pose the first real test of government actions in the post-State Question 640 era. Already, this environment is stimulating proposals for expanding government services through mechanisms that bypass the state’s rev- enue constraints. These proposals are the early manifestations of longer-term structural changes that will affect Oklahoma’s financial future. Survey Results This study included a telephone survey of Okla- homa voter attitudes toward governmental finance. The survey was undertaken by the University of Oklahoma’s Center for Economic and Manage- ment Research in September and October of 1993. The survey results indicate that the state’s voters are strongly opposed to tax increases, prefer expen- diture reductions to tax increases, support bal- anced government budgets, and have a general distrust of politicians and government officials. The respondents, however, were not uniformly and consistently anti-government. Views of taxa- tion are negative; for example, 82 percent oppose
Open PDF at page 5 ↗PDF page 6
raising the personal income tax and 73 percent oppose raising the sales tax to meet state needs, However, there are also strong demands for key state government services in the fields of education, health care, public welfare, and services related to the quality of life, Respondents demonstrated a greater willingness to increase taxes for specific purposes than if the proceeds are for government in general, This suggests some degree of acceptance of earmarked taxes. Moreover, the survey suggested that Oklahomans tend to accept use taxes linked to particular services. Revenues Given the combined effects of the budget balane- ing amendment and State Question 640, Oklahoma is moving toward alternative forms of financing state government services. This study specifically examined three types of funding alternatives: a state lottery, an increase in higher education tu- ition, and turnpike construction, The current lottery proposal would provide a new source of revenue for Oklahoma's state govern- ment, although there are indications that voter approval would simply signal a desire to “play the fame,” rather than exhibit willingness to fund an- other tax source. Lottery revenues are likely to be earmarked for specific services but, under the eir- cumstances, that may not be a factor in voter ap- preval. In any event, approval of a lottery would establish only arelatively minor new revenue source, The other two major proposals for revenue in= vestigated here are increases in fees for service. One is the current proposal for a tuition increase for higher education; the other is the proposal toexpand the state highway system through new turnpike construction, Although each is a special case, to- gether these plans suggest.a pattern. Ibis difficult to enhance the funding sources that are capable of producing the most revenue; thus, alternative pro- posalsare likely to target smaller revenue sources or services that generate their own revenues. Expenditure Impacts The current budgeting mechanism in Oklahoma becomes an effective limit when there is a shortfall in revenues relative to the growth in expenditures for existing services. That raises the question of the prospects for increases in expenditures. In this con- text, the research team investigated three areas of hard-to-avoid pressures upon the state budget— education, criminal justice, and health care. Anincrease in elementary and secondary educa- tion funding for fiscal 1995 was mandated by earlier legiglation—House Bill 1017, In addition, enrollments have exceeded levels forecasted at the time of the education reform measure’s passage and, if these enrollment gains are included in the calculation of costs to fund House Bill 1017 in fiseal 1995, common. education will claim a large share of growth in state appropriations. The Oklahoma State Regents for Higher Education are requesting an even larger share of new revenues than the common schools as they face the task of developing a new budget that builds on a fiscal 1994 budget funded partially with one-time funds, Concerns about crime and violence are given a high priority in Oklahoma by the public and by political leaders. Responding to these concerns will mean additional allocations to the criminal justice system and could lead to some new funding meth- ads, such as the proposed Criminal Justice Trust Authority. Health care is a major national issue that will affect Oklahoma’s budget during fiscal 1995. State government, which in 1993 spent at least $1.9 billion on health related services, is an operator of hospi- tals, an insurer of employees, and a provider of health services. These functions will be affected hy the tax limitation measure (as well as by national health care reform), but in ways that are as yet uncertain, Perspective The combined effects of the budget balancing amendment and State Question 640 have altered the methods by which Oklahoma's state government. performs its business. One can observe the adjust- ments already in the emerging revenue and expen- diture issues of fiscal 1996. Proposals are being offered to expand programs that can generate rev- enues through fees-for-service. New concepts for raising revenue are being introduced. What is more important, these adjustments are probably not short- lived; they appear to be a preview of the future for funding state government in Oklahoma.
Open PDF at page 6 ↗PDF page 7
CHAPTER II THE STATE BUDGETING CYCLE AND THE BALANCED BUDGET REQUIREMENT ince 1941, Oklahoma’s constitution has re- quired that every state budget be balanced, both at the time it is passed into law and month-to- month throughout the fiscal year. There is no provi- sion for exceptions. No state checks may be written unless funds are currently on hand to cover the expenditures. If revenues do not come into the state treasury at the projected level, the constitution prescribes the method by which appropriations are to be cut in order to achieve a balance. Oklahoma’s state budget cycle follows an or- derly and rigid process each year. Its foundation is the constitutional balanced budget requirement first putin place in 1941 and amended in 1968, 1975, and 1985. The current balanced budget requirement pro- vides for two points at which the estimated revenues available for appropriation are certified. The pre- liminary certification by the State Board of Equal- jzation (composed of the Governor, Lieutenant Gov- ernor, State Auditor and Inspector, Attorney Gen- eral, State Superintendent of Public Instruction, State Treasurer, and president of the State Board of Agriculture) occurs approximately at Christmas time. This arrangement assures that the Governor’s bud- get recommendations, presented to the legislature on the first day of the session (the first Monday in February), are in balance. The final certification of revenues occurs about mid-February, and may be amended only if statutory changes in the tax laws are passed during the session. Figure II-1 presents the time line of Oklahoma’s budget cycle. The constitutional balanced budget require- ment allows the legislature to appropriate only 95 percent of the revenue estimate certified for the next fiscal year, thus building in a margin for error in the estimates. If actual revenues received exceed the certified estimate, the difference—the so-called “5 percent money”-becomes available for appropria- tion from the Cash Flow Reserve Fund in the next fiscal year. An important feature of the current balanced budget requirement is the creation of the “rainy day fund,” formally titled the Constitutional Reserve Fund. Any and all funds received above 100 percent of the certified estimate are deposited to this fund at the end of the fiscal year. In actuality, the Constitu- tional Reserve Fund is composed of two parts: the Emergency Fund and the Budget Stabilization Fund. These funds are computed as one-half each of all monies in the Constitutional Reserve Fund at the end of the fiscal year. The Emergency Fund may be accessed by the legislature with a three-quarters affirmative vote in both houses and the signature of the Governor without an emergency declaration of the Governor, or through a two-thirds affirmative vote in both houses and the Governor's signature upon a decla- ration of an emergency by the Governor. There are no provisions regarding what constitutes an emer- gency. The Budget Stabilization Fund may be accessed only when the certified revenues for the next fiscal year fall below those of the current fiscal year. Under these circumstances, monies are automatically cred- ited to the General Revenue Fund to the extent of the difference between the two levels of certification or the available funds in the Budget Stabilization Fund, whichever is smallest. The History of the Constitutional Reserve Fund Since the creation of the Constitutional Reserve Fund in 1985, there have been four deposits and six withdrawals (two in fiscal 1989) under the emer- gency declaration provisions. In the past three fiscal years, this so-called “rainy day fund” has been an important source to supplement state revenues. The history of deposits and withdrawals and the current balance available for appropriation for fiscal year 1995 are presented in Table II-1. Some of the $45.6 million available for appropriation from the Emergency Fund will be used in the develop- ment of the fiscal 1995 budget, and this money will be used for continuing operations of state govern- ment services, rather than one-time expenditures. This type of use is typical of recent years.
Open PDF at page 7 ↗PDF page 8
FIGURE Il-1 Oklahoma’s Budget Cycle December January February March April May June I] VT im VI i VT 15° ai" 4° i2' 17° 35° | 1 i | | i | I ! JAA I ———— +. Equalization First day of — Final Last Day of Board Sets Session: Equalization Legislative First Budget Limit Governors Board Budgel Session Budget Due Limit Set duly August September October November | VT 1 i | | 1 1 | | | | Beginning of Fiscal Year Agancy Budget Deposits Made to Requests Due Constitutional Reserve OSF for Next Fund, If any. Fiscal Year Apportionment to Emergency Fund and Budigat Stabilization Fund ” Approximate dates, depending upon the date of the first Monday in February and last Friday in May
Open PDF at page 8 ↗PDF page 9
State Question 640 changes the method by which the appropriations process will proceed. Balancing the budget with tax increases, no matter how small, is an unlikely option for state officials during the same session asa budget pinch, no matter how great the pinch, Because tax ineveases that do not receive a three-quarters vote in both houses must go to a vote of the people in the next general election, budgets now must be written for the next fiscal year, at least, on the assumption that no new taxes are available. Certified Funds for Fiscal Year 1995 On December 30, 1995, the State Board of Equal- ization made its preliminary certification of esti- mated funds for the 19965 fiscal year. In accordance with tradition, the Board also received an updated estimate of revenues for fiscal year 1994, While the December figure is not “the last word,” there is usually little variation between the preliminary certification and the final certification made in Feb- ruary, All indicators point to another extremely tight budget for fiscal 1995, On the surface, the comparison of the fiseal 1994 estimated revenues with the fiscal 1996 certification would not suggest a particularly difficult budget year, For the General Revenue Fund, there is a projected growth of 2.7 pereent, Estimates of the three major tax sources all indicate healthy growth: individual income taxes are expected to rise by 5.3 percent, sales taxes by 4.4 percent, and motor ve- hicle taxes by 7,2 percent, While gross production taxes on oil are estimated to take a steep decline in fiscal 1995, they are now almost a trivial part of the state budget, comprising only 2.4 pereent of the General Revenue Fund. This decline is estimated to be nearly offset by an increase in the gross produe- tion tax on natural gas, which also represents a very small part of the General Revenue Fund—2.5 per- cent, From an economic perspective, using Lax rev- enues as an indicator of economic activity, the Okla- homa economy has come through the national reces= sion and is growing ata respectable rate in compari- son to other states, Nevertheless, there are weak- nesses in several sectors, most notably petroleum, The reality of the state budget, however, is quite different. Difficulties become apparent when com- paring the certified revenues available for appro- priation during the next fiscal year with the actual level of funding for the current fiseal year. Table L- 2 contrasts the budget situation as the 1994 session of the legislature begins to prepare the budget for fiscal year 1995 with circumstances at the beginning of the 1993 session as the 1994 budget was being written. These figures do not include the appropria- tion of restrieted funds to the Department of Trans- portation or the School Land Commission. TABLE II-1 Constitutional Reserve ‘Rainy Day' Fund History (Millions)* FY-88 FY-89 FY-90 Fyeg FY=92 FY-93 FY-94 Deposits $77.99 $100.81 $73.93 $76.12 $0 $0 $0° Appropriated $0 $26 $30 $61.88 $43.87 NA Balance? $0 $152.80 $151.73 $196.86 $135.01 $91.14 NA Revenues collected as a percentage of the cartified estimate 103.36% 104,03% 102.78% 102.50% 98.40% 96.80% SB%E “Far Depaaits, fiscal year is the year during which the revenue accrued Only one-hall of the balance is deposited in the Emergency Fund and is available for appropriation “Eslimatod as of December 30, 1993 State Board of Equalization meeting Source: Adapted tram Oklahoma Aevenue, Issue 93-11, Ollice of State Finance, June 29, 1993 and State Board of Equalization fhinutes, December 30, 1993. nm
Open PDF at page 9 ↗PDF page 10
TABLE Il-2 Comparison of Certified Revenue Estimates and Previous Year Appropriations® (Millions) FY-a4 FY-95, Fy-9a Certitied Fy-g4b Cartified Actual Available Actual Available Appropriations Funds Variance Appropriations Appropriations Variance $3,411.0 $3,278.58 ($132.2) $3,379.0 $3,371.0 ($8.0) (3.8%) (0.2%) TExciides restricted use funds to he Department o! Transportation and the School Land Commission includes appropriatians from the Cash Flaw Reserve Fund and the Rainy Day Fund Source: Adapted (rom FY-98 General Revenue Forecasl and F¥-94 Upefate, Presantatien to the Stato Board of Equalization, December 90, 1993, Olfice of State Finance and FY-94 Genoral Revenua Forecast and FY-93 Update, Presentation to the State Board of Equalization, Decamber 22, 1992, Ollice of State Finance Table 11-2 reveals two very important features of the budgeting problem. First, the fiseal 1995 budget must be written with estimated revenues which are $8 million below the fiseal 1994 spending levels, exclusive of nonappropriated fee revenue. By com: parigon, the fiseal 1994 budgeting process began with a deficit of $132.2 million im terms of money available for appropriation relative to the previous year’s spending level. ‘The Oklahoma economy is expected, therefore, to grow nearly enough to offset the use of one-time money in the fiscal 1994 budget, but not enough to provide any revenue for program expansion or to cover increasing costs of government services, As noted in Table 11-2, the fiseal 1994 budget was written with $100.2 million more than was certified as available for appropriation. This was possible only through the extensive use of one-time money drawn primarily from the Cash Flow Re- serve Fund and the Constitutional Reserve Fund. A total of $71.4 million was drawn from these sources to financefunderwrite the fiscal 1994 budget, In writing the fiscal 1995 budget, only $45.6 million is available from the “rainy day fund” for “emergency” appropriations; and perhaps another $30 million is available from the Cash Flow Reserve Fund, If the remaining one-time cash reserves are used to fi- nance the fiseal 1995 budget, then the state's economy must continue to grow enough to make up the one- time money. Not present in Table II-2, but just as eritical to the budgeting process, is the condition of the State ‘Transportation Fund. This fund ia composed of motor fuel taxes earmarked for road construction and maintenance. The certified estimate for fiseal 1995 indicates a decline of 6.6 percent in available rev- enues for this function of government. This decline ig in addition to a 13.7 percent drop in revenues to the Transportation Fund from fiseal 1993 to fiseal 1994. From fiscal 1988 to date, the Oklahoma Depart- ment of Transportation (ODOT) has been funded virtually exclusively from these earmarked revenues and the federal matching funds these state tax dollars are able to draw. Previously, ODOT reecived extensive appropriations from the General Revenue Fund so that no federal matching dollars would be lost. The decline in the Transportation Fund will no doubt generate pressure to tap the General Revenue Fund and funds earmarked for county road pro- grams in order to finance state highway construc- tion and maintenance. The development of more direct fee-funded highways, such as turnpikes, may also receive closer scrutiny as the ability of ODOT to meet service demands declines. Revenues from turn- pike tolls have been an historically important source to supplement the tax revenues which support vital highway transportation links across the state. The Growth of Fees to Fund State Government A number of state agencies have the ability to finance their operations with nonapprepriated funds, most notably fees. The largest users of fees are the state's colleges and universities. Student tuition and fees represent 40 percent of all fee revenue tothe state, but cover only about 23 percent of the cost of education, During the past few fiscal years, growth
Open PDF at page 10 ↗PDF page 11
in appropriations te higher education has been un- usually low, but this has been partially offset by increases in student fees. From fiseal 1990 through fiscal 1993, college and university fees and tuition grew from $130,9 million to $159.4 million—an increase of 21.7 percent—while appropriations re- mained virtually constant, The reliance upon increases in fees to fund government activities has also occurred in other agencies. The Department of Veterans Affairs, for example, increased fee revenue by 49 percent for medical services in long-term care facilities during the same fiscal 1990-93 period. Overall, fee revenue to the state rose from $315.9 million to $394.9 million from fiseal 1990 through fiseal 1993, an increase of 25 percent. Just over one- third of this growth can be attributed to higher fees and tuition at the state’s colleges and universities. Changes in fees for government services do not require a vote of the people, as do tax increases under the provisions of State Question 640. Itis reasonable to expect further reliance on fees to fund atate government services. Among the likely places for future fee increases are the Corporation Commission, to fund regulatory activities; at insti- tutions of higher education; at the Department of Environmental Quality; and at various agencies that provide services to local units of government, such as the Water Resources Board, the Department of Transportation, the Conservation Commission, the Oklahoma Highway Patrol, and the Oklahoma State Bureau of Investigation. Increased fees for services provided to local units of government will place greater stress on local government budgets. References Office of State Finance, Fiscal Year 1994 General Revenue Forecast and Fiseal Year 1993 Update, Presentation to the State Board of Equalization, December 22, 1992, Office of State Finance, Fiseal Year 1995 General Revenue Forecast and Fiseal Year 1994 Update, Presentation to the State Board of Equalization, December 30, 1993. Office of State Finance, Oklahoma Revenue, Issue 93-11, dune 29, 1993, Office of State Finance, Schedule of Fees, various years,
Open PDF at page 11 ↗PDF page 12
CHAPTER HI ATTITUDES OF OKLAHOMANS TOWARD STATE AND LOCAL TAXES AND EXPENDITURES he objective of this study is to examine the likely future course of public expenditure and revenue pressures in Oklahoma. To obtain greater insight into the probable future, the research team surveyed the Oklahoma populace. State Question 640 now virtually mandates a “survey,” of the grand sort, of voter attitudes for practically every tax increase, with the will of the majority ruling. This ominous fact is the primary impetus for an in-depth exploration of citizen atti- tudes on public finance issues. There are other reasons, however, for conduct- ing survey research on citizen attitudes. Among them is a need to better understand the attitudes of Oklahomans in regard to the public sector. There is a need, as well, to gauge the intensity of reaction to possible future courses of action: just how strongly is the electorate opposed to new revenue sources? Survey research is also a useful tool for assessing the extent of citizen knowledge of public sector issues. Voters, it could be argued, have taken on new re- sponsibilities with passage of State Question 640, greatly increasing their need forinformed judgments. Surveys are useful, too, in exploring general levels of satisfaction of Oklahoma citizens with state and local government. Is widespread dissatisfaction with the services government provides a root cause of discontent? Finally, there is a need to “get inside the heads” of Oklahoma taxpayers to see what they want from government and to check for inconsisten- cies and conflicts in goals. Fiscal constraints are such, at present, that government may be called on for more than it can hope to provide. Following careful review of the literature on the design of state and local government surveys and a review of hundreds of questions asked in previous efforts, we defined five types of information needs: (1) national benchmarks; (2) perceptions of value and knowledge indicators; (3) attitudes toward spe- cific government programs; (4) attitudes toward sources of revenue; and (5) the citizen psyche—an exploration of voter values, beliefs, and attitudes. The survey was conducted over the period Septem- ber 9 through October 5, 1993. Responses were obtained randomly from 1,091 adults, providing an error rate of slightly better than plus or minus three percentage points. The following sections present the survey’s major findings. National Norms The researchers took two questions directly from a national survey administered by the Advi- sory Commission on Intergovernmental Relations (ACIR). The comparisons given below contrast Okla- homa respondents’ answers to results of the 1991 ACIR survey. ¢ The Oklahoma citizen regards local govern- ment much more favorably relative to national benchmarks (44 percent versus 31 percent) as the level of government from which the most is gained for the money. The federal and state governments are regarded about equally fa- vorably in comparison with national norms. A much lower proportion of Oklahoma respon- dents than national respondents said they didn’t know or provided no definite answer (11 per- cent versus 22 percent). ° A much larger percentage of Oklahomans re- gard the federal income tax as the least-fair tax compared to other forms of taxation (38 per- cent versus 26 percent in the national poll). ‘The property tax ranks second among Oklaho- mans, with 26 percent of respondents stating that it is the least-fair tax. The state income tax and the state sales tax scored similarly in relation to national norms. Perception of Value and Knowledge Indicators ¢ Several questions addressed voter perceptions regarding the value of state and local govern- ment and awareness of state revenue issues. The results were mixed. Oklahomans strongly believe that they do not receive good value from state and local government. More than three- fifths responded negatively to the statement
Open PDF at page 12 ↗PDF page 13
“Oklahomans generally receive good value for the state and local tax dollars they pay.” Only about one-third said that they agreed with this statement and only 2 percent said that they strongly agreed. * Respondents appeared somewhat knowledge- able about comparative reliance on various forms of taxation at the state and local level. Oklahoma’s state income and sales taxes are generally higher than those in many other states, and about two-fifths responded that this is so. In addition, 31 percent responded correctly that property taxes are lower. Those responding that they did not know ranged from 10 to 20 percent for these questions. * Respondents were also asked whether Olsla- homa has a state constitution. Sixty-two per- eent said that it did; only 6 percent said that it did not, The remaining 32 percent said that they did not know. The percentage who know that their state has a constitution may seem astonishingly low, but Oklahomans actually compare quite favorably with a national norm. In the ACIR survey, 52 percent responded affirmatively; 11 percent negatively; and 37 percent did not know. Attitudes Toward Specific Programs Because voters are likely to face decisions re- garding specific services, the survey attempted to distinguish among attitudes about various services. For example, the survey asked respondents to “sup- pose government funding is limited and a decision must be made whether to reduce services or raise taxes. Would you favor or oppose additional taxes for the purpose of supporting the following activities?” For various categories of public spending, there were some notable differences. The responses were as follows: ¢ Education: strong supportwas shown, For edu- cation in kindergarten through grade twelve, 78 percent favored additional taxes to provide support. For higher education, 65 percent indi- cated favor. * Social problems: strong to moderate support waa shown, In terms of health care for the elderly, handicapped, and poor, 74 percent would favor additional taxes. For drug educa- 10 tion and treatment, 60 percent favored; for health and social services for children, 56 per- cent favored higher taxes over reduced ser- vices. For assistance for the poor and homeless, 56 percent favored, while in the area of crime prevention and prison facilities, 58 percent would choose additional taxes rather than re- duce services, * Physical infrastructure: varying support was recortled, Sixty-one percent favored more sup- port for maintenance of roads and bridges. Yet, 71 percent opposed higher taxes for new high- way construction. Sixty-two percent would sup- port higher taxes for water and sewage treat- ment, while 66 percentopposed increased taxa- tion for public transportation. © Other activities also met with varying support, Additional taxes for parks and recreation fa- cilities, wildlife preserves, and tourism were oppased by 61 percent of survey respondents. For environmental regulation and cleanup, 50 percent opposed, For economic development, including location incentives, 49 percentopposed. These results indicate moderately strong sup- port for government programs, especially in view of the question’s wording, which asked whether the citizen would prefer more taxes in support of these funetions instead of service reductions, Many of the unfavorable responses bordered on the 50 percent mark. Very few programs or services were strongly opposed. Attitudes Toward Sources of Revenue In probing attitudes toward sources of revenue, the survey asked respondents: “If the state needed additional money for a program that voters have approved, would you favor or oppose increases in each of the following revenue sources?” The ordering of the responses by the percentage opposing in- creases in the corresponding source of revenue is shown in Table If-1. Only two tax sourees—on games such as bingo and on tobacco and liquor—were favored by a major- ity of respondents. Sale of state assets had the blessing of slightly more than one-half the respon- dents, and fees to users of government services scored near the 50 pereent mark.
Open PDF at page 13 ↗PDF page 14
TABLE Ill-1 Rank Ordering of Various Revenue Sources by Percent Opposed to Increases Taxes on utilities 86% Taxes on residential property a3% State personal income tax 82% Taxes on moter vehicles 73% State salos tax rate increases 73% Gasoline tax 71% Sales taxes on services 71% Oil and gas production taxes 6o% Taxes on businesses and corporations 55% Fees to users of governmant servicas 45% Sale of state assets 40% Tobacco and liquor faxes 33% Taxes on games such as bingo 19% With the exception of these minor sources of revenue, however, survey respondents decisively indicated opposition to tax increases, Results even reveal opposition to expansion of the sales tax base to services. Services constitute a growing proportion of household consumption expenditures, and thus, a growing proportion ef consumption expenditures escapes sales taxation. The Citizen Psyche Ag noted, the researchers asked a series of ques- tions of respondents in order to assess citizen think- ing on a variety of issues related to state and local government taxes and expenditures. Sixteen ques- tions were submitted to each respondent and, while the ordering of the questions was random, the ques- tions fell naturally into five categories: (1) state and local intergovernmental relations, (2) the role of government, (8) tax burdens on higher-income fami- lies and corporations, (4) attitudes toward politi- cians.and government workers, and (5)other tax and budget issues, For each question, respondents were asked whether they strongly agreed, agreed, dis- agreed, strongly disagreed, or did not know or have an opinion, An example of detailed responses to the other tax and budget issues questions is provided in Table III-2. State and Local Intergevernmental Relations In the questions on intergovernmental rela- tions, 85 percent of the respondents agreed or strongly agreed that the state should be involved in funding and quality assurance of local public edueation, This result is in contrast to a virtually equal plurality (86 percent) who believe that state government pro- vides too much support to local government func- tions. Almost 90 percent believe that local govern: ments should be free to set their own sales and property tax rates, presumably free from any encum- brances on that process from the state government. Role of Government The tabulations on questions related to the role of government reveal strong and consistent prefer- ence by Oklahomans for an activist role for state government. For example, one-half of the respon- dents agreed or strongly agreed that state govern- ment should aggressively seek to improve the qual- ity of life, the environment, educational attainments, and the economic vitality of Oklahoma, Only 31 percent disagreed or strongly disagreed. TABLE Ill-2 Detalled Survey Results Other Tax and Budget Issues (in pereent) Strongly Strongly Other Tax and Budgot Issues Agree Agree Disagree Disagree Don't Know Taxas should not be increased unless linked to spacific gavernmant programs. 27 6a 7 1 4 Balancing the state budget Is a first priority, even if we must reduce services. 28 47 18 4 4a Revenue problems in Oklahoma government ara matters of serious concer. 6 a7 30 2 26 il
Open PDF at page 14 ↗PDF page 15
In a similar vein, respondents believe that gov- ernment should not be limited to provision of just basic services, defined in the questionnaire as edu: cation, transportation, and crime prevention, The desire for an activist role extends to health care. Fifty-eight pereent think that state government should provide a minimum level of health insurance for all citizens. In addition, respondents indicated that the state should provide financial incentives for businesses to locate in Oklahoma. The state also has a responsibility to provide financial assistance to families in need, suid 71 percent of those surveyed, but that support is highly constrained: almost 93 pereent of the respondents stated that people ave on public welfare much too long. Tax Burdens Respondents were split on the question of whether higher-income families pay their fair share of state taxes; 48 percent agreed and 44 percent disagreed, Fifty-seven percent believe that corpora- tions and businesses are paying their fair shave. Attitudes Toward Politicians and Government Workers Respondents apparently do not hold politicians in high esteem, according to their responses to the statement “Politicians are, for the most part, in public life for their own financial gain." Over three- quarters of respondents agreed with this statement, Government workers were perceived by 88 percent of those surveyed as having done better in job secu- rity and pay inereases than workers in the private sector. Other Tax and Budget Issues Almost 90 percent of reapondents strongly he- lieve that taxes should not be raised unless they are linked to specific government programs. Further- more, three-fourths of the sample favored balaneing the state budget as a first priority, even if it means that services must be reduced. Differences were found among Oklahomans on whether revenue prob- lems are matters of serious concern in the state. A slightly higher percentage of the sample agreed than disagreed, but of special note is the one-fourth ofrespondents whe did not know or have an opinion on this issue. 12 Conclusions State Question G40 gives the voter new power over state taxes. These survey results indicate that the tax sources preferred by Oklahomans are those that are unlikely to yield significantly higher rev- enues, Opposition is uniform and strong across the full spectrum of major tax sources. Problems of state and local finance are likely to be made more difficult by the high expectations that citizens have of government. zens apparently want more education, better health care, more pub- lie welfare, a higher quality of life, a cleaner environ- ment, improved physical infrastructure, anda myriad of other government programs. However, these wants will certainly clash with unwillingness to pay for programs. Indeed, the survey results show that the demand for public services bears little or no relation to willingness to pay. Oklahomans are divided when itcomes to locally provided government services. Local government is viewed as the level of government offering the most value, and citizens want to have control over taxes at the local level. However, there is strong opposition to relying more heavily on the property tax—a principal source of local revenue. Only one in seven Oklaho- mans favors higher property taxes aa a means of financing approved programs, in spite of the fact that citizens know that this source is underrepresented as a source of revenue in Okla- homa in comparison to other states. Oklahoma citizens want state government in- valved in local education, yet a high proportion believes that state government provides too much support for loeal government functions. Oklaho- mans believe that government should provide finan- cial assistance to the poor, but nearly unanimously agree that people are on welfare much too long. ‘These views suggest either that poverty is viewed as atransitional phase, rather than a permanent prob- lem, or perhaps that the respondents believe that the poor can do more to help themselves after they have received a boost from the state. Although the survey results show that the Okla- homa voter is not likely to favor significant tax increases in a State Question 640 election, they also show that voter preferences for services are incon- sistent with this rigidity. Perhaps the Oklahoma voters have not yet reconciled the inherent conflict between tax rigidity and its implication for levels of state services,
Open PDF at page 15 ↗PDF page 16
CHAPTER IV PROSPECTS FOR STATE EXPENDITURES The 1994 session of the Oklahoma legislature will present lawmakers with an all-too-familiar dif- ficulty: a probable shortage of new funds available for appropriation for fiscal year 1995 relative to demands for increased government support. As indi- cated earlier in this report, there will be some growth in available funds, especially iflawmakers summon the political will to tap the Constitutional Reserve Fund and to use the revenues that will accumulate during fiscal year 1994 in the Cash Flow Reserve Fund. It seems unlikely, however, that available funds will grow enough to meet all of the demands the legislature is likely to face. The State Superinten- dent of Public Instruction has already stakedaclaim for $81 million in new money from the General Revenue Fund to cover the cost of the fifth year of House Bill 1017’s reforms. The Oklahoma State Regents for Higher Education have requested nearly $88 million in additional funds to meet the needs of the state’s colleges and universities. Some $35-40 million will probably be needed to meet the in- creased costs of Medicaid. The state will likely have to pay $36 million to federal retirees to replace taxes that allegedly were levied on them illegally in the past, and there is strong bipartisan support for new programs in corrections and juvenile justice. The state’s General Revenue, Cash Flow Re- serve, and Constitutional Reserve Funds together cannot fund all of these needs, let alone the addi- tional requests still to be articulated by other state agencies. Hence, efforts may be launched to tap revenue sources not subject to the limitations im- posed by State Question 640, including turnpikes, a lottery, a tuition increase, and bond issues for new prison facilities (repaid, perhaps, from lottery re- ceipts). There are even some signs of direct chal- lenges to State Question 640’s limits, in the form of arepeal of the state income tax exemption for retired public employees and an organized campaign for a tax hike for higher education modeled after House Bill 1017. Proposals for a lottery, a tuition increase, and fees for new turnpike projects were examined in some detail in Chapter V, because they appear to be the most likely candidates for nontax revenue in- 13 creases in the coming year. This chapter explores the demands for new expenditures faced by the legislature in the areas ofelementary and secondary education, higher education, corrections, juvenile justice, and health care. Elementary and Secondary Education The $81 million requested to finance the fifth year of House Bill 1017’s initiatives represents a significant increase over the amount many people thought would be required. As such, it deserves a closer look. House Bill 1017, the Education Reform Act, was passed by the legislature in 1990. In fiscal year 1990, common schools received $882 million in state ap- propriated funds, At the time of passage, the costs of this legislation’s many provisions were projected to reach $597 million per year by fiscal year 1995.2 This projection was scaled down to $574 million in July, 1991.3 The sum of the latter projection and the level of appropriations in fiscal year 1990, or $1,456 million, is one benchmark for the appropriations promised to common schools in fiscal year 1995 by the passage of House Bill 1017. Common schools will receive $1,364 million in state appropriations in fiscal year 1994—$92 mil- lion less than the amount apparently promised for fiscal year 1995 by House Bill 1017. In this sense, then, the legislature still “owes” the common schools all that is being requested for fiscal year 1995. There is an alternative way, however, to view the situation: namely, how does the amount being requested compare to the sum that was mandated by House Bill 1017 for fiscal year 1995? The 1991 revised projections indicate that the legislature would need to appropriate about $26 million in fiscal year 1995 to meet that year's obligations mandated in House Bill 1017. Approximately $17 million may be needed for money that was supposed to be, but wasn't, appropriated in fiscal year 1994 to cover the costs of the extended school year and healthy living initiatives. These obligations together amount to only $43 million of the $82 million request.
Open PDF at page 16 ↗PDF page 17
The extra amount requested has been defended on the grounds that school enrollments have grown much more than expected when House Bill 1017 was passed, Projections likely to have been available at that time indicate that enrollment in kindergarten through grade twelve could have been expected to increase by 13,000 students between the 1990 and 1995 school years.’ Presumably, enrollment has already grown by over 25,000. There is probably little basis for doubting this claim, because a 12,000 student error on a base of roughly GO0,000 students seems well within the bounds of what could be attributed to inability to accurately forecast the growth in enrollment due to migration. An unexpected increase in enrollment would cost the same as an expected increase in enrollment of the same size. Oklahoma schools spent almost $4,000 per student in fiscal year 1992, nearly $2,400 of which came from state appropriations, The state’s tab for the unexpected 12,000 students, therefore, is around $29 million. Whether House Bill 1017 mandates that the state pick up these unexpected costs may be techni- cally debatable, but paying for them is probably within both the spirit and the intent of House Bill 1017, Given this interpretation, the Department of Education can establish a need for $72 million ofthe $82 million at issue. An extra 2,500 atudents in 1995 could secount for the remainder. According to the latest available projeetions of the National Center for Education Statistics, how- ever, the number of students in Oklahoma in grades kindergarten through twelve will start dropping in 1995, and continue falling at least until 2002.5 The average annual rate of decline over this period is projected to be about 2 percent, or approximately 12,000 stucents. If thia projection is accurate, the $10 million unaccounted for above may be difficult to defend—at least on the basis of expected enrollment growth. In fact, some of the money spent on enroll- ment inereases to date may no longer be defensible on that basis. A turning point in enrollment growth may or may not occur in 1995, but the matter seems to deserve elose study by the legislature and the Department of Education. Higher Education Oklahoma’s public colleges and universities are slated to receive $556 million in appropriated funds in fiseal year 1994, $21 million of it in the form ofone- time appropriations from reserve funds, The total is 14 $19 million less than the $575 million appropriated in fiseal year 1993. The State Regents are asking the legislature to fund the $21 million on a recurring basis, and to provide $88 million in new funds.® Nineteen million dollars ofthe new funds would replace the money cut from appropriations in fiscal year 1994. According to the Regents, the fiscal year 1994 cut resulted in the deletion of nearly 700 course offerings, the elimina- tion of almost 140 faculty positions, and budget cuts for student services. The remaining $69 million in new funds would be used for a variety of purposes, The Oklahoma Tuition Aid Grant Program would receive $2.3 mil- lion, and $9 million would be used for system devel- opment. Much of the remaining $58 million would be used to fund an increase in faculty and staff compen- sation (wages, salaries, and fringe benefits), and new faculty positions. TABLE IV-i Educational and General Expenditures, by Object, Oklahoma Public Colleges and Universities Fiscal 1980 and 1990 (Millions) 1980 1 Object Expands Percent Expends Teaching Salaries $84.9 38.4 163.5 35.6 Other Prof Salaries g1.7 14.4 74.8 15.8 Nonprofit Salaries a44 15.6 65.8 13.9 Staff Benefits 17.6 7.9 65.5 13.2 Tatal Comp 16B.6 76.3 369.6 78.5 Utilities 10.2 46 20.3 43 Supplias/ Materials 9.8 44 14.5 3.0 Other 32.3 147 66.4 14.2 Total Expands $220.9 100.0 $470.8 100.0 Source: Oklahoma State Regents for Higher Education, Current ‘Operating Income.and Expenditures, Fiscal Year 1979-80 and Fiscal Year 1989-901
Open PDF at page 17 ↗PDF page 18
The Regents’ emphasis on employee compensa- tion is not surprising; colleges and universities are very labor-intensive enterprises. As indicated in Table IV-1, employee compensation accounted for 78.5 percent of total educational and general expen- ditures for Oklahoma's 26 public colleges and uni- versities in fiscal 1990, By way of contrast, employee compensation was only 59.7 percent of the tatal cost. of producing national outputin 1990. Table IV-1 also shows that employee compensation accounted for nearly the same percent of expenditures 10 years earlier. Table 1V-2 contains the latest generally avail- able information on total compensation paid college and university faculty in Oklahoma relative to com- pensation paid by the State Regents’ peer institu- tions. The peer institutions serve as the Regents’ benchmarks for judging resource adequacy and in- stitutional quality. The researeh universities in Oklahoma are Oklahoma State University and the University of Oklahoma; their peers consist of the other Big Bight universities and the Big Ten univer- sities, with the exceptions of Northwestern and Penn State, There are ten universities in the com- prehensive four-year category in Oklahoma—the six regional universities and Cameron, Langston, Panhandle, and the University of Sciences and Arts of Oklahoma. Their peers consist of forty-nine insti- tutionsin seventeen states, Oklahoma has fourteen public two-year calleges, with 136 peer institutions in seventeen states, TABLE IV-2 Average Compensation of College and University Faculty, Oklahoma Institutions and Peer Institutions, 1992-93 Category Peer Institutions OK Institutions Research Univ. $65,100 $56,200 Comprehensive 4-¥r 47,600 43,600 Two-Year College 43,100 36,400 Source: "Treading Water: The Annual Aepar of the Economic ‘Status of the Professian, 1992-93," Academe, March-April, 1993, B- BB. Noteg: This survey contains data on both of Oklahoma's public Research Universities, on 6 of Oklahoma's 10 Comprahensive 4: Year public Universities (University of Cantral Oklahoma and Langston University not included), and an all 13 of Oklahoma's 2- Year public Colleges. The survey provides information an all 15 of the Regent's peer institutians in the Research University category, on 48 of the 49 peer institutions in the Comprehensive 4-Year category, and on G4 of the 136 institutions in the 2-Yoar Gollege category. 16 The data in Table IV-2 indicate that faculty compensation in Oklahoma’s public colleges and universitios was lower than compensation paid in the Regent's peer institutions in 1992-93, Given the eut in appropriations to higher education for the 1993-94 school year, Oklahoma schools may have fallen even further behind their peers than these data indicate. Based on these data alone, however, it would have taken average increases in compensa- tion of 16 percent, 9 percent, and 12 percent to come up to the peer averages in the research university, four-year comprehensive university, and two-year college categories, respectively, The Regents’ re- quest for a salary increase and additional funds to cover mandated cost increases for fringe benefits represent an 8-9 percent increase in compensation. The Regents have also requested finds for 204 new faculty positions in 1994-95, One way to put this request in perspective is to examine what has hap- pened to the ratio of full-time-equivalent(FTE) stu: dents to full-time-equivalent faculty in the state's colleges and universities. In 1982-83, the state sys- tem of higher education had 104,315 FTE students taught by 4,114 FTE faculty, or 25.4 students per faculty member. In 1992-95, the state system had approximately 127,000 PTE students and 4,150 FTE faculty, or about 30.6 FTE students per faculty member. It would have taken an additional 850 faculty members in 1992-93 to achieve the 1982-83 ratio of students to faculty, The number required to achieve this ratio in 1994-95 may be somewhat higher, given the positions cut in 1993-94. Corrections and Juvenile Justice Crime and violence have pronipted public outery throughout the United States. In Oklahoma, re- spondents to recent publicopinion polls have tabbed crime as the number one issue facing the state. The Governor and state lawmakers from both political parties and both legislative bodies have indicated that concerns about crime and juvenile justice will be given high priority in the 1994 legislative session, Ironically, the alarm over crime seems to be sounding just when the overall crime rate may be starting to fall. The U.S. Department of Justice reported in October, 1993, for example, that re- ported crimes fell in 1992 by 2 percent, the first decline since 1984,’ Violent crime is up, however, and the violence is more and more attributable to youthful offenders, While arrests of adults for mur- der and other forms of homicide rose by 11 percent from 1982 to 1991, arrests of juveniles for these
Open PDF at page 18 ↗PDF page 19
crimes rose by 93 percent. Violent crimes that have been highly publicized by the media have led state legislators to enact an array of mandatory and determinate sentencing laws that are packing juve- nile detention centers and training schools around the country, even though most juveniles are in custody for nonviolent or property offenses. Judging from the public and political reaction to inereased violence and repeat offenses, there isstrong support for locking up violent and repeat offenders and for keeping them locked up for longer periods of time. This attitude has been common in Oklahoma over the past decade for adult criminals, and it scems ta be growing in regard to juvenile offenders, as well, The outcome for adult criminals has been a greatly increased probability of incarceration, In 1980, Oklahoma locked up criminals at the rate of 134 per 100,000, By 1992, the incarceration rate had grown to 414 per 100,000, the fourth highest rate in the nation.® Some of this increase can be attributed to the adoption of “get tough” sentencing policies for violent crimes, but inearceration rates for nonvio- lent offenses have also increased, One consequence of these policies has been ex- tremely rapid growth in the corrections budget. Between 1980 and 1992, expenditures for correc: tions grew at an annual rate of 17 percent per year, the fastest rate of growth among the major state government agencies, Juvenile offenders have been handled much differently from adults. Most of them have ended up in community-based treatment under the jurisdic- tion of the Department of Human Services, rather than in the custody of the Department of Correc- tions. Even a casual reading of the state’s major news- papers indicates that the legislature will be dealing with a large number of proposals for changing the systems of both adult and juvenile justice in Okla- homa. On the adult side, the emphasis is on stricter and more certain penalties for violent and repeat offenders. Especially popular are variations of the “three strikes and you're out" theme; that is, manda: tory long-term sentences without parole for crimi- nals with three or more offenses. Lawmakers are also attracted to “truth in sentencing” laws, the essence of which is to make incarceration more certain and early release less likely, Serious consid- eration will also be given to efforts to repeal the unpopular Prison Population Management Act, which allows for early release of criminals when prisons become too crowded. 16 Much of the proposed juvenile justice legislation also will deal with various means of providing stricter and more certain punishment, Among thenumerous items on this agenda will be gun control for minors, provisions for waiving juvenile cases to adult court when an offense is considered serious, and less lenient release programs for juveniles in detention. Should the legislature approve proposals such ag these, the numbers of adults and juveniles incar- cerated will increase. The state's prison and deten- tion facilities are already overcrowded. So, too, are the county jails, Thus, new facilities would have to be constructed at both the state and county levels. Some legislators and the Governor are calling for a complete overhaul of the juvenile justice sys- tem, This, they argue, requires the establishment of anew Department of Juvenile Justice. There is little doubt that a fall law-and-order agenda would be quite expensive; exactly how much would depend on the actions proposed. At this time, only preliminary estimates have been made, Among them are the ¢laims that a Department of Juvenile Justice could require an initial budget of $40 million, that as much as $250 million may be needed to construct new state adult and juvenile facilities, and that $50-60 million a year could be required to operate the new facilities. No estimates, however preliminary, haye emerged on the amount of money needed to construct new county jail facilities, nor on the cost of the criminal justice resources that would be required in addition to those for corrections, per ae, Several suggestions have been made regarding funding sources for criminal justice, The Governor has proposed that the large construction items be paid for by the proceeds of a bond issue that could be repaid over time, at least partly out of the receipts of a state lottery. Another suggested source of repay- ment is slate revenues from the excise tax on ciga- rettes. State Representative Michael ‘Thornburgh has recommended the creation of a Criminal Justice Trust Authority to operate county jails, with the Authority given the right to ask county voters to approve up to a five-mill increase in property taxes to build, operate, and maintain jail facilities. So far, there have been few suggestions to raise state taxes in order to fund new initiatives in correc: tions and criminal justice. This may seem surpris- ing, given the strong demands by the public that something be done about crime, but it is probably testimony to the even stronger constraining influ- ence of State Question 640 and the public attitude on taxes. In the environment created by this tax
Open PDF at page 19 ↗PDF page 20
limitation measure, state government is likely to turn inereasingly to bend finance and the creation of trust authorities lo accomplish what it might other- wise accomplish through tax increases, It would be premature to try to evaluate the rash of proposals in adult and juvenile justice; all of them are, as yet, in preliminary form, However, it is possible, and perhaps instructive, to put the juvenile justice initiatives in context. The apparently greater demand for punishment than for rehabilitation appears to be something of a throwback to the past. Oklahoma was sued in 1978 because children who didn’t need secure settings were being locked up in institutions under question- able conditions. Eventually, state officials closed the institutions and resources were redirected toward community-based alternatives. Public sentiment in Oklahoma for this change may never have been strong, and all that the sentiment for punishment needed to become dominant once again was a mount- ing level of concern about crime. In any event, Oklahomans will likely be engaged in a spirited debate once again over the respective merits of juvenile rehabilitation and incarceration. The costs and benefits associated with each will be carefully identified, measured, and considered. Health Care Tn the fall of 1993, President Clinton and his Domestic Policy Council unveiled recommendations for major changes in the nation’s health care deliv- ery system. Other strategies for health care reform have also been proposed. Whatever the relative merits of the various measures being examined by the U.S. Congress, it is likely that the federal gov: ernment will soon make some changes in the health care system. Because Oklahoma state government is deeply involved in health care, it is likely that actions by the federal government will have signifi- cant impacts on the state's finances, During fiscal year 1993, roughly one out of every four dollars of Oklahoma state government expendi- tures was related to health care, Table IV-3 lists selected expenditures on health-related activities amounting to nearly $1.9 billion. This is a conserva- tive measure because it does not include state em- ployee health insurance, some health-related educa- tion programs, and some environmental expendi- tures directly related to health. Atan expenditure level of $1.1 billion, Medicaid dominates state government health expenditures, During fiscal year 1993, Medicaid provided medical 17 benefits to 381,000 low-income persons in Okla- homa. Medicaid payments were for hespital care (94 percent); physicians’ services (21 percent); interme- diate care facilities, such as nursing homes (34 percent); in-home care (3 percent); and drugs (8 percent). About 70 percent of Oklahoma's Medicaid outlays are financed by reimbursements from the federal government. The program is referred to as an “entitlement” because benefits must be paid to those who meet eligibility criteria. During fiscal years 1987-93, the state's Medicaid outlays rose 110 percent, while total state outlays increased 44 per- cent. The recent rapid relative growth of Medicaid expenditures cannot be sustained over long periods without forcing a major restructuring of state gov- ernment expenditure priorities. In recognition of this, the 1993 session of the Oklahoma legislature removed the program from administration by the Department of Human Services and placed it in a TABLE IV-3 Selected Expenditures Related to Health Cara, Oklahoma State Government Fiscal 1993 (Millions) Program Amount Medicaid, Dapt. of Human Services (DHS) $1,103.5 Oklahoma Madical Canter (hospitals, OHS) 204.8 Depariment of Health 149.2 Depariment of Mental Health 147.9 Health Sciences Genter, Univ. of Oklahoma 137.5 Department of Veterans Affairs (hospitals) 44.5 State Insurance Fund and Special Indemnity Fund (workers compensation) 40.0 DHS, Other Medical Services 24.9 Health Regulatory Agencies® 3.5 Other 14.2 Total $1,870.0 ® Regulatory boards controlling podiatrists, chirapractors, dentists, medical doctors (M.0.s), nursing home administra: lors, nurses, osteopaths, pharmacists, psychologists, optom- alrists, and speech pathology and audiology specialists, ‘includes the Gollage of Osteopathic Medicine, Okla: homa State University; the J.D. MeGarly Center; and the Workers Compansation Court, Source: Office of State Finance, Schedule Ill, Fiscal 1993; Department of Human Services, FY93 Annual Report, p. 13,
Open PDF at page 20 ↗PDF page 21
new ageney, the Oklahoma Health Care Authority. Anew approach to administration of Medicaid is to be implemented, in which the state will enter into contracts with health care providers for services to those eligible for Medicaid benefits. The payments will be based on a fixed amount per person. If the price of health care continues to grow at the same rate as in the past, even this new framework will not be able to keep the Medicaid program from absorb- ing ever-larger shares of the state budget. The Medicaid program illustrates three of the major problems faced by the nation’s health care system. First, Medicaid provides health benefits to those who, because of low incomes, would not other- wise have any health insurance. In fact, however, many persons under 65 (and, therefore, noton Medi- eare), have no health insurance and are not eligible for Medicaid. In Oklahoma, it is estimated that during the period 1989-91, 21 percent of the popula- tion under 65 had no health benefit coverage at all. Nationwide, 16 percent of that population group was without coverage.” Asecond problem is the rapid rise of health care costs. Although the rate of inflation in health costs appears to be slowing down, in recent years it has not been unusual for health care costs to inflate twice as rapidly as the overall price level, A third problem is labeled “cost-shifting.” It is argued that Medicaid reimbursement rates are in- sufficient to cover the actual costs of providing ser- vices, Moreover, many without health insurance cannot pay their medical bills. Since someone has to pay, the typical response by health care providers has been to charge higher prices to those with insurance to offset inadequate or no payment from others, In recent years, health insurance organiza= tions and employers have become increasingly resis- tant to cost shifting. On September 22, 1993, President Clinton ad- dressed a joint session of Congress to set forth his health care reform proposals. The proposals were based on six principles! 1. Security: universal coverage with a compre- hensive and irrevocable set of benefits; 2. Simplicity: a program that is easy to under- étand and administer; 3. Savings: greater efficiency and the reduction of health care inflation; 4. Choice: freedom for individuals te choose their doctors and health eare plans; 5. Quality: provision of better information to 18 health care consumers aboutcomparative quali- ties of care; 6. Responsibility; avoidance of health-impairing behavier and price consciousness in health care purchases. The administration then submitted a very com: plicated 1,842-page Health Security Act proposing major changes in the nation’s health care delivery system. At the heart of the proposals is an adapta- tion of a concept referred to as “managed competi- tion,” If the act is adopted, all employers will be required to provide health benefits. Each state will have one or more “health alliances” which will make arrangements for the purchase of health insurance ov other medical care plans from a variety of health care providers, Premiums paid by employers will be channeled through the health allianee organization to the various approved providers. Employees can choose among approved programs, but the basic purehase of coverage must be through a health alliance serving a particular area. Very large em- ployers ean become their own health alliance, The theory underlying managed competition is that em- ployers and workers will benefit from economies of scale in the purchase of coverage, and from the massive bargaining power which the alliances will exercise over the providers. It is likely that the health alliance for Oklahoma will be the abave- mentioned Oklahoma Health Care Authority or a similar entity created by state government. There have been negative reactions to the President's proposals—though many critics are not inclined to attack the six basic principles of reform and the need for some change. This leads ta specu- lation that there will be federal health care mea- sures adopted before the general elections in the fall of 1994. What this means for Oklahoma state gov- ernment finance, of course, depends on the specif- ics, The existence of a single health alliance agency would represent a remarkable change in the struc- ture of state government, Nationally, the health care sector accounts for about 14 percent of Gross Domestic Product. If the ratio is about the same in Oklahoma, this sector stands at about $10 billion in 1994. The current entire state budget of Oklahoma is about $8 billion. It is not clear what share of the $10 billion spending flow would be channeled through state government's health alliance, but the share is likely to be very large and could easily result in an alliance that is half the size of the current budget. It is difficult to imagine such an
Open PDF at page 21 ↗PDF page 22
activity without a significant and costly new admin- istrative infrastructure in state government. More- over, should a state health alliance run into finan- cial difficulty, it is likely that state, rather than federal, financial resources will be required to honor health coverage commitments. Although the Clinton administration anticipates that its health care program will save money, many observers are less sanguine. In Oklahoma, for ex- ample, it will be difficult to provide coverage at no net additional cost to the 500,000 or so persons currently not insured, Since the percent of Oklaho- mans without coverage is well above the national average, the increased coverage will be especially expensive in this state. If employer financing is mandated, the impact on small business costs in Oklahoma may be particularly burdensome. Even conservative crities ofthe administration's plan appear to accept the principle of universal coverage. The Consumer Choice and Health Secu- rity Act offered by twenty-five senators relies on a system of insurance reforms and tax reforms, but they assert that it provides universal health care coverage.!! The head of the conservative think- tank, The Cato Institute, supports expanding cover- age for the poor by replacing Medicaid witha voucher system and raising the eligibility threshald to 150 percent of the poverty level.!? Given the perilous status of the federal government’s budget, itis likely that federal measures providing universal coverage will foster attempts to shift part of the burden to state governments, As Table IV-3 indicates, state government in Oklahoma has a big involvement in hospitals. Cost containment measures may generate pressure to fund deficits at state hospitals through appropria- tion of general revenue funds, State government's outlays on its own employee health insurance could be decreased as a result of health care reforms which eliminate cost-shifting, Itis even possible thathealth care reforms would reduce the costs of workers! compensation to the state, itself, and to employers throughout the state. Universal health care cover- age might shrink theresponsibilities of county health departments and reduce the need for state financial aid to those agencies. Currently, the state must use a good deal of its own-source revenues to finance mental health and substance abuse services—though some federal block grant monies are available, De- pending on the treatment of mental health in the basic benefits package of a universal care system, the state might be relieved of some expenditure responsibilities in this area of treatment. 19 In early 1994, uncertainty is the most salient feature of the health care dialogue. It is obviously important for state government and for private employers to remain very much involved in the debate which is unfolding at the national level. This isa sector in which changes in policy are likely ta be associated with major restructuring of budgets. Even the “incremental” changes called for by oppo- nents of the national administration’s proposals are likely to have large impacts. Footnotes Unexpected Enrollment Drives Up 1017 Costs,” Stillwater NewsPress, January 18, 1994, p. 14, 2Craig Knutaon, et al., "House Bill 1017: The Eduea- tion Reform Act of 1990," in State Policy for Econamic Development, 1991, Oklahoma City; Oklahoma 2000, Inc., pp. 19-28, Joint Staff Information Sheets on Major Topies Addressed in House Bill 1017," August, 1991, Oklahoma City: Oklahoma State Legislature. 4S. Department of Education, Projections of Educe- Hon Statiatier ta 2001, An Update, 1991, Washington, D.C.: U.S. Government Printing Office. 51.8, Department of Education, Projections of Bduea- tion Statistics to 2002, 1991, Washington, D.C.: U.S. Government Printing Office, ®Oklahoma State Regents for Higher Education, “State Regents Outline 1994-95 Budget Priorities, Approve Ap- propriations Request," Leader, 8(1), 1994, pp. 1-2, 7U.S. Department of Justice, Crime in the United States, 1992, Washington, D.C.: U.S. Government Print+ ing Office, ®Corrections Gut of Control,” State Policy Reports, 11(16), p. 4. ® Pamela Loprest and Michael Gates, State-Level Data Book on Health Care Access and Financing, Washington, D.C.: The Urban Institute, 1993, p. 12. 1OT he White House Domestic Poliey Council, Health Security, The President’s Report to the American People, Washington, D.C.; U.S. Government Printing Office, Oc- tober, 1993, pp, 89-106. Usee Don Niekles, “Health Plan for Consumers,” Washington Post, December 14, 1993, p. A26, and “Con- sumer Choice and Health Security Act, Fact Sheet,” No- vember 16, 1993. 12William A. Niskanen, speech before the Society of Government Economists, Washington, D.C., January 12, 1994,
Open PDF at page 22 ↗PDF page 23
CHAPTER V RESPONDING TO TAX LIMITATIONS BY DEVELOPING NON-TAX REVENUES he limitations imposed by State Question 640 and the attitudes of Oklahomans toward tax increases reduce the options for policymakers seek- ing to expand state-supplied services. These con- straints will not, however, slow down the growing demand for government programs. Under these cir- cumstances, Oklahomans are turning to various means of raising non-tax revenues. They have, in fact, already started to do so. More than 200,000 registered voters have signed. an initiative petition for a vote on a lottery, and polls indicate that it will have a good chance of passing if the state Supreme Court denies the horse racing industry's challenge to the lottery. The voters ap- proved a $350 million bond issue last year to meet some long-standing needs for physical capital, espe- cially in higher education. The Governor has pro- posed a $250 million bond issue to fund new correc- tional facilities for adult and juvenile offenders, part of which he proposes would be repaid with the state’s take from a lottery. The Governor has pushed hard for construction of additional turnpikes under the Oklahoma Turnpike Authority. The legislature has established the Oklahoma Health Care Authority to restructure the state’s Medicaid program. The people may get an opportunity in the future to vote on a proposed Criminal Justice Trust Authority, which would have the right to ask county voters to approve up to a five-mill increase in property taxes to build, operate, and maintain county jail facilities. And both the Governor and the State Regents for Higher Education have indicated that they will push for a tuition increase for the state’s colleges and universi- ties. Some of these alternatives are in such an embry- onic stage that an evaluation would be premature. This is not the case, however, for proposals which seek to establish a state lottery, increase higher education tuition, and expand the state’s turnpike system. An Oklahoma Lottery Governor Walters and the Oklahoma BEST ’93 organization are vigorously campaigning to create a 21 statewide lottery. Three forces add momentum to their effort: the lottery’s popular appeal, the success of similar efforts in other states, and Oklahoma’s need for revenue. Currently, thirty-nine states and the District of Columbia have government-run lotteries.! People apparently want to play the game, and Oklahomans appear to be no exception. A recent poll in this state suggested that 61 percent of Oklahoma’s population favors a lottery.2 This is close to the 65 percent average level of support in the states where lotteries have been approved over the last thirty years.? Texas, Kansas, Missouri, Colorado, and Louisi- ana operate state-run lotteries, and by doing so have created an environment of interstate competition for revenues. Many Oklahomans purportedly drive to Texas or Kansas to play the lotteries in those states. Some policymakers see this as a source of potential revenue for Oklahoma that is being lost to other states, and that could be claimed with an Oklahoma lottery. The third force at work in favor of a lottery in Oklahoma is the state’s need for revenue. One of the expected effects of the passage of State Question 640 is that Oklahoma policymakers will look for pres- sure valves to escape the constraints imposed by this measure. One type of pressure valve is new or existing non-tax revenue sources that are not sub- ject to the limits. The lottery fits into this category. Seventeen of the twenty-two states that have adopted limits on total appropriations or taxes since 1976 conduct a state-run lottery. In light of the anti-tax sentiment surrounding the passage of State Ques- tion 640, Oklahoma may join this group. Opposition to the lottery in the press tends to focus on the moral and ethical objections to gam- bling. With state-run lotteries, state governments are in the business of providing a new source of gambling. It is legalized gambling, but it is still gambling, and opponents argue that it is morally wrong. They argue that it also contributes to per- sonal financial problems, leads to illegal gambling, and creates an aura of crime and corruption. The lottery campaign has attempted to defuse these objections by promising to earmark a majority of the revenues for education. In this way, a vote for the
Open PDF at page 23 ↗PDF page 24
lettery becomes a vote for better schools. In Okla- homa, the need for better schools may garner sup- port from groups who might otherwise be opposed to a state-run lottery. Whatever their merits, the objections just noted are beyond our purview. Subsequent discussion is confined to the economic aspects of the lottery. There are two economic perspectives on lotter- ies. One is that a lottery is essentially a service provided by government to satisfy consumer de- mand; i.e., a lottery is like a government-operated utility providing water or electricity. The second perspective is that a lottery is basically a source of taxes to the state. In this perspective, the profits from a state-run lottery essentially are an implicit tax that can be raised or lowered just like conven: tional taxes, In the utility perspective, the lottery is judged by how effectively it meets consumer de- mand. In the tax perspective, one judges the lottery aga revenue source by the same economic standards that one judges other taxes. The primary point to be made from the utility perspective is that if Oklahoma voters approve a lottery, it meets the first test of consumer acceptance. It is then incumbent upon the government to provide the lottery service in a cost-effective manner. There is extensive literature on whether lotter- ies are an effective means of raising tax revenues. Thus, the focus here is primarily on seven key points that are supported in the economics literature on lotteries. One feature of a lottery that separates it from other state tax sources is that itisa voluntary action, That is, the choice to participate in the lottery, and the payment of the tax, is left entirely te the disere- tion of the taxpayer. Lotteries as a Revenue Source Net lottery revenues generally amount toa small portion of a state's budget. On average, about 38 percent of lottery revenues are turned over to the state government.’ This contributes an average of about 2 percent to total state revenue,® and repre- sents the eighth largest source of revenue (on aver= age) for the lottery states.® Oklahoma BEST '98 projects that an Oklahoma lottery will gross about $183 million annually, with anet return of $64 million.” If that is true, the net proceeds would represent less than 2 percent of the total revenues collected by the state in fiscal year 1992. Given the state’s income tax base, Oklahoma could raise approximately the same amount by raising 22 the average state income tax rate 0.2 percentage points. Lottery revenues tend to be more volatile than other sources of state revenue, Lottery sales very rarely decline, even in real terms. However, as lotteries mature, their annual rate of growth in sales tends to diminish, like many consumer goods and services.® Also, as more states enact lotteries in a particular region, sales growth in any one state tends to slow down due to competition from sur- rounding states. Thus, most lottery states, after a time, have become more aggressive in their adver- tising and development of new lettery games in an attempt to maintain the rate of growth in sales experienced in the firat few years, This may partly explain why lottery revenues have been more vola- tile than other state revenue sources. Part of the apparent variability in lottery revenues alsa is due to their rapid growth over time. But even when this secular trend is accounted for, lottery revenues are still relatively more volatile around their trend than other state revenue sources.? Some states are more successful than others in generating a high rate of growth in lottery sales. While it is true that introducing a lottery in Okla- homa will generate revenue, experience elsewhere indicates that it is difficult to keep per capita sales growing. Lottery officials would apparently have to be very aggressive to generate consumer interest year after year, especially since Oklahoma may have difficulty attracting many out-of-state players, given the success of pre-existing lotteries in Kansas, Mis- souri, Colorado, and Texas, Of course, the more aggressive state govern- ment has to be to maintain a particular rate of growth in sales, the greater cost of product innova- tion and promotion. That, in turn, increases the ratio of administrative costs to revenue, The operat- ing expenses associated with a state-run lottery averaged over 25 percent of lottery revenues in 1986.!° Compared with other atate revenue sources, this ratio is extremely high. If the lottery is viewed as a state run monopoly, however, this ratio may not. be excessive. Cletfelter and Cook, in a 1989 report on state lotteries, suggest that the administrative costs of state-run lotteries should not be compared to the administrative coats of other state revenuesources.!! They view lottery agencies as state monopoly enter- prises selling a product to consumers, not as tax collectors. Therefore, the administrative costs asso- ciated with the lottery represent the costs of provid- ing a commodity, not collecting revenue.
Open PDF at page 24 ↗PDF page 25
There is some evidence of economies of scale in lottery administration. The operating expenses per dollar of revenues raised for the state decline as sales increase.!” However, because of its small popu- lation base, the likelihood that Oklahoma can take advantage of this phenomenon appears tobe slim. It will be difficult for the state to realize any significant. economies of scale if it operates a lottery on its own. Many states demographically similar to Oklahoma have taken advantage of the economies of scale in lottery administration by combining their lottery operations with other states, Evaluation of lotteries as a potential revenue source for the state requires that the effects of the lottery on other state revenue sources be considered. States lose an avernge of fifteen cents of other revenue per dollar of lottery revenue collected.!3 If consumer expenditures on lottery tickets crowd out expenditures on other goods, then sales tax revenue will decrease. Pari-mutuel tax revenues will decline as the lottery substitutes for betting at the track, In fact, for every one dollar increase in spending on the lottery, there is about an eighteen-cent decrease in pari-mutuel wagering.!4 State income tax revenues will increase, how- ever, to the extent that the winnings are subjeet to the state income tax. There is some evidence that those states with no state income tax and a high proportion of state revenue collected by sales or excise taxes are at higher risk of losing alternative revenues as a result of their lotteries, Oklahoma uses a combination of both income and sales taxes and could lose between seven cents and twenty- three cents per dollar of lottery revenue gained.!° The Implicit Lottery Tax Three prior claims are made on lottery revenue collected by a state before the remainder goes into the state treasury. Prizes, administrative costs, and sales agent commissions must be paid, Viewed as a consumer item, the net revenue or profit from a state-run lottery, similar to an excise tax, is the portion of each ticket sale that ends up in the state treasury. The implicit lottery tax is high when com- pared to other excise taxes. In 1985, the implicit tax on lotteries averaged 85 percent of the net price, while tobacco was taxed at.49 percent and liquor at 48 percent.!® Most state excise taxes are regressive with re- spect to income; as income increases, taxes paid asa percentage of income decrease. ‘The implicit tax associated with the lottery also has been found 23 regressive with respect to income, Studies on lottery participation have shown that lower-income house- holds tend to play the lottery more often than house- holds in other classes of income, In fact, no other state tax exhibits the degree of regressivity as that associated with the implicit lottery tax.!7 Opponents of a lottery may argue that this is a good reason to oppose a lottery. Proponents may argue that they should have the right to play, just as people have the right tosmoke, and that the “sin” tax likely to be levied is merely excessive. Generally, lower-income households are not the largest group of voters who vote “yes” on the lottery issue. Al- though higher-income voters tend to vote yes, they play the game less frequently, 18 Of course, any discussion of the distributional impacts of a state lottery also must consider the incidence of the benefits generated by the lottery revenues. If the net. lottery revenues fund programs that benefit low-income households, then lotteries would be less regressive overall, Tt is diffieult ta identify which specific programs atate lottery revenues support. When the money is added to the stnte’s General Revenue Fund, it is spent the same ag any other revenue souree. And even if the additional funds are earmarked for a particular program, there is no guarantee that the money will not be just a substitute for funds that would have heen spent. on a program anyway. For example, many states earmark their lottery revenues for education. In most cases, however, the additional lottery revenue has substituted for other funds that would have supported education.!9 Rar marking lottery revenues will have the most effect when the earmarked revenues contribute a large proportion of the total spending on a particular program.“9 In the states with lotteries where funds were earmarked for education, lottery revenues con- tributed only 11.6 percent of total state revenues to education in 1991, and only 3.8 pereent of total state and local revenues to education.2! Apparently, this was not a large enough contribution to preclude the substitution of lottery funds for general revenue funds. A Tuition Increase As this report was being written, it was clear that a tuition increase would be up for consideration in the 1994 legislative session, but its size was less certain, Governor Walters has called for an increase of $16 million, or a little over 9 percent of the $159.4
Open PDF at page 25 ↗PDF page 26
million collected in tuition and fees in 1992-93. The State Regents have not yet recommended a specific tuition increase for 1994-95. Their long-term goal, however, is to inereage students’ share of total ap- propriations and tuition from the current 23 percent to 33 percent by the year 2000.22 To achieve this goal, tuition would have to be increased an average of 7 percent per year for each of the next six years, Governor Walters appears te be pushing for a tuition increase as a means of offsetting a proposed 2.75 percent across-the-board cut in appropriations to most state agencies, Such a cut would take ap- proximately $15 million from higher education, the game amount as the proposed tuition increase, Currently, Oklahoma students are funded at only 66 percent of the average amount per student at similar colleges and universities in other states, To close this gap would require an additional $280 million in appropriated funds plus attainment of the Regents’ tuition goal.?* Proposing a tuition increase is one thing, abtain- ing legislative approval is quite another, In fact, there may be significant opposition to sueh an in- crease. Tuition increases are normally opposed on several grounds, Chief among them are the fears that a tuition increase will cause a significant de- cline in enrollment, and that it will reduce access to higher education for low- and/or middle-income stu- dents. Tuition increases can, but they need not, have these effects, Enrollment is negatively associated with tu- ition:i.¢., enrollment will fall when tuition increases. Enrollment is positively associated, however, with personal income, student aid, the number of high school graduates, and tuitions charged by compet- ing educational systems.“4 An increase in tuition in Oklahoma need not cause an enrollment decline if personal income, student aid, the number of high school graduates, and tuitions in other systems (especially in Kansas, Arkansas, and Texas) are growing fast enough at the same time that Oklahoma's tuition is increasing. Normally, modest increases in personal income are enough by themselves to offset increases in tuition. This happens because the positive effect on enrollment of a 1 percent increase in personal in- come is much stronger than the negative effect on enrollment ofa | percent increase in tuition, Studies of the factors influencing college enrollment indicate that a 1 percent increase in tuition will decrense total enrollment by about. 0.6 percent.2° An inerease of 1 pereent in personal income will increase total enrollment by about 1.6 percent.?* Applying these findings, a 7 percent increase in tuition (the annual inerease required to meet the Regents’ long-term goal) would cause a 4.2 percent deerease in total enrollment, but this could be offset entirely by a 4.2 percent enrollment inerease resulting from a 2.6 percent increase in income, Oklahoma personal in- come is projected to grow in 1994 by 6 percent. Thus, the level of tuition increase likely to be suggested on a sustained basis by the Regents probably will not reduce total enrollment next year, In fact, a 6 per- centincrease in personal income is more than enough to offset the 9 percent increase in tuition that the Governor has suggested, These calculations apply only to the total popu- lation of college students; they do not necessarily apply to each part of the college population, A 7 percent tuition increase may have a greater effect. on some groups of students than on others. The ratio of a 0.6 percent decline in enrollment fer a 1 percent increase in tuition is the average—a larger ratio may apply to some groups of students and a smaller ratia may apply to other groups. An increase of 6 percent in state personal income is also an average increase; personal incomes used to finance a college education will grow faster than 6 percent for some students’ families and slower than 6 percent for others. There is no guarantee, either, that the stu- dents whoare most. affected by tuition increases will be the students who are experiencing the fastest inereases in personal income. Thus, one must look more closely at specific segments of the student population, The effect of a tuition increase, per se (that is, independent of any changes in personal income, number of high school graduates, student aid, and tuitions charged in other states or systems) is gener- ally larger (1) for freshmen than for continuing students, (2) for students with lower academic achievements than for students with higher aca- demic achievements, and (3) for students supported by smaller personal incomes than for students sup- ported by larger personal incomes. ‘The number of high school graduates in Okla- homa is projected to increase by a little over 2 percent per year for the next six yeara.2? This may be a large enough increase in the pool of prospective freshmen to offset the somewhat larger effect of a tuition increase on the total number of freshmen enrolled, There is no denying, however, that the number of freshmen enrolled would be larger in the absence of any tuition increases. The differential effeet on freshmen ean be avoided, of course, by avoiding tuition increases, but in doing so the State
Open PDF at page 26 ↗PDF page 27
Regents would come up short of achieving their goal of more funding for higher education in Oklahoma. Alternatively, the State Regents can achieve their funding goals and minimize the differential effect of a tuition increase on freshmen by (1) providing more financial aid to freshmen, and/or (2) raising tuition more for continuing students than for freshmen, The second problem associated with higher tu- ition is that a tuition increase will have a greater effect on lower-achieving students than on higher- achieving students. Simply put, higher achievers will, on average, be more motivated to pursue a college education in the face of tuition increases than will lower achievers. It is doubtful that there is much public sentiment in Oklahoma for providing long-term financial aid to lower-achieving students, or for charging higher achievers more tuition than lower achievers simply ag a means of offsetting the larger effect of higher tuition on the group of lower achievers. There may be some public sentiment, however, for giving lower achievers “second chance.” ‘The Regents could accommodate these sentiments and achieve their finding goals by using one of the alternatives noted as a solution to the “tuition: affects-freshmen-more” dilemma; namely, they could provide more financial aid to freshmen (only) that is not based on performance in high school. This would help to lower the barrier posed by higher tuition and give lower-achieving students the “second chance” that some of the public may favor, Perhaps the fact that is most Lroubling is that the effeet of a tuition hike increases as the personal income supporting the student decreases. This prob- lem eould be avoided either by providing move in- come-conditioned financial aid (the amount of finan- cial aid would increase as personal income decreases) or by making tuition income-conditioned (tuition would decrease as personal income decreases). The public would probably faver income-conditioned fi- nancial aid, but the two alternatives are equivalent in their effects. Two issues must be reselyed whenever an in- come-conditioned subsidy is considered. The first is whether the subsidy should be specific or general, The second is how much the subsidy should increase as family income decreases. A specific subsidy is one that is provided only for the purchase of a apecific goad or service; income- conditioned financial aid and income-conditioned tuition are specific subsidies, A general subsidy is one thatis provided for the purchase of many differ- ent kinds of goods or services. Most economists believe that the recipient households benefit more 25 from a general subsidy, by making their own con- sumption choices, than from a speeifie subsidy. Haw- aver economists also recognize that the welfare of taxpayers may be higher when the subsidy is given for the purchase of specific “merit” goods. Subsidies for higher education clearly fall in the latter cat- egory. This still leaves the question of deciding how large the subsidy for higher education should be at each income level, Actually, the most important part of this decision has already been made: students at all income levels are going to have at least two- thirds of the cost of their public college education subsidized direetly by general taxpayers. Still to be decided is who is going to pay how much of the remaining one-third, Few would argue with the proposition that stu- dents from poor and near poor families should pay a amaller share of the cost of their college edueations than students from middle-income and upper-income families.2® There may even be quite a bit of senti- ment for providing the poor and near-poor with financial aid that pays virtually all of their tuition, and for providing upper-income students with no financial aid. But it is unlikely that the case is this clear for students from middle-income families, It is difficult to separate the effect of the sheer weight of numbers from considerations of equity. For example, educators and lawmakers who oppose an increase in tuition on the grounds that it will harm the middle classinay simply be counting votes, instead of acting on the basis of evidence that it will pose a severe hardship on this group. If votes are what matters, the issue may be far from clear, The middle class has already let it be known through its support of State Question 640 that it does not, in general, favor more taxes. The survey described in Chapter IIT, however, indicates that the vote on State Question 640 was not neces- sarily a vote against government programs, in gen- eral, or higher education, in particular. There may be other concerns in addition to the impaet of tuition increases, however, e.g., cost for value received ora structure thought to be wasteful, It is possible that the concern really is that higher tuition will constitute a severe hardship for the middle class. This aspect of the issue is resolv- able with the accumulation of enough information on the true impact of a tuition increase and the crafting of a financial aid package that offsets, to some degree at least, the harm imposed on middle- ineome families. This is largely an empirical matter, not a matter of principle.
Open PDF at page 27 ↗PDF page 28
Fee For Service: The Turnpike Authority The state financing of highways, roads, and bridges in Oklahoma has taken several forms. Ear- marked state revenues, principally from fuel excise taxes and motor vehicle fees, flow to the State Transportation Fund to support the construction and maintenance of the state highway system by the Oklahoma Department of Transportation (ODOT). Earmarked state revenues from these sources also support city and county road programs and flow into the Oklahoma Turnpike Authority (OTA) Trust Fund. The limitations of State Question 640 offer virtually no prospect for increasing tax rates of these traditional taxes in the near term, and the tax bases of these revenue sources change very slowly. On the other hand, since the OTA collects tolls to fund its operations, it is isolated somewhat from the direct constraints imposed by State Question 640. Even before passage of the tax limitation mea- sure, there was little likelihood that revenue sources would keep up with maintenance and construction requirements for state highways. Now, significant shortfalls are even more likely. Various proposals to expand the turnpike system through debt financing backed with toll revenues are currently at issue, and are probably precursors of a longer-term pattern of funding state highway construction in Oklahoma. Highway Needs The building ofnew highways, roads, and bridges and the maintenance of the existing system are critical needs independent from funds available. According to the ODOT’s assessment, 3,329 miles of Oldahoma highways are presently inadequate to serve their traffic demands.?? In addition, ODOT calls for 102 miles of interstate highway construc- tion and 62 miles of new roads in urban areas. The projected cost of fulfilling these needs is approxi- mately $3.6 billion. ODOT has annualized the cost of Oklahoma's highway needs, distinguishing among interstate, principal arterial, minor arterial, and collector roads and defining whether they are in rural or municipal areas. The approximate annual cost to supply the necessary roads—75 percent of which are in rural areas—is estimated by ODOT to he $827 million. Fifty-four percent of the required construction and maintenance relates to minor arterial or collector roads. 26 Revenues for Roads Historically, revenues for roads and bridges in Oklahoma come principally from excise taxes on fuel and various fees charged to road users, These collec- tions are apportioned to the ODOT and to state, county, and local governments to support roads in their jurisdictions. OTA, of course, relies upon tolls collected from turnpike users. State Apportionment. In fiscal year 1993, ap- portionments of earmarked revenues to the State Transportation Fund totaled $192.6 million, as shown in Table V-1. In addition, the apportionments for county highways and bridges from fuel excise taxes and motor vehicle fees totaled $169.2 million. These are the two largest categories of state support for the road infrastructure. In addition, $23.6 million was apportioned to the OTA Trust Fund to finance debt service in case other funds were inadequate. How- ever, when funds are not needed for OTA debt service, as was the case in 1993, OTA turns them ever to the ODOT. In fiscal year 1993, an additional $29.0 million from gross production taxes was ap- portioned to counties for highways. Also evident from Table V-1 is that a large portion of the revenues collected from fees on motor vehicles and the excise taxes on fuels goes to state services other than highways. For example, $149.3 million (19.3 percent of the revenues from these two sources) went to sehool districts and $209.8 million (27 pereent) went to the General Revenue Fund. TABLE V-1 Fuel and Vehicle Revenue Total Apportionments Fiscal 1993 (Milllens) Amount Percent State Transportation Fund $192.6 24.9 General Revenue 209.8 27.2 Cities and Towns 17.8 2.3 School Districts 149.3 19.3 County Highways and Bridges 159.2 20.6 Other — Non-Highway 20,1 2.6 Turnpike Authority Trust Fund 23.6 a4 $772.2 100.0 Source: Oklahoma Daparimant of Transporation,
Open PDF at page 28 ↗PDF page 29
Further examination of the revenue sources for highways suggests the possibility of future funding impacts. For example, approximately 74 percent of the State Transportation Fund apportionment came from the 15.92-cents-per-gallon gasoline excise tax during fiseal 1993. An additional 18 percent came from the 18-cent-per-gallon diesel fuel excise tax. A stable fuel consumption tax base means that rev= enues will not grow with income or economic expan- sion; i.e, fuel excise taxes are a very income inelastic tax source, Although, over time, increased gasoline efficiencies will reduce consumption, recently there has been a slight increase in fuel usage. Indeed, the state's Transportation Fund has been more or less stable for several years. Table V-2 compares the 1989 receipts for high- ways by all units of government in Oklahoma with the contiguous states. Most of these states also rely on user fees to support their road infrastructure. Because of Oklahoma's relatively extensive turn- pike system, it is not surprising that this state has a higher percentage of its road expenditures sup- ported by toll revenues than the surrounding states. On the other hand, the neighboring states use the property tax to support their highways; Oklahoma does not. TABLE V-2 Receipts for Roads for All Units of Government: 1989 (Percent) User Falls General Properly Oklahoma 6o.7 55 10.3 og Arkansas: 76.5 0.0 5.0 44 Colorado 59.9 0. BO 9.4 Kansas 39.9 34 ard 9.6 Missouri 68.9 on O6 4.2 New Mexico 63.0 0.0 93 0.9 Texas 55.1 14 16.0 16.4 Source: Fadoral Highway Adminiatratian. Federal Funds. Federal funds are an impor- tant source of revenue for highway construction in Oklahoma, as in any state. Oklahoma selects the routes that will be eligible for federal funds. Oklahoma has not fared well, compared toneigh- boring states, in receiving federal funds for high- ways. For example, the ratio of federal apportion- ment-to-payments for the 1956-1990 period in Okla- homa is very low. That ratio (comparing the road funds coming to Oklahoma with those leaving) is 85, 27 By contrast, the ratio for New Mexico was 1.45, for Colorado 1.42, and for Louisiana 1,40. Under provisions of the Intermodal Surface Transportation Efficiency Act (ISTEA) of 1991,Okla- homa is now able to certify OTA toll revenues as a “soft match” for federal funds. The certification of state funds associated with recent turnpike con- struction has the potential of generating federal funds for Oklahoma's highway system if, in some year, the match from state programs is inadequate. Federal funding could offset otherwise limited rev- enue prospects for the rond system in Oklahoma. The Oklahoma Turnpike Authority. Operat- ing a8 a somewhat independent entity, OTA projects an operating budget for calendar year 1994 of $96.2 million, supported by the tolls from the ten operat- ing turnpikes.2° But only three turnpikes—the Turner, Will Rogers, and H.E. Bailey—account for approximately two-thirds of total OTA revenues, The OTA, which is possibly unique among state turnpike authorities in this regard, can use the total revenues of the entire system to support all of the system's bonded indebtedness. This provision pro- vides OTA the flexibility of initiating new turnpikes based on the tolls of the existing system, However, it is also a source of controversy, because it means that drivers on heavily-used turnpikes support drivers on lesser-used turnpikes. Passenger care account for 58.1 percent, and five-axle trucks for 33.2 percent, of OTA’s budgeted revenues. Meeting the debt service of the three classes of debt requires 64 percent of the Authority's budget, Operating and maintenance expenses re- quire 38 percent of the total expenditures. Intergovernmental Funding of Roads State highways benefit the economies and the general well-being of the counties and local govern- ments where they are located. The state financing of highways within their boundaries is a form of sup- port for the county and local governmental units. As noted, a large proportion of current highway needs are in Oklahoma's rural areas, As pressures mount on the relatively stable highway funds, the level of state support for roads serving regional needs is an area of almost certain intergovernmental contro- veray. Turnpike Construction At the beginning of the 1994 fiseal year, the OTA had $686.7 million in debt outstanding, and, accord- ing to its own assessment, an additional bonding
Open PDF at page 29 ↗PDF page 30
capacity of $600 million to $700 million.?? To sup- port that incremental debt, the tolls on the turnpike aystem would have to approximately double, (Of course, an increase in the rate of turnpike usage would reduce the level of toll increase required to support that level of debt.) At this time, 32 road projects (beyond the ten roads completed or partially completed) are autho- rized by the legislature for construction, Likely to be among the earliest projects undertaken by OTA are (1) rehabilitating the Turner and Will Rogers turn: pikes and expanding them te six lanes to serve eommiuter traffic, (2) continuing the John Kilpatrick turnpike to Interstate 40, (3) connecting the Creek turnpike to the Turner turnpike, and (4) extending the Muskogee turnpike to the southeast. If built, these projects most. likely will require increased tolls because of the added debt service requirements, Because of the price inelasticity of highway use at current toll levels, usage may not decline significantly from such a toll increase, How- ever, tolls will not be raised without controversy. Footnotes ‘James Alm, Michael McKeo, and Mark Skidmore, “Fiseal Pressure, Tax Competition, and the Introduction of State Lotteries,” National Tax Journal, 46(4), 1993, p. 463. *Stillwater NewsPress, “Walters Asks Fast Petition Ruling,” Jannary 11, 1994, p. B-1. 'Charles T. Clotfelter and Philip J, Cook, Selling Hope: State Lotteries in America, Harvard University Press, Cambridge, Massachusetts, 1989, p. 146, ‘[bid., p. 216 5Educational Research Service “State-Run Lotleries: Their Effects on School Funding,” Prepared by David P. Brandon, Arlington, VA, 1993, p. 6, §John L, Mikesell and C. Kurt Zorn, “State Lotteries for Public Revenue,” Public Budgeting and Finance, Spring, 1988, p. 89. 7Oklahoma BEST '93, “A Lottery Initiative Petition Campaign,” Lynn White, ed., Oklahoma City, OK, Sep- tember, 1993. 5John L. Mikesell, and C. Kurt Zorn, “State Lottery Sales: Separating the Influence of Markets and Game Structure,” Growth and Change, 184), Fall, 1987, p. 17. ®Clotfelter and Cook, p. 218, 10[bid, p. 219. 28 ‘bid, p. 219. !2Larry Deboer, “Administrative Costs of State Lot- teries,” National Tax Journal, 38(4), 1985, p. 484. 19Mary O. Borg, Paul M. Mason, and Stephen L. Shapiro, “The Cross Effects of Lottery Taxes on Alterna- tive State Tax Revenue,” Prblie Finance Quarterly, 21(2), April, 1993, p. 133, MQ, David Gulley and Frank A. Scott, Jr., “Lottery Effects on Pari-Mutuel Tax Revenues,” National Tax Journal, 42(1), 1989, p. 91. 15Borg, et al., 1993. p. 183, 16Clotfelter and Cook, p, 232. "i[bid, p. 226, I8Philip L. Hersch and Gerald 5. McDougall, “Do Peaple Put Their Money Where Their Votes Are? The Case of Lottery Tickets,” Southern Economie Journal, 56(1), duly, 1989, p. 36. 19Mary O. Borg and Paul M. Mason, “The Budgetary Incidence of a Lottery to Support Education,” National Tax Journal, 4101), March, 1988, p. 81. 20CIotfelter and Cook, p. 228. 21 Rducational Research Service, p. 6. 22Qklahoma State Regonts for Higher Education, Leader, &(1), p. 2. *Stbid, p. 2. “This is by no means a complete list of the determi- nants of the demand for acollege education, Itdoes include many of the principal factors which would tend to offset the adverse effect of a tuition increase on enrollment. “5This is the consensus estimate deduced by Larry Leslie and Paul Brinkman from their thorough review of the literature in “Student Price Response in Higher Edu- cation,” Journal of Higher Education, 1987, 68(2), pp, 1B1= 20d, 26Robert Campbell and Burry Siegel, “The Demand for Higher Education in the United States, 1919-1964," American Economie Review, 1967, 57(3), pp. 482-94. 271),S, Department of Education, Prajections of Edee- cation Statistics fo 2002, 1991, Washington, D.C. U.S. Government Printing Office. 24*°Poor" is defined as having income below the pov- erty line, “near-poor” as having income between the pov: erty line and 150 percent of the poverty line. 2Oklahoma Department of ‘Transportation, Needs Study and Sufficiency Rating Report, 1993 Vol. I, p. 1 Oklahoma Turnpike Authority, Annual Budget, 1994, p. 2. ®Ubid. 34Oklahoma Turnpike Authority, Fiianeial Report, March 6, 1993, p. 611-12
Open PDF at page 30 ↗PDF page 31
Previous Studies 1992 Oklahoma’s Special Programs for Economic Development Oklahoma Tax Expenditures for Economic Development: Post HB 1444 Marketing and Awareness of State Financial Assistance Programs The 1990 Clean Air Act Amendments and Their Impact on Oklahoma 1991 State Government Provision of Business Finance in Oklahoma HB 1017: The Education Reform Act of 1990 Oklahoma's Corporate International Trade Opportunities in Eastern Europe Choice: The Next Educational Reform Changes in Oklahoma's Tax Base in the 1980s: Implication for Economic Development The Oklahoma Superconducting Super Collider Proposal Effort: Lessons Learned Medical Care for the Uninsured: Approaches to State Policy The Cotton Industry in Oklahoma: Current Status and Future Prospects 1990 Oklahoma Constitutional Revision 1988-1989 State Debt Management and Budgeting for Capital Needs in Oklahoma The European Economic Community in 1992: Some Influences on the USA and Oklahoma Economies Child Care: What Role for State Government? Measures of Diversification Agricultural Product Processing in Oklahoma Public Policies Affecting the Oklahoma Coal Mining Industry The First Session of the 42nd Oklahoma Legislature: Highlights and Economic Development Initiatives 1989 Target Industry Analysis Migration of New College Freshmen in Oklahoma Resources for Oklahoma Public Education: Needs and Sources State Policy Toward Indian Tribes and Economic Development in Oklahoma Impact of Tourism and Recreation on Oklahoma State Policy for the Development of the Warehousing and Distribution Industry in Oklahoma 1988 Tax Exempt Bond Financing — A New Era for Oklahoma Trust Authorities Impediments to Growth of Small Manufacturers in Oklahoma: Another Perspective Constitutional Reform and Economic Development in Oklahoma The Legislative Development Efforts and Economic Diversification College Student Migration and State Economic Growth Improving Oklahoma Higher Education: The Unfinished Agenda Banking ~ An Industry in Crisis The State Response Retailing, Public Policy, and Economic Growth Oklahoma’s 41st Legislature: A Review and Analysis of the First Session 1986 Impediments to Locating Manufacturing Activities in Oklahoma: An Update The Status of the Oil and Gas Sector Systematic Thinking for State Tax Reform Local Infrastructures in Oklahoma and Economic Development The Oklahoma Ethics Commission: Toward Greater Confidence in the Public Sector Higher Education and Economic Growth: The Quality Dimension Tort Reform and Insurance Rates Deregulation of the Trucking Industry: Current Issues
Open PDF at page 31 ↗PDF page 32
1985 Oklahoma State Government Reform in 1985 State Government Responses to Changing Natural Gas Markets Right-to-Work in Oklahoma Legislative Initiatives to Increase the Supply of Venture Capital in Oklahoma New Tax Initiatives for Economic Development Industrial Hazardous Waste Policy in Oklahoma Workers’ Compensation Legislation: An Introductory Evaluation Education and Economic Development in Oklahoma: Recent Initiatives 1984 Economic Development Implications of Governmental Reform The Council on Science and Technology State Financing of Higher Education: How Well is Oklahoma Doing? Oklahoma’s Constitution and Economic Development Policies: Are they Compatible? Renewed Local Tax Effort and the Continuing Property Tax Controversy Agriculture and Oklahoma Economic Growth State Financing of Local Water Projects Revisited The Job Training Partnership Act in Oklahoma 1983 State Response to Declining Revenue Growth The Human Services Budget: Problems and Issues State Policies Affecting Local Government Oklahoma Enterprise Zone Act: An Empty Shell Natural Gas Market Ordering Initiatives The Creation of a New Industry: Parimutuel Betting State Control of Bank Structure in Oklahoma The Interest in High Technology and Economic Growth 1982 Workers’ Compensation Hazardous Waste Land Commission Rail Abandonment and the Oklahoma Program to Restore Service The Prospects for Nuclear Power inOklahoma: The Black Fox Decision State Government Financing of Water Resource Development in Oklahoma Oklahoma State Merit System The Impact of the New Federalism Unfunded Liabilities in State and Local Government Pension Programs Toward a Savings Account for Oklahoma State Government. Property Tax Equalization
Open PDF at page 32 ↗PDF page 33
STATE POLICY AND ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT IN OKLAHOMA: 1994 STATE GOVERNMENT FINANCE IN OKLAHOMA AFTER SQ 640 A REPORT TO OKLAHOMA 2000, INC, by Dr, Robert C, Dauffenbach Dr. Donald A. Murry Director of the Center for Economics and Professor of Economics Management Research University of Oklahoma University of Oklahoma Dr, Kent W. Olson Dr, Mary Gade Professor of Economics Associate Professor of Economics Oklahoma State University Oklahoma State University Dr. Larkin Warner Dr. Alexander Holmes Regents Professor Regents Professor of Economics Oklahoma State University University of Oklahoma
Open PDF at page 33 ↗PDF page 34
OKLAHOMA 2000, INC. KLAHOMA 2000, INC., affiliated with the Oklahoma State Chamber of Commeree and Industry, is a nonpartisan, nonprofit corporation ereated to perform and promote research regard- ing the role of industry in the civic, sociological and cultural betterment of the citizens of the State of Oklahoma, OKLAHOMA 2000, INC. makes the results of its studies available to members of vari- ous State and Federal government agencies, legis= lators and the general public. OFFICERS JAMES G. HARLOW, JR. Chairman J.D. SCOTT Viee Chairman DONALD A. MURRY President LARKIN WARNER Vice President RICHARD P, RUSH Secretary JUDITH EVANS Program Coordinator
Open PDF at page 34 ↗